Zone1 Do the Gospels make a concerted effort to portray the resurrection of Jesus as an historical event?

Do the Gospels make a concerted effort to portray the resurrection of Jesus as an historical event?

  • yes

  • no


Results are only viewable after voting.

ding

Confront reality
Joined
Oct 25, 2016
Messages
141,690
Reaction score
26,272
Points
2,220
Location
Houston
The risen Christ appeared to a variety of individuals and groups, with accounts in the Bible describing appearances to at least eight different groups of people over a 40-day period. While the Bible details specific instances, it does not explicitly state that these were the only appearances.

In all Jesus appeared a dozen different times over forty days to more than 515 individuals. He appeared to women and to men, He appeared to individuals and to groups, He appeared indoors and outdoors, He appeared to people who were skeptics and people who were believers, He appeared to people who were hardhearted and people who were tenderhearted. And He talked with people, He ate with people, He even invited Thomas - the skeptic, the doubter - to put his finger in the nail holes in His hands, put his hand in the spear wound in His side - to see and touch the evidence himself. Then what was Thomas's reaction? To say, "My Lord and my God!" He became convinced by the evidence that Jesus had returned from the dead. And what does history tell us about Thomas? He spent the rest of his life declaring Jesus did return from the dead, He is the Son of God, even to the point of being put to death for his faith in southern India.

Here's a breakdown of some of the groups Jesus appeared to:


All four canonical Gospels make a concerted and central effort to portray that Jesus rose from the dead, presenting it as a physical, historical, and transformative event. While the narratives differ in specific details—which scholars often interpret as complementary, independent eyewitness accounts rather than contradictions—they consistently agree on the core truth that the tomb was empty and Jesus appeared to his followers.

Key Evidence of a Concerted Effort

The Gospels employ several strategies to assert the reality of the resurrection:
  • The Empty Tomb & Early Witnesses: All four Gospels record that women were the first witnesses to the empty tomb on Sunday morning, an detail that would have been unlikely to be fabricated in 1st-century Jewish culture where a woman's testimony was often not accepted.
  • Physicality of the Risen Jesus: To combat early notions that Jesus only rose spiritually, the Gospels emphasize a physical resurrection. Luke 24:39-43 describes Jesus eating fish and showing his "flesh and bones," while John 20:24-29 features Jesus inviting Thomas to touch his wounds.
  • Post-Resurrection Appearances: The Gospels record multiple appearances to individuals and groups, including Mary Magdalene, other women, the disciples in locked rooms, and on the road to Emmaus, designed to prove he was alive.
  • The Great Commission: The Gospel narratives culminate in Jesus appearing to his disciples to authorize their mission, cementing the resurrection as the foundation of the Christian faith.
Thematic Differences in the Narratives

While the message is consistent, the authors emphasize different aspects:
  • Matthew (28): Highlights the earthquake, the guarding of the tomb, and Jesus' appearance to the women.
  • Mark (16): Originally ends abruptly with the empty tomb and fearful women, though the longer ending (16:9-20) adds later,, traditional post-resurrection appearances.
  • Luke (24): Focuses on the road to Emmaus appearance and the physical, touchable nature of Jesus, emphasizing the fulfillment of Scripture.
  • John (20-21): Provides detailed accounts of Mary Magdalene at the tomb and the doubting Thomas scene, placing strong emphasis on the personal, intimate nature of the interactions.
The consistent, albeit varied, reporting of these events suggests a deliberate effort by the gospel writers to affirm that the resurrection was not a myth or legend, but a concrete event.
 
"somebody told me something once" is not proof of anything.
 
Many biblical scholars argue the Gospels make a concerted effort to present the Resurrection as a historical event, highlighting evidence like multiple testimonies, the empty tomb, and the transformative experience of early followers, while other scholars (liberal, non-Christian) view the accounts as myth or theological interpretations, though there's scholarly consensus on core historical facts around the resurrection like crucifixion and disciples' belief.

Arguments for Historicity (from a traditional/evangelical view):
  • Multiple Attestation: Events appearing in multiple, independent Gospel accounts (Matthew, Mark, Luke, John) are considered more historically probable.
  • Empty Tomb: Many scholars find the empty tomb difficult to deny on purely historical grounds, suggesting it points to a real event.
  • Eyewitness Testimony: The Gospels and Paul's letters preserve testimonies from Peter, James, Mary Magdalene, and hundreds of others, seen as strong evidence.
  • Transformation of Disciples: The dramatic change in the disciples, from fearful followers to bold proclaimers, is cited as evidence for genuine experiences.
 
The risen Christ appeared to a variety of individuals and groups, with accounts in the Bible describing appearances to at least eight different groups of people over a 40-day period. While the Bible details specific instances, it does not explicitly state that these were the only appearances.

In all Jesus appeared a dozen different times over forty days to more than 515 individuals. He appeared to women and to men, He appeared to individuals and to groups, He appeared indoors and outdoors, He appeared to people who were skeptics and people who were believers, He appeared to people who were hardhearted and people who were tenderhearted. And He talked with people, He ate with people, He even invited Thomas - the skeptic, the doubter - to put his finger in the nail holes in His hands, put his hand in the spear wound in His side - to see and touch the evidence himself. Then what was Thomas's reaction? To say, "My Lord and my God!" He became convinced by the evidence that Jesus had returned from the dead. And what does history tell us about Thomas? He spent the rest of his life declaring Jesus did return from the dead, He is the Son of God, even to the point of being put to death for his faith in southern India.

