It is an observable fact that there is no Palestinian leader that can credibly offer peace to Israel. I understand that that fact undermines your proposals, but denying it only makes you look foolish.
Since 1948 they have endlessly persecuted the Palestinian people - right down to denying them their own homeland - instead stuffing, herding them into economic unsustainable Ghettos called Gaza and West-bank. Doing exactly what they had done before from 1150 BC onward, with the Canaanite, Hyksos, Hittites, etc. who had lived in this area hundreds and thousands of years before. Not to mention constantly attacking/bombing their neighboring, sovereign nations since 1980.
Hebrews are the only group of people known to me, that in general don't integrate/mix with other ethnicities, thus always persistently segregating themselves from others, and wanting to be "special" and having their own cake baked.
Even though they were a nobody - they even managed to aggravate Rome to such an extend that they were wiped out.
You got anymore questions? - read up on your self-written and Faked History book - the Bible - off course it wasn't the Israelite's, it's their God that told them to do so - right? until today!!
Therefore the real question you need to ask yourself is; why does antisemitism exist throughout the entire world?
Israel will get what it has now in Judea and Samaria in Gaza once it installs the same kind of military and security presence it now has in Judea and Samaria, which is far more manageable than what is has now in Gaza and is probably the best Israel can hope for for the foreseeable future. Adding five million impoverished, hostile Arabs to the Israeli population would destroy Israel.
Leaving Palestinian territories as formally separated (or even 'independent') entities doesn't resolve the issue. The Palestinian question, 'Two states solution' and similar themes will be surfacing here and there in such scenario.
Anyway, the time will show. I am not sure in capabilities of the Israeli state now, especially its military and security branches. Yesterday, it was seemed as a solid rock. Now, not so sure.
I can't help but admit the 'right' timing of this attack. Virtually on the eve of Saudi-Israeli 'peace' agreement. That could have reshuffled the Middle East. Now, it seems more vague.
Putin's reason for moving Russian troops into Crimea, Donbas/Luhansk underlies the exact same principle as Israel occupying e.g. GAZA. -
SAVE/Protect RUSSIAN LIVES !!! and finally annex land which they believe to belong to them anyway. Which YOU fully support, when it comes to screwing Palestinians and occupying/annexing Gaza and the West-Bank.
Read up your own garbage to understand as to how stupid and ignorant and bigoted YOU are indeed. Goes basically for all your posts here on USMB.
Show me a single protocol between elected Palestinian-Arab authorities and Zionists/Hebrews council headed by Ben Gurion, regarding a discussion before 1948. You dimwit.
The territory that was to become the Jewish National Home was named Palestine by the Ottomans in 1915 without consulting with (or even alerting) the indigenous Palestinian population. The British later adopted this name in 1920, after obtaining a mandate from the prior Ottoman government in 1922 to govern Palestine .
In 1947, United Nations Special Committee on Palestine (UNSCOP) proposed a partition plan to resolve the Arab–Jewish conflict by partitioning Palestine into two states and letting the Palestinians and Jews who immigrated there vote to determine which state they would join. The plan passed in the General Assembly with a two-thirds majority but was opposed, mainly by Arabs. The plan was formally accepted by Britain as the governing authority in Palestine, with no input from any Palestinian Arabs.Many of them had advocated for a single state in which Jews and Arab Palestinians would have equal rights.
The following day, Jerusalem was captured by the Arab Legion and Violence broken out between Jews and Arabs in various parts of Palestine. The next day, the British government announced its decision to terminate its mandate in Palestine. The State of Israel was proclaimed, an independent Jewish state with its capital in Jerusalem. By the end of the month most Palestinian Arab areas had been occupied by Israel.
Putin's reason for moving Russian troops into Crimea, Donbas/Luhansk underlies the exact same principle as Israel occupying e.g. GAZA. -
SAVE/Protect RUSSIAN LIVES !!! and finally annex land which they believe to belong to them anyway. Which YOU fully support, when it comes to screwing Palestinians and occupying/annexing Gaza and the West-Bank.
Leaving Palestinian territories as formally separated (or even 'independent') entities doesn't resolve the issue. The Palestinian question, 'Two states solution' and similar themes will be surfacing here and there in such scenario.
Anyway, the time will show. I am not sure in capabilities of the Israeli state now, especially its military and security branches. Yesterday, it was seemed as a solid rock. Now, not so sure.
I can't help but admit the 'right' timing of this attack. Virtually on the eve of Saudi-Israeli 'peace' agreement. That could have reshuffled the Middle East. Now, it seems more vague.
