"H.R. 1526, the No Rogue Rulings Act of 2025.

[martybegan]

That’s never how it’s worked. The Supreme Court delegates authority to the lower courts, just as executive branch members are delegated authority by the president. Your solution is a prescription for chaos. The lower courts were created to only send the most important cases to SCOTUS, but the executive doesn’t get to decide which ones they are.

We've never had District courts issue blanket TRO's against the executive in this volume or manner before.

You fucks changed the conditions, not us.

 

[martybegan]

Maybe you should get in touch with the members of the regime who admitted Garcia was mistakenly deported. Or read any of the many available articles explaining the situation.

So of course one mistake means every single deportation must be stopped, right?

 

[konradv]

We've never had District courts issue blanket TRO's against the executive in this volume or manner before.

We’ve never had a president employ this volume of fascism before.

 

[martybegan]

We’ve never had a president employ this volume of fascism before.

LOL, right to the fucking fake fascism argument.

Every EO he has made references passed legislation that it is based on.

 

[Zincwarrior]

Then they would just all file in the DC Circuit because that's where the President is.

Tricksy! but in this scenario, Presidential actions or generally effective along the entire US, or multiple regions. A DC court would only impact effects specifically the DC area.

Alternatively, Congress could mandate that such actions would have to be brought in DC. Then you would not have forum or judge shopping and the route to appellate and SCOTUS review would be faster - if those courts desired.
Marty my boy I think you found the answer!

 

[konradv]

So of course one mistake means every single deportation must be stopped, right?

Yes, if the administration lies about not being able to do anything about the mistake. That sounds like begging for relief because, ‘we’re too incompetent’!

 

[martybegan]

Tricksy! but in this scenario, Presidential actions or generally effective along the entire US, or multiple regions. A DC court would only impact effects specifically the DC area.

Alternatively, Congress could mandate that such actions would have to be brought in DC. Then you would not have forum or judge shopping and the route to appellate and SCOTUS review would be faster - if those courts desired.
Marty my boy I think you found the answer!

The District Court Judges doing this stuff would probably beg to differ.

This still allows the progs to stop the President from his constitutional duties to execute the laws of the country purely as delay lawfare.

The SC needs to step in each time. If that means other cases have to wait, well that's on the Progs and the stupid TRO's they ask for.

 

[martybegan]

Yes, if the administration lies about not being able to do anything about the mistake. That sounds like begging for relief because, ‘we’re too incompetent’!

Nope.

Now go pretend Biden was competent from 2020-2024 and a half.

 

[struth]

https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/1526/text

House Repubs are on board with the false narrative the WH is trying to foment regarding lower court rulings that have blocked or delayed the implementation of the regime's draconian, radical, agenda. Hence the bill they passed and the name they gave it. There are a number of talking points reverberating around the right wing echo chamber in support of this. "Legislating from the bench," "judicial overreach," "unelected, activist judges," blah, blah, blah. trump supporters parrot them like a mantra.

One of the more high profile, consequential cases being the regime's deportation of around 270 men to an El Salvadorian gulag. One man in particular who was mistakenly deported posing a problem for Team trump. Because the SC ruling on the return of Abrego Garcia to the US drove a truck over the false narrative by reaffirming lower courts have all the authority they need to order the regime to do what it is told when it commits executive overreach.

This seems to simply codify what the SCOTUS has ruled.

 

[Nuthin' Fancy]

Nope.

Now go pretend Biden was competent from 2020-2024 and a half.

Pretend Trump was EVER competent for ANYTHING.
MAYBE.......Selling his Chinese made trinkets to his gullible cult.

 

[martybegan]

Pretend Trump was EVER competent.

 

[Nuthin' Fancy]

Terrible orange man/child.

 

[Zincwarrior]

This still allows the progs to stop the President from his constitutional duties to execute the laws of the country purely as delay lawfare.

Even presidents are not above the law.

 

[martybegan]

Terrible orange man/child.

View attachment 1099281

Sad sack skittle hair person.

 

[martybegan]

Even presidents are not above the law.

They are above district courts. The SC has the authority to review disputes at the Presidential level.

 

[Zincwarrior]

They are above district courts. The SC has the authority to review disputes at the Presidential level.

The Constitution disagrees. The Executive is the same as legislative and judicial.

 

[Billiejeens]

Troll Bot Bugger 86 continues to insist that he is UnAmerican in every way imaginable .

He pretends to follow the law in order to support Illegals and even dangerous ones.

Are there no depths that this Extremist Lefty Troll Bot will not sink to ?

No
There are no depths that he won't aspire to.

 

[martybegan]

In your head they are. The Constitution disagrees.

The only judicial court in the Constitution is the Supreme Court, all the others are created by acts of congress to make the Supreme Court's job easier. That's it. And having to reign in idiot District judges does not make the SC's job easier, and it interferes with the execution of the President's duties.

 

[Nuthin' Fancy]

Sad sack skittle hair person.

 

[Lisa558]

MAGA is "draconian and RADICAL"

Yes, apparently deporting lowlife gang members here illegally from Central America is so draconian.

(These Dems are nuts. Always on the side of the wrong people. I wish they showed as much care and concern for innocent Jewish students being robbed of their rights on liberal university campuses as they do for illegal scum.)