Judge rules deportation was “an illegal act”

[Crepitus]

The dude that was deported. They had a hearing on it. Judge agreed he was a MS 13 member. He appealed and didn't contest that he was a MS 13 member. When it went back down, for some reason the judge said he was deportable, but don't deport him. Don't know why. I haven't seen that order.

That is not true. They did n;t order deportation.

 

[Hollie]

That is not true. They did n;t order deportation.

Coconut tree groupie, please.

Your hero had an existing deportation order.

 

[Rawley]

That is not true.

yup 100% true

They did n;t order deportation.

Let me say it again, slowly this time. He ruled he was deportable based on being part of MS-13. Then he ordered witholding of the deportation.

 

[konradv]

A federal judge doesn't have the ability to force El Salvador to deport up one of their own citizens.

Judge Xinis has zero authority over what Presidente Bukele does.

Although if Garcia is indeed innocent, his own people in his own country can make an appeal to their own court system.

Trump can get El Salvador to do whatever he wants. If anything happens to the man, it’s on his head.

 

[Crepitus]

yup 100% true

Let me say it again, slowly this time. He ruled he was deportable based on being part of MS-13. Then he ordered witholding of the deportation.

So deportation was not ordered. like I said.

 

[konradv]

They are in the country illegally, their due process is limited to what we say it is.

No it isn’t; it’s defined by the Constitution and up to judges to tell us where the limits are.

 

[Polishprince]

Trump can get El Salvador to do whatever he wants. If anything happens to the man, it’s on his head.

All President Trump wants from El Salvador is to do the right thing.

If Garcia is innocent, release him into the El Salvadorean population.

If he's an ordinary criminal, transfer him from CECOT to an ordinary penitentiary in El Salvador.

If he's the worst of the worst, keep him where he's at.

Sending this illegal back to America isn't one of the options, not as if El Salvador want to go to that expense anyhow. They are a poor country.

 

[j-mac]

The Constitution is not a suicide pact.

 

[konradv]

All President Trump wants from El Salvador is to do the right thing.

If Garcia is innocent, release him into the El Salvadorean population.

If he's an ordinary criminal, transfer him from CECOT to an ordinary penitentiary in El Salvador.

If he's the worst of the worst, keep him where he's at.

Sending this illegal back to America isn't one of the options, not as if El Salvador want to go to that expense anyhow. They are a poor country.

He has legal status and a family here. He has nothing in El Salvador. Is cruelty the point?

 

[Rawley]

So deportation was not ordered. like I said.

Third time, even more slowly. The judge ruled he was deportable because he was a member of MS13. The dude never challenged that ruling.

 

[LeftofLeft]

Judges care about violations of law, including immigration laws pertaining to deportation like the one the regime broke.

What law was broken? These are illegal immigrants that broke more laws with violent crimes.

 

[j-mac]

No it isn’t; it’s defined by the Constitution and up to judges to tell us where the limits are.

Watch and see...

 

[OhPleaseJustQuit]

He has legal status and a family here. He has nothing in El Salvador. Is cruelty the point?

.

Prove it.



.

 

[justoffal]

He is ordering the return of a man who illegally detained. El Salvador must return him. The State Department fucked up.

El Salvador doesn't have to do shit.

 

[sartre play]

None of us has enough accurate information too make much of a decision about the ICE STUFF.
Everything is being treated as a political situation,
And there is not much want to know anything else.

 

[Rogue AI]

The administration made a clerical error. That is not illegal nor is the administration forced to waste countless tax dollars to assuage some liberal whiny judge's inability to comprehend the Constitutional limits of the judiciary.

 

[DigitalDrifter]

Dimocrats love gang members, and they want them living next door to them, and in fact want to have Sunday afternoon barbeques with them. Let's help them get what they want.

 

[Polishprince]

Garcia was probably welcomed as a hero by the MS13 cellies at CECOT. He knows their handshakes and other rituals.

 

[OKTexas]

STAY ON TOPIC FOLKS, 45 OFF TOPIC POSTS DELETED, THREAD BANS COMES NEXT

 

[Seymour Flops]

Now we're getting somewhere.

You think so?

I'll wager a week off the board for me against two days off the board for you that Trump does not bring Kilmar Abrego Garcia back to the U.S. by Monday.