Judge Who Ordered Admin to “resettle” 12,000 Refugees Tucks Tail After 9th Circuit Corrects Him...Again

[Hollie]

Boom. Folks might remember the article of the leftist judge who ordered President Trump to immediately “resettle” 12,000 migrants in American communities.

Federal judge orders Trump admin to immediately resettle 12K migrants

U.S. District Judge Jamal Whitehead ordered the Trump administration to immediately resettle some 12,000 refugees into the U.S. under a court order.

www.foxnews.com

Not so fast as the the 9th circuit has weighed in and stoppped the nonsense.

Judge Who Ordered Admin to Process 12,000 Refugees Tucks Tail After 9th Circuit Corrects Him...Again

redstate.com

 

[jwoodie]

Why aren't local judges' orders limited to their own jurisdictions?

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Why aren't local judges' orders limited to their own jurisdictions?

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments on that today!

 

[Seymour Flops]

Why aren't local judges' orders limited to their own jurisdictions?

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments on that today!

I hope they rule the right way.

Overruling the president it's something that will happen under our separation of powers but it should be rare and only happen after lot of deliberation and cases adjudicated up to the highest court in the land.

Nobody regardless of party, position or policy could run the executive for the nation if they have to be concerned about being, constantly "corrected" by more than eight hundred federal judges.

 

[Hollie]

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments on that today!

Weren’t those oral arguments in connection with birthright citizenship?

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

I hope they rule the right way.

Overruling the president it's something that will happen under our separation of powers but it should be rare and only happen after lot of deliberation and cases adjudicated up to the highest court in the land.

Nobody regardless of party, position or policy could run the executive for the nation if they have to be concerned about being, constantly "corrected" by more than eight hundred federal judges.

I just watched a report on Fox News indicating that Kagan's questions indicated she didn't think the district courts could rule nationwide.

 

[Admiral Rockwell Tory]

Weren’t those oral arguments in connection with birthright citizenship?

Same thing. The district judges ordered Trump to stop imposing limits on citizenship, as they likely should IMHO. There was a lot of discussion involving class of those filing suit. If it was limited in scope, so should the ruling.

I predict SCOTUS will rule for the 14th and recommend changing the Constitution if so warranted, but that just MHO. I don't think Trump can overrule precedent with an EO.

I think SCOTUS will also restrict judges from issuing nationwide rulings because they do not have the power. They should rule, stay it and appeal it up to SCOTUS for a final ruling.

 

[EvilEyeFleegle]

Weren’t those oral arguments in connection with birthright citizenship?

No..actually the arguments were about District courts issuing nationwide rulings.
If they can, when they can and what sort of mechanism could take their place.

 

[EvilEyeFleegle]

I just watched a report on Fox News indicating that Kagan's questions indicated she didn't think the district courts could rule nationwide.

I listened to all 2 hours of argument. I did not get that impression.
I got the impression that the court wanted to limit the circumstances that a ruling could be applied nation-wide..and fast-track emergent issues straight to them.
The concern expressed by a number of Justices was that if you limited district court ruling to the District..or to the class represented--that the Executive Branch would simply exempt that class or defendant...and continue on with their criminal behavior.

Which is, of course, exactly what Trump is doing and will continue do~