As I watch the two major parties cater more and more to the fringes, it is just a matter of time before a new major party comes along which caters to the intelligent, critically thinking people who have rejected both of the current major parties.
I cannot wait for that day.
As we watch billionaires toy with the idea of running as independents, it is just a matter of time before some of them pool their money to supply the necessary resources to get a new major party off the ground.
Then we can truly make America great again. Then it will be a new morning in America.
We have 3rd parties, Green Party, Libertarian Party, ect. In fact, we've had dozens of third parties, yet not one third party candidate has every occupied the White House. Also Third Party members rarely win congressional seats.
The so-called third parties in this country are specialty parties obsessed with some small ideological idea, and/or promoting extremist positions. There's the Jill Stein/Bernie Sanders radically leftist Greens, the ridiculously twisted inside out Ron Paul Libertarians, and so on. They are the opposite of what the OP is suggesting, which is a reasonably minded avenue that rejects the extremism all parties now represent.
Most all 3rd parties specialize. They do that to differentiate themselves from the big two. If a third party's issues are essential the same as the democrats and republicans and they take a reasonable minded approach to the issues they will lose because that's not what most voter want to hear. People don't watch the presidential debates to hear a real debate. They're looking for gotchas and great one liners. They don't want to listen to a reasonable approach to abortion, immigration, or healthcare. They just want a candidate that will assure them that he'll get the job, not explain why nothing should be done or a comprise needs to be made, or agree with opposition. Sorry, that is not how you win elections.
Everything you're saying substantiates what the OP is saying. Except you're failing to realize that those things are only true
now. The current environment is not the way our politics have traditionally been. The Republicans and Democrats both used to be relatively moderate parties. Other parties couldn't gain traction because the only appealed to a narrow audience while the two major parties constantly battled to win the center.
Now, both Rs and Ds have abandoned the center in favor of their own radicalism. And it's not amusing to the majority of Americans. Nearly half of all registered voters are unaffiliated, and only about half of those in either of the big two are particularly loyal or orthodox about their politics.
So their is a lot of merit to that suggestion that a centrist party would run away with poplar support, if it managed to gain a foothold in the national stage. Yes, there address plenty our challenges to gaining that foothold. But you're objections all boil down to a desperate attempt to deny that reasonable middle roads options are even with considering. Which highlights the only
real reason such a third party would struggle: because so many people stupidly assume the third party can win, so they stupidly run away in a panic.
Stupidity begets stupidity.