Kind of like putting "foot in mouth" syndrome Joe? Why Joe...WHY did you order testing to stop in 2009?

Another lie from the Trump Media Mouthpiece... but but Obama...

Trying to compare apples and oranges, or in this case two DIFFERENT diseases.


Deflecting attention from the rise in COVID-19 cases, President Donald Trump has repeatedly said the Obama administration “stopped testing” during the H1N1 pandemic. He’s correct that individual reporting was halted after a few months, but some testing did continue — and the two viruses are very different, making the comparison misleading.

Whereas pandemic H1N1 influenza was no worse than the seasonal flu, and testing did not play much of a role in controlling the spread of the virus, COVID-19 is far more deadly, and testing is critical for contact tracing and isolation.

The decision (to stop testing) followed the World Health Organization’s July 16 announcement that it would no longer issue global reports on the number of confirmed H1N1 cases, given the difficulty of testing such a large number of cases, and the fact that such counts were “no longer essential in such countries for monitoring either the level or nature of the risk posed by the pandemic virus or to guide implementation of the most appropriate response measures.”

The CDC would go on to report estimates of the number of H1N1 cases, hospitalizations and deaths in the U.S. throughout the pandemic, specifically trying to use statistical methods to account for underreporting.

Dr. Nicole Lurie, a physician and assistant secretary for preparedness and response during the H1N1 pandemic, told us the comparison to COVID-19 is “really misleading.”

“The role of testing in those two diseases is terribly different,” she said in a phone interview. “In flu, the major reason that they tested people at the beginning of the epidemic was so that you would know when influenza arrived in different communities.”

But once the virus had arrived and established itself, she said, doctors could “make a pretty good presumption” that people with flu-like symptoms had flu.

“Individual testing was no longer needed because it was just wasteful and provided no additional information,” said Lurie, who is now a strategic advisor to the CEO of the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations, a nongovernmental organization dedicated to developing vaccines to stop epidemics, including COVID-19.

Dr. Amesh Adalja, a senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins University Center for Health Security, also told us that testing for H1N1 was not particularly valuable because the virus was so prevalent, and there was a readily available therapy — Tamiflu and other similar antivirals, which also work on seasonal flu.

“The testing was onerous,” he said, noting that a confirmatory diagnostic test could take days to come back with results. “The rapid tests were not very accurate, and we had an antiviral, and we didn’t want people to refrain from giving them an antiviral because they were waiting for a test or the test result was negative.”

There are no FDA-approved drugs to treat or prevent COVID-19, although research suggests the investigational drug remdesivir may shorten the time to recovery and the steroid medication dexamethasone may improve survival of critically ill patients.

The situation with COVID-19, Lurie said, is very different, because testing is still critical for understanding where the coronavirus is spreading and because it’s an essential public health tool for controlling the virus.
Your link confirms Barry halted testing.

:oops8:


Yes, but it provides the context you lack in your claim. In other words - it was no big deal to stop testing at the federal level, WHO recommended the same, and the reasons are listed. If you can't comprehend that, then admit you're just a hack.

OH yea... "WHO" is epitome of accuracy!
WHO admits error in assessment of deadly coronavirus risk
The World Health Organization said the global risk from the deadly coronavirus was high, after incorrectly rating the global risk as “moderate” last week.
World Health Organization director general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus was effusive in his praise of the country's response to the coronavirus crisis.
"We appreciate the seriousness with which China is taking this outbreak, especially the commitment from top leadership, and the transparency they have demonstrated," Tedros said, in comments that would be repeatedly quoted in China's state media for weeks.

Sorry but your use of WHO shows your communist sympathies and your totally inane ability to comprehend distinctions.
I bet YOU see NO problem with a country that has tested 90,410,000 with ONLY 84,668 cases, of which only 4,634 died...out of a population of 1,439,323,776... and you find WHO believes China?
WHO is run by the Chicoms. Anyone who listens to them is an idiot.

Well, we can disagree on that.
You never agree with facts.
 
Biden specifically called for the White House to "immediately resume operating federally-managed community-based testing around the country and establish multiple sites in Arizona." And, in recent weeks, Biden has demanded that Trump "speed up the testing" nationwide, saying Trump has been "putting politics ahead of the safety and economic well-being of the American people."

However, during the 2009 swine flu pandemic, the Obama administration suddenly told states to shut down their testing, without providing much in the way of explanation. And, Biden's top advisor at the time has acknowledged that the Obama administration didn't do "anything right" to combat that pandemic, before walking back those comments.

View attachment 373002
Coronavirus started in 2019.

H1N1deaths: 12,000
Trump's virus Deaths: 150,000 and counting.
That we know there were 12,000 deaths in 2009 Under Obama...
But at the same time this was the number of Americans dying from the flu the year before 2019...
CDC estimates that the burden of illness during the 2018–2019 season included an estimated 35.5 million people getting sick with influenza, 16.5 million people going to a health care provider for their illness, 490,600 hospitalizations, and 34,200 deaths from influenza

So how many of the so-called COVID-19 deaths in 2020 are actually influenza deaths???

Likely none. They would have been tested for Covid and the two illness's show up quite differently in how the body is affected.
If they are dead they are most likely NOT tested for COVID... but some deaths are being counted as COVID.
This Issues & Insights editorial does a good job of bringing together some of the relevant data. But let’s start with something they didn’t mention: this acknowledgement by the Director of the Illinois Department of Public Health:
"I just want to be clear in terms of the definition of people dying of COVID. So, the case definition is very simplistic.
It means that at the time of death it was a COVID-positive diagnosis.
So that means if you were in hospice and had already been given, you know, a few weeks to live and then you were also found to have COVID, that would be counted as a COVID death.
It means that if, technically, even if you died of a clear alternate cause but you had COVID at the same time it’s still listed as a COVID death.
So, everyone that’s listed as a COVID death doesn’t mean that that was the cause of the death, but they had COVID at the time of death."
That certainly is clarifying. We also know that some doctors have complained about being pressured to list COVID-19 as a cause of death, perhaps because the CARES Act provides a 20% Medicare bonus for COVID patients. And most recorded COVID-19 fatalities are elderly people with one or more co-morbidities.
This Issues & Insights editorial does a good job of bringing together some of the relevant data. But let’s start with something they didn’t mention: this acknowledgement by the Director of the Illinois Department of Public Health:

 
God you people are desperate to make Drumpf look more competent when he has completely fucked up our response to Covid-19.

But keep digging, it's amusing to watch you work.
NOT desperate when we have PROOF that Trump is far far better than Biden or Obama.
YOU tell me if you'd be happy with these policies that Obama wanted to put into place...that Trump actually has been working to reverse!

And remember Obama told us he was a "God" so why didn't "God" stop H1N1 or step in a stop COVID?
Obamaantibus011320.png
 

Forum List

Back
Top