Israel is here to stay

[Coyote]

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

 

[montelatici]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

 

[Coyote]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

 

[Coyote]

Of course...let's assume, for one bizarre moment - they aren't "natives" of Israel (once you've sorted them out) - WHERE are you going to send what will amount to millions of people? Europe is a continent - a continent I might add, where almost successful attempts were made to eradicate them - composed of many countries.

What's your plan here?

 

[Boston1]

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan, and of course not all would qualify for repatriation, some would of course maintain their protected person status and be allowed to stay.

 

[Coyote]

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over some period of time.

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

Ok - I mixed up who was expelling whom (is that grammatically correct)? We have one side calling for the expulsion of 8 million Israeli's and the other side calling for the expulsion of 4 million Palestinians.

That's a lot of homeless people milling around.

 

[Boston1]

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over some period of time.

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

Ok - I mixed up who was expelling whom (is that grammatically correct)? We have one side calling for the expulsion of 8 million Israeli's and the other side calling for the expulsion of 4 million Palestinians.

That's a lot of homeless people milling around.

Sounded good to me ;--)

My english isn't very good anyway so yeah. Do go on ;--)

Oh and no, my plan, would take them one Arab Muslim terrorist enclave at a time, and then bulldoze the illegal structures within each given area once all who were going to willingly come out had done so; but siege warfare has always been highly effective.

I'm just suggesting that the legal process of segregating combatants from noncombatants is long overdue

A lot of the concrete walls are already in place so I'd estimate maybe a five year turn around on the total process. So no, not all milling around at once

 

[montelatici]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.

 

[Coyote]

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over some period of time.

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

Ok - I mixed up who was expelling whom (is that grammatically correct)? We have one side calling for the expulsion of 8 million Israeli's and the other side calling for the expulsion of 4 million Palestinians.

That's a lot of homeless people milling around.

Sounded good to me ;--)

My english isn't very good anyway so yeah. Do go on ;--)

Oh and no, my plan, would take them one Arab Muslim terrorist enclave at a time, and then bulldoze the illegal structures within each given area once all who were going to willingly come out had done so; but siege warfare has always been highly effective.

I'm just suggesting that the legal process of segregating combatants from noncombatants is long overdue

Have you ever listened to George Carlin...and his idea for prisons?

There are some interesting ideas there....

 

[Coyote]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.

Of course they aren't going anywhere - not without a humanitarian nightmare.

But here is a serious question. If demographics "will rule the day" - would you stand by and allow demographics to destroy an entire people?

 

[Boston1]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.

Not sure what you are blithering on about or even who you are talking to at this point but if I had my way I'd set you up with a nice ham sandwitch, robe and slippers too await your turn at the determination center. Might even offer your pimply old wrinkled ass an umbrella so you don't sunburn while you wait your turn.

The Israeli's just need to work up the fortitude to end this.

 

[Coyote]

While they're working on fortitude...can I have the ham sandwitch?

 

[Boston1]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.

Of course they aren't going anywhere - not without a humanitarian nightmare.

But here is a serious question. If demographics "will rule the day" - would you stand by and allow demographics to destroy an entire people?

Not a nightmare at all, they'd just be going home where they belonged. They can get their UN welfare somewhere else, clearly they are not happy in Israel, so out they go.

 

[Coyote]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.

Of course they aren't going anywhere - not without a humanitarian nightmare.

But here is a serious question. If demographics "will rule the day" - would you stand by and allow demographics to destroy an entire people?

Not a nightmare at all, they'd just be going home where they belonged. They can get their UN welfare somewhere else, clearly they are not happy in Israel, so out they go.

8 million Israeli's are going to have a tough time figuring out where "they belonged'.

 

[USAF 2023]

The terrorist state of Israel is eventually gonna fall.......and fall hard. ......

The terrorist " Palestinian State" is going to fall and fall hard..... Forgot; It doesn't exist.

 

[Boston1]

While they're working on fortitude...can I have the ham sandwitch?