At this point in time, imo, the Palestinian problem and the Israeli problem are two separate issues. The Palestinians' problem is that they don't have a coherent leadership, and nothing Israel does will help them get one.
The Israeli problem is much simpler and easier to solve: the Israeli government must decide how to best protect its people from Palestinian terrorists.
If I understand you correctly, then I agree that Iran and the Gaza terrorists conspired to launch this war to prevent or at least delay the normalization of relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia.
I had read your post before, and it does not address the current situation in Israel and Gaza. For Israel, the only relevant question is whether the government can best protect its citizens by continuing to defend the border with Gaza of by reoccupying Gaza and eliminating the terrorists.
Nonsense talker - by far the most wars in Europe since the 12th century amongst nations were conducted on behalf of England, France, Spain, Russia, Sweden and the Ottomans. Some of them stretching for hundreds of years of continued wars.
Peace came to Europe due to the EU and NATO. replacing military conducted expansion, via money and politics.
The same principle applies to the Israeli/Palestinian issue. The initial plan to create a State of Israel and Palestine - both based on an idiotic patchwork of separated and disconnected territories - impossible to guarantee an economic survival as a nation. The Zionists naturally realized this, and took matters (land-allocations) into their own hands - before the UN mandate expired.
Thus creating a connected Israel territory that would allow for an economy to support a population and state. For the Palestinians this was never done nor achieved - a Gaza or a West-bank - simply doesn't work to support an economy and thus creating a peaceful nation.
The only way to solve this dilemma - aside from killing each other for the next 100 years - would be to divide the former Palestine in it's e.g. horizontal width - then choosing which side gets the Northern and Southern part
Please tell us who gets to keep the " entire Jerusalem entity?" If your capable, , which I doubt, do some research . Olmert proposed to Abbas that Jerusalem be declared a INTERNATIONAL CITY FOR EVERYONE and it was REJECTED
It is an observable fact that there is no Palestinian leader that can credibly offer peace to Israel. I understand that that fact undermines your proposals, but denying it only makes you look foolish.
Right, foolish again only being YOU - because you got no idea about the composition of the present Palestinian authorities. nor the name of the present Prime Minister.
Neither are you familiar with the HAMAS political setup - nor any other Palestinian authority nor any Arab states that are in support for the Palestinians and by far their largest financial contributors.
And as long as Israel beholds it most righting government in it's history since 1949 - who are the Palestinians supposed to talk to???
It is absolutely no coincidence that the present Hamas insurgency occurred during the "disputed reign" of Netanyahu - about which "SUPPOSEDLY" the IDF and MOSSAD - "were taken by utter surprise"
Right, foolish again only being YOU - because you got no idea about the composition of the present Palestinian authorities. nor the name of the present Prime Minister.
Neither are you familiar with the HAMAS political setup - nor any other Palestinian authority nor any Arab states that are in support for the Palestinians and by far their largest financial contributors.
And as long as Israel beholds it most righting government in it's history since 1949 - who are the Palestinians supposed to talk to???
It is absolutely no coincidence that the present Hamas insurgency occurred during the "disputed reign" of Netanyahu - about which "SUPPOSEDLY" the IDF and MOSSAD - "were taken by utter surprise"
I had read your post before, and it does not address the current situation in Israel and Gaza. For Israel, the only relevant question is whether the government can best protect its citizens by continuing to defend the border with Gaza of by reoccupying Gaza and eliminating the terrorists.
Even a nitwit like you should know as to what Israel aka Netanyahu is going to do.
The issue is about how to solve this Palestinian/Israeli conflict peacefully - and killing off Palestinians as in the previous ratio e.g. 1100 Palestinians dead and 13 Israelis - certainly wont solve this.
Even a nitwit like you should know as to what Israel aka Netanyahu is going to do.
The issue is about how to solve this Palestinian/Israeli conflict peacefully - and killing off Palestinians as in the previous ratio e.g. 1100 Palestinians dead and 13 Israelis - certainly wont solve this.
There is no way to solve the conflict, peacefully or otherwise, so the only relevant question for Israel is how best to protect its citizens from Gaza terrorists, and recent experience suggests the best way is to reoccupy Gaza and eliminate the terrorists.
If you can't name a Palestinian leader who can credibly offer peace to Israel, you have nothing relevant to say about any possible diplomatic solution.
Kiddo - I stated, that your ignorant statement - reflects to 100% Putin's mindset. Now learn to live with your own ignorance and stop derailing this thread.