Isn’t the same exclusionary principle at play when you refer to Palestinians as “Arab Moslems” implying they are foreign invaders in a Jewish land?
This is a red herring and an offensive one.
Why?
1.Because my grandfather, G-d give him long years, is a Palestinian Jew, so were at least 20 generations of my family after they've arrived from the most ancient Jewish diaspora community in the middle east - Babylon.
2. Because when the different posters here argued for transfer - I argue that it would be a catastrophe for the Israeli society in whole. Yet You stick this accusation to me as if I was to exclude them from my society.
3. Because my family has long (more than a century) friendship with the respected Arab Aboulafia family and several others less known clans, who do not deny of their foreign origins, and it never EVER was an issue between us.
4. Because while the word "Palestine" coming from MY LANGUAGE - means exactly that - INVADERS, the Arab governments identify officially as invaders who took the land by force, and their flag is represnting the 4 Caliphates. Yet You want me to lie about such basic undeniable truth in favor of Your twisted moral relativism, projections and PC bs - Your main measure of truth is Your emotions regarding the subject: And somehow You feel it's acceptable to
emotionally blackmail me to deny truth that Arabs themselves don't deny, only to feed Your delusions about the fairness of the world on my behalf.
But the most disturbing thing is that You're trying to extract this guilt by comparing Jewish independence, heritage and truth to antisemitism - the most long documented vile and violent form of violence that was inflicted on any nation on earth (that I know of) throughout the centuries. You're comparing our struggle to independence to antisemitism, a struggle that continues to this day against a group of people who made it their goal in life to ERASE my people from their ONLY land, while also stealing every aspect of Jewish identity to do that. That You even dare to do it shows how detached are You from the reality of one of the most persecuted nations on earth - and You do the same thing our enemies do - trying to water down and steal our identity by comparing antisemitism to our defense against the Arab nation.
I've spoken in Your favor when people accused You of antisemitism, I'm saddened by the fact that I can't anymore - because my people lost a friend to the most vile ideology used against us.
