How Baby Formula May End Up As Collateral Damage In Trump’s NAFTA War

g5000

Diamond Member
Nov 26, 2011
128,965
73,269
2,605
June 15, 2018:


Furious American dairy farmers see the capital investment as yet another example of Canadian dairy farmers taking advantage of an unfair pricing system. Specifically, the Class 7 pricing program which came into effect last year and which, as I have previously written, introduced a favourable pricing category covering such skim milk components as skim milk powder. Butter lovers might define these as the leftovers.

Democratic Senator Chuck Schumer has been on the warpath about this since Class 7 came into effect, noting that Canadian exports of skim milk powder, rich in protein and ideal for baby formula, more than tripled in the first year of its existence, while dairy farmers in Cayuga County saw the export potential for their skim milk powders, to Canada and Mexico, shrink dramatically.

[snip]

The conditions, as there are now, are set for success.

That’s bound to change if Donald Trump decides to focus on Class 7 as a winnable concession in the NAFTA wars.



4 months later:

Class 7 Pricing Scheme in New NAFTA Deal

Trump administration officials said the USMCA eliminates Canada’s “Class 7” pricing system for milk ingredients and opens the Canadian dairy market to U.S. exports at an additional 3.59 percent (an increase from the 3.25% that was negotiated by the Obama administration under the Trans-Pacific Partnership).

Increased access to Canadian markets for dairy products was a major point of contention in trade talks, as was the termination of Class 7 pricing. The program saturated the international market with subsidized skim milk powder and cut the demand from Canadian cheesemakers for ultra-filtered milk from the U.S. USMCA will include the development of new safeguards to prevent major export increases for certain dairy products.
 
June 15, 2018:


Furious American dairy farmers see the capital investment as yet another example of Canadian dairy farmers taking advantage of an unfair pricing system. Specifically, the Class 7 pricing program which came into effect last year and which, as I have previously written, introduced a favourable pricing category covering such skim milk components as skim milk powder. Butter lovers might define these as the leftovers.

Democratic Senator Chuck Schumer has been on the warpath about this since Class 7 came into effect, noting that Canadian exports of skim milk powder, rich in protein and ideal for baby formula, more than tripled in the first year of its existence, while dairy farmers in Cayuga County saw the export potential for their skim milk powders, to Canada and Mexico, shrink dramatically.

[snip]

The conditions, as there are now, are set for success.

That’s bound to change if Donald Trump decides to focus on Class 7 as a winnable concession in the NAFTA wars.



4 months later:

Class 7 Pricing Scheme in New NAFTA Deal

Trump administration officials said the USMCA eliminates Canada’s “Class 7” pricing system for milk ingredients and opens the Canadian dairy market to U.S. exports at an additional 3.59 percent (an increase from the 3.25% that was negotiated by the Obama administration under the Trans-Pacific Partnership).

Increased access to Canadian markets for dairy products was a major point of contention in trade talks, as was the termination of Class 7 pricing. The program saturated the international market with subsidized skim milk powder and cut the demand from Canadian cheesemakers for ultra-filtered milk from the U.S. USMCA will include the development of new safeguards to prevent major export increases for certain dairy products.
This is BS, Candiaian Dairy farmes had a distinct advantage over US dairy Farmers before Trump ever took up the issue due to their subsidies.

There is no shortave of formula due to a shortage of milk components, there's a shortage of Formula because the FDA shuttered Abbott's Plants searching for a contaminant they never could find and keeping the plants shut down for two full months after a massive recall of their products that were already on store shelves.
 
Well thats weird...
There was never a shortage of Baby Formula when Trump was president.
Nothing Trump ever did contributed in any way to this shortage, it's just another lie to deflect the blame away from the current administration.

If there's something good coming out of this shortage it's that more women will be breast feeding longer. That is always a plus for the long term help of the baby.
 
Well thats weird...
There was never a shortage of Baby Formula when Trump was president.
The devastating shortage was sparked by a recall of formula from Abbott Nutrition in February, after fears that formula produced in its Sturgis, Mich., factory was contaminated with bacteria.

Abbott occupies about 43% of the U.S. market for infant formula, and provides the formula many U.S. states use to supply nutritional assistance programs for low-income households. On Monday, Abbott announced that it was on track to reopen its Sturgis factory, but said it will still take eight to ten weeks before its products return to store shelves.

Almost 98% of the U.S.'s formula supply comes from domestic manufacturers, with the 2% that's imported mainly coming from Mexico, Chile, Ireland and the Netherlands. Now that supply from domestic manufacturers is falling short, ramping up imports should be a quick way to meet excess demand. But strict approval processes and steep taxes are preventing U.S. formula buyers from simply shopping overseas.

 
The devastating shortage was sparked by a recall of formula from Abbott Nutrition in February, after fears that formula produced in its Sturgis, Mich., factory was contaminated with bacteria.

