Is it Possible for Israel and Palestine to Peacefully Coexist?

jwoodie

Platinum Member
Aug 15, 2012
21,067
10,118
940
The only thing that the Israelis and the Palestinians seem to agree on is that their opposites should not exist as sovereign countries. Is this an immutable law of religious beliefs, or is it a stubborn bargaining position that both sides have taken? Will it ultimately take the removal of millions of Israelis or Palestinians from the area to resolve this conflict?

The idea of resettling local populations to other areas has been around (and practiced) for thousands of years. [Even Hitler wanted to resettle European Jews to the French colony of Madagascar before that became unrealistic.] Are there any geographical options today that might separate these two warring parties before they annihilate each other?
 
The only thing that the Israelis and the Palestinians seem to agree on is that their opposites should not exist as sovereign countries. Is this an immutable law of religious beliefs, or is it a stubborn bargaining position that both sides have taken? Will it ultimately take the removal of millions of Israelis or Palestinians from the area to resolve this conflict?

The idea of resettling local populations to other areas has been around (and practiced) for thousands of years. [Even Hitler wanted to resettle European Jews to the French colony of Madagascar before that became unrealistic.] Are there any geographical options today that might separate these two warring parties before they annihilate each other?

Is it Possible for Israel and Palestine to Peacefully Coexist?​

I doubt it.
 
After the military defeat of the native people they resign themselves to life in the racial enclaves imposed by the supremacist state. Just visit any indian reservation to see an example of what I'm saying first hand.

The problem is that the level of violence required to defeat the palestinian people would lead to a complete international delegitimization of the jewish racial dictatorship.
 
Last edited:
The only thing that the Israelis and the Palestinians seem to agree on is that their opposites should not exist as sovereign countries. Is this an immutable law of religious beliefs, or is it a stubborn bargaining position that both sides have taken? Will it ultimately take the removal of millions of Israelis or Palestinians from the area to resolve this conflict?

The idea of resettling local populations to other areas has been around (and practiced) for thousands of years. [Even Hitler wanted to resettle European Jews to the French colony of Madagascar before that became unrealistic.] Are there any geographical options today that might separate these two warring parties before they annihilate each other?
Already tried about 76 years ago, and rejected by the Arab/Muslim neighbors of Israel/Palestine, and most of the Arab-Muslims within.
Hence the 1948 war and several more since.

United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine - Wikipedia

United Nations Resolution 181 - Encyclopedia Britannica

345px-UN_Palestine_Partition_Versions_1947.jpg
 
The only thing that the Israelis and the Palestinians seem to agree on is that their opposites should not exist as sovereign countries. Is this an immutable law of religious beliefs, or is it a stubborn bargaining position that both sides have taken? Will it ultimately take the removal of millions of Israelis or Palestinians from the area to resolve this conflict?

The idea of resettling local populations to other areas has been around (and practiced) for thousands of years. [Even Hitler wanted to resettle European Jews to the French colony of Madagascar before that became unrealistic.] Are there any geographical options today that might separate these two warring parties before they annihilate each other?
I highlighted the major error in your thinking. Throughout the conflict, Arabs (Palestinians as they are falsely called) have refused offers for statehood and a two-state solution because they refuse to acknowledge Israel's right to exist. That has been a stumbling block since the 1940s when Israel came into being. Did you miss that part of the equation? What about all of the Arabs that are Israeli citizens and serve in their armed forces? What makes them any different than the people in Gaza and the West Bank? Being in the West Bank and Gaza has not soothed their butthurt, even when they were allowed to self-govern.
 
I doubt it.

WHITE_6

:yes_text12:

ZINCWARRIOR

Only if they could.

Gaza must be plowed under and salted each for a decade.

The Gazans should be resettled in Madagascar.


John Edgar Slow Horses

Of course not.

EvilCat Breath


Already tried about 76 years ago, and rejected by the Arab/Muslim
neighbors of Israel/Palestine, and most of the Arab-Muslims within.
Hence the 1948 war and several more since.


STRYDER50

I highlighted the major error in your thinking. Throughout the conflict, Arabs (Palestinians as they are falsely called) have refused offers for statehood and a two-state solution because they refuse to acknowledge Israel's right to exist. That has been a stumbling block since the 1940s when Israel came into being. Did you miss that part of the equation? What about all of the arbs that are Israeli citizens and serve in their armed forces? What makes them any different than the people in Gaza and the West Bank? Being in the West Bank and Gaza has not soothed their butthurt, even when they were allowed to self-govern.

ADMIRAL ROCKWELL TORY
As I said... the defeat of the native people is a necessary, crucial condition for them to resign themselves to living in the racial enclaves imposed by the supremacist state.
 
The Israeli's don't want peace.
In fact, they never have.
Israel has never declared a fixed border.
Because their goal is to slowly ethnically cleanse all the Arabs from the region and establish a Greater Israel.
Israel ceded territory and declared a fixed border with Gaza. And here we are.

(Israel does not need to declare borders, she inherited borders at her Independence.)
 
The Israeli's don't want peace.
In fact, they never have.
Israel has never declared a fixed border.
Because their goal is to slowly ethnically cleanse all the Arabs from the region and establish a Greater Israel.

Slowly. No kidding. Slowest damn cleansing ever.
The only cleansing where there are more "victims" every decade than the decade before.
 
The only thing that the Israelis and the Palestinians seem to agree on is that their opposites should not exist as sovereign countries. Is this an immutable law of religious beliefs, or is it a stubborn bargaining position that both sides have taken? Will it ultimately take the removal of millions of Israelis or Palestinians from the area to resolve this conflict?

The idea of resettling local populations to other areas has been around (and practiced) for thousands of years. [Even Hitler wanted to resettle European Jews to the French colony of Madagascar before that became unrealistic.] Are there any geographical options today that might separate these two warring parties before they annihilate each other?
Not quite accurate. Back in the 1990's, Israel offered the so called Palestinians all of Gaza, 93% of the West Bank, an elevated highway under the control of the PA connecting Gaza and the West Bank and joint jurisdiction to Jerusalem, and the Palestinians emphatically said, no, by launching the second intifada.

After the second intifada had been suppressed, Israel made another effort to exchange land for peace with the so called Palestinians under Olmert, and again it was rejected.

In 2005, Ariel Sharon withdrew all Israelis from Gaza and closed all but a few settlements in the West Bank in still another effort to give the Palestinians a sovereign state in return for peace, and the offer was again rejected; the war we are now seeing is the direct result of withdrawing the IDF from Gaza in Israel's search for peace with the Palestinians.

So it clearly incorrect to say Israel is opposed to the existence of a sovereign Palestinian state, however the Palestinians have made quite clear that they will not live in peace with Israel.
 
Israel just stole Syria's buffer zone a few days ago.
With the Syrian government having been overthrown by a fragmented group of fighters, Turkey occupying about 15% of the land the Assad government had once controlled, Iranian militias occupying still more and the Russians occupying still more, does a sovereign state of Syria still exist?
 
The only thing that the Israelis and the Palestinians seem to agree on is that their opposites should not exist as sovereign countries. Is this an immutable law of religious beliefs, or is it a stubborn bargaining position that both sides have taken? Will it ultimately take the removal of millions of Israelis or Palestinians from the area to resolve this conflict?

The idea of resettling local populations to other areas has been around (and practiced) for thousands of years. [Even Hitler wanted to resettle European Jews to the French colony of Madagascar before that became unrealistic.] Are there any geographical options today that might separate these two warring parties before they annihilate each other?
Samdbars

Obviously, Libya, Tunisia, and Algeria.
 

Forum List

Back
Top