You want fries with that ? And here's our beer menu

 

[montelatici]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

It amazes me, but the people that propose expelling millions of other people - Palestinians...Israeli's - seem to think they can just take them to a border somewhere and dump them. Or...even better - deport them. But where the hell do you deport someone who's nationality is right where they are? There is never a coherent answer to that.

8 million Israeli's
4 million Palestinians
add that to the millions of Syrians, Iraqi's and Libyans milling around...

Yes, we have some brilliant lights hidden under the bushels....but the batteries died.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.

Of course they aren't going anywhere - not without a humanitarian nightmare.

But here is a serious question. If demographics "will rule the day" - would you stand by and allow demographics to destroy an entire people?

The ruling whites in South Africa were not destroyed when all the non-whites were enfranchised.

 

[Coyote]

While they're working on fortitude...can I have the ham sandwitch?

You want fries with that ? And here's our beer menu

YESSSSS! Supersize them please

 

[Boston1]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.

Of course they aren't going anywhere - not without a humanitarian nightmare.

But here is a serious question. If demographics "will rule the day" - would you stand by and allow demographics to destroy an entire people?

Not a nightmare at all, they'd just be going home where they belonged. They can get their UN welfare somewhere else, clearly they are not happy in Israel, so out they go.

8 million Israeli's are going to have a tough time figuring out where "they belonged'.

Again not Israel's problem

Where in the Geneva Conventions does it say its Israel's problem to figure out where they end up ?

 

[Coyote]

Repatriation of combatants means returning invading POWs to their homeland. The Palestinians are the natives of Palestine, the invaders were from Jews from Europe. Repatriating the Palestinians that were expelled from their homes would mean returning them to what is now Israel.

Not. Quite. Accurate.

Israeli citizens are (imagine that!!!!) - natives of Israel.

Its called repatriation when its in relation to a wartime event. And its perfectly legal.

And its no Israel's problem where they go.

I'm not sure why some people get all in a tizzy at the suggestion that the combatants be treated in the exact manor specified in international law.

Its the only thing thats going to lead to peace in this region.

Israel needs to toughen up some

So how are you going to "repatriate" 8 million Israeli's?

Yikes are you ever confused.

I'd estimate perhaps 50% to 75% of the present Arab Muslim people under Israel jurisdiction might be classified as combatants.

I'd further estimate that their repatriation would be spread out over about five years based on the numbers below .

Starting with the largest of the terrorist enclaves, just cut off aid and force them to come out with their hand up in their birthday suits to the determination center where they get a PBJ a robe and some flip flops ;--) Oh and an interview.

Really it doesn't have to be violent at all.

The UN has procedures outlined for admittance to refugee camps that also requires a determination process. They are not allowed to offer aid to combatants.

Except in Israel that is ;--)

Not sure where you thought it would be 8 million people. Pretty sure only about 1.5 million Arabs total are even in Israel.

Even if you process say 1000 a day it would still take about 5 years to vet every Arab Muslim individually.

Plenty of time for the to integrate into say Gaza society, although I'm sure some would chose to go to Jordan.

You've worked yourself up into a lather based on a false premise. The Palestinians aren't going anywhere, neither are the Jews. Demographics will rule the day and eventually the non-Jewish majority in the territory currently ruled by Jews will assume power. It is what happens historically.

Of course they aren't going anywhere - not without a humanitarian nightmare.

But here is a serious question. If demographics "will rule the day" - would you stand by and allow demographics to destroy an entire people?

The ruling whites in South Africa were not destroyed when all the non-whites were enfranchised.

There is a big difference between South Africa and the Middle East - a difference in cultures, in history, and in the nature of the conflict. Add to that that the reason the ruling whites did not get destroyed was becuase Nelson Mandella implimented a truth and reconciliation plan. Much as I am a pro-palestinian, they lack a figure that can unite them and unite the Israeli's into such a plan. Neither do the Israeli's have such a figure. Without that, how will you transform hate into reconciliation?

Note: the Middle East does not have any good examples to draw from.