Abbott occupies about 43% of the U.S. market for infant formula, and provides the formula many U.S. states use to supply nutritional assistance programs for low-income households. On Monday, Abbott announced that it was on track to reopen its Sturgis factory, but said it will still take eight to ten weeks before its products return to store shelves.

Almost 98% of the U.S.'s formula supply comes from domestic manufacturers, with the 2% that's imported mainly coming from Mexico, Chile, Ireland and the Netherlands. Now that supply from domestic manufacturers is falling short, ramping up imports should be a quick way to meet excess demand. But strict approval processes and steep taxes are preventing U.S. formula buyers from simply shopping overseas.


Bla bla derp derpity and in conclusion ....derpity derp,derka derka mohammed jihad.
 
The devastating shortage was sparked by a recall of formula from Abbott Nutrition in February, after fears that formula produced in its Sturgis, Mich., factory was contaminated with bacteria.

Abbott occupies about 43% of the U.S. market for infant formula, and provides the formula many U.S. states use to supply nutritional assistance programs for low-income households. On Monday, Abbott announced that it was on track to reopen its Sturgis factory, but said it will still take eight to ten weeks before its products return to store shelves.

Almost 98% of the U.S.'s formula supply comes from domestic manufacturers, with the 2% that's imported mainly coming from Mexico, Chile, Ireland and the Netherlands. Now that supply from domestic manufacturers is falling short, ramping up imports should be a quick way to meet excess demand. But strict approval processes and steep taxes are preventing U.S. formula buyers from simply shopping overseas.

So, you're saying Biden's FDA and not Bad Orange Man caused the crisis.
 
The baby formula shortage is the Biden admin's problem and no one else's.
Biden could have written an EO when the Abbott plant closed allowing more imports in, and he didn't, not until the store shelves were empty putting babies at risk.

Trying to blame Trump is laughable. Maybe Biden needs to be sent to the showers?
1653651781600.png
 
That's an absolute lie.

Canada never had any significant exports of formula to the US and their dependence on US manufactured formula is putting their own citizens in a bind right now due to shortages.
You obviously did not read the OP link or comprehend it. Canada provided a significant amount of baby formula. That's why American dairy farmers wanted it stopped.

Duh.
 
June 15, 2018:


Furious American dairy farmers see the capital investment as yet another example of Canadian dairy farmers taking advantage of an unfair pricing system. Specifically, the Class 7 pricing program which came into effect last year and which, as I have previously written, introduced a favourable pricing category covering such skim milk components as skim milk powder. Butter lovers might define these as the leftovers.

Democratic Senator Chuck Schumer has been on the warpath about this since Class 7 came into effect, noting that Canadian exports of skim milk powder, rich in protein and ideal for baby formula, more than tripled in the first year of its existence, while dairy farmers in Cayuga County saw the export potential for their skim milk powders, to Canada and Mexico, shrink dramatically.

[snip]

The conditions, as there are now, are set for success.

That’s bound to change if Donald Trump decides to focus on Class 7 as a winnable concession in the NAFTA wars.



4 months later:

Class 7 Pricing Scheme in New NAFTA Deal

Trump administration officials said the USMCA eliminates Canada’s “Class 7” pricing system for milk ingredients and opens the Canadian dairy market to U.S. exports at an additional 3.59 percent (an increase from the 3.25% that was negotiated by the Obama administration under the Trans-Pacific Partnership).

Increased access to Canadian markets for dairy products was a major point of contention in trade talks, as was the termination of Class 7 pricing. The program saturated the international market with subsidized skim milk powder and cut the demand from Canadian cheesemakers for ultra-filtered milk from the U.S. USMCA will include the development of new safeguards to prevent major export increases for certain dairy products.

:auiqs.jpg: :auiqs.jpg: :auiqs.jpg:
 
As predicted in 2018, Trump's NAFTA war resulted in a baby formula shortage.

Do you tards think the reporter went back in time and wrote that article?
 
You obviously did not read the OP link or comprehend it. Canada provided a significant amount of baby formula. That's why American dairy farmers wanted it stopped.

Duh.
Canada never provided any significant portion of baby formula in the US. Perhaps you should read the article because what you are claiming simply isn't there.
 
Last edited:
You obviously did not read the OP link or comprehend it. Canada provided a significant amount of baby formula. That's why American dairy farmers wanted it stopped.

Duh.
Neither did you because it doesn’t say anything about Canada exporting baby formula to the US. Only the skim milk powder. Lack of skim milk powder isn’t the problem causing the shortage.
 
As predicted in 2018, Trump's NAFTA war resulted in a baby formula shortage.

Do you tards think the reporter went back in time and wrote that article?
No it didn't why are you lying?

The FDA is wholly and solely responsible for this shortage.
 
It sounds to me like if the FDA is more worried about shaking down manufacturers than providing a reliable stream of safe baby formula. I guess they think every company is like Pfizer. Trump would have addressed this problem much quicker.
 

Forum List

Back
Top