Here's a breakdown of some of the groups Jesus appeared to:


All four canonical Gospels make a concerted and central effort to portray that Jesus rose from the dead, presenting it as a physical, historical, and transformative event. While the narratives differ in specific details—which scholars often interpret as complementary, independent eyewitness accounts rather than contradictions—they consistently agree on the core truth that the tomb was empty and Jesus appeared to his followers.

Key Evidence of a Concerted Effort

The Gospels employ several strategies to assert the reality of the resurrection:
  • The Empty Tomb & Early Witnesses: All four Gospels record that women were the first witnesses to the empty tomb on Sunday morning, an detail that would have been unlikely to be fabricated in 1st-century Jewish culture where a woman's testimony was often not accepted.
  • Physicality of the Risen Jesus: To combat early notions that Jesus only rose spiritually, the Gospels emphasize a physical resurrection. Luke 24:39-43 describes Jesus eating fish and showing his "flesh and bones," while John 20:24-29 features Jesus inviting Thomas to touch his wounds.
  • Post-Resurrection Appearances: The Gospels record multiple appearances to individuals and groups, including Mary Magdalene, other women, the disciples in locked rooms, and on the road to Emmaus, designed to prove he was alive.
  • The Great Commission: The Gospel narratives culminate in Jesus appearing to his disciples to authorize their mission, cementing the resurrection as the foundation of the Christian faith.
Thematic Differences in the Narratives

While the message is consistent, the authors emphasize different aspects:
  • Matthew (28): Highlights the earthquake, the guarding of the tomb, and Jesus' appearance to the women.
  • Mark (16): Originally ends abruptly with the empty tomb and fearful women, though the longer ending (16:9-20) adds later,, traditional post-resurrection appearances.
  • Luke (24): Focuses on the road to Emmaus appearance and the physical, touchable nature of Jesus, emphasizing the fulfillment of Scripture.
  • John (20-21): Provides detailed accounts of Mary Magdalene at the tomb and the doubting Thomas scene, placing strong emphasis on the personal, intimate nature of the interactions.
The consistent, albeit varied, reporting of these events suggests a deliberate effort by the gospel writers to affirm that the resurrection was not a myth or legend, but a concrete event.


An astonishing number of modern near death experiencers are reporting that Jesus is the bar none best Jewish doctor ever!

The team of doctors and nurses who worked on the rather shocking Robert Marshall near death experience admit that Robert's healing astonished them. They had felt that the time had came for his wife Carol to allow them to take her husband off life support so that nature could take its inevitable course.



"Upon entering the emergency room, the admission staff quickly observed the medical emergency: I was having difficulty breathing. I was immediately escorted to the care area of the ER and met with a member of the medical team who performed the perfunctory vital signs and symptom identification.


The hospital staff responded to my symptoms and ordered a new CT scan and a broader, all- encompassing blood test. The results showed I had “unstable/abnormal vital signs and life-threatening conditions,” as described in my medical record. I was at risk of my airway being blocked by the mass indicated on the CT scan and I needed emergency intubation with ventilator support. They moved me to a surgical suite, inserted the oral intubation tube, and admitted me to the ICU immediately."
Emergency Room Medical Note:

IMPRESSION:

Increased inflammatory change in the deep left neck soft tissues with worsening swelling of the epiglottis and moderate to severe airway narrowing. Additional inflammatory change involving the left submandibular fossa and submandibular gland as well as the left anterior belly of the digastric. Findings suggest worsening infectious pharyngitis/tonsillitis/epiglottitis. No drainable collection.


Left glossotonsillar sulcus fullness persists. Although superimposed infection is likely, evaluation for an underlying malignancy should be pursued. Direct visualization and tissue sampling may be warranted by ENT. Follow-up CT neck with contrast in one to 3 months is recommended to confirm resolution.

No cervical lymphadenopathy by size criteria.

Incidental severe spinal canal narrowing C5-6 due to ossification of the posterior longitudinal ligament.

For the next two days, I rested comfortably, my body fighting the infection with the help of IV antibiotics, and the intubation tube that kept the mass away from my airway.
[Robert and Carol Marshall, Forty Four Hours in Heaven," page 13]



 

Do the Gospels make a concerted effort to portray the resurrection of Jesus as an historical event?

their clarity for an actual historical event the resurrection is no more certain than their incoherent accounting for the reason jesus was crucified in the first place for a reason the latter event to have actually occurred and its purpose.

“Truly I tell you,” Jesus answered, “this very night, before the rooster crows, you will disown me three times.”

were that but one ...

you fail again to address the question why the roman authorities who had just crucified jesus for the jews have no records of their prisoner being still alive on the lose for them to rearrest or give reason not to have done so ...

for the simple reason as the event of the resurrection is a 4th century fallacy to promote the agenda of those in the 4th century using jesus for their own purposes written in their bible than the liberation theology, self determination jesus truly gave their life for - including the repudiation of judaism, false commandments et al the 4th century crucifiers include in their own maleficient document.
 
Ethiopian bible on resurrection as Grok 4 saw it:

 
The risen Christ appeared to a variety of individuals and groups, with accounts in the Bible describing appearances to at least eight different groups of people over a 40-day period. While the Bible details specific instances, it does not explicitly state that these were the only appearances.

self promoting delusional desert dweller ...

where were the f b i, roman army to rearrest who they just crucified as though they would ignore either their victim or those in rebellion claiming such a fallacy.

- no contemporary tabloid accounts just their 4th century book of forgeries lies and fallacies.
 
self promoting delusional desert dweller ...

where were the f b i, roman army to rearrest who they just crucified as though they would ignore either their victim or those in rebellion claiming such a fallacy.

- no contemporary tabloid accounts just their 4th century book of forgeries lies and fallacies.
Jesus was worshiped as God immediately after he rose from the dead. Your timeline is off by over 300 years.
 

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom