Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS

ScienceRocks

Democrat all the way!
Mar 16, 2010
59,455
6,793
1,900
The Good insane United states of America
Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS

A 29-year-old woman will die without a new drug that the NHS is refusing to provide despite the manufacturer offering it to her for free, it emerged today.

Caroline Cassin, 29, who suffers from Cystic Fibrosis (CF) has been offered a new drug free of charge for a limited period by the makers but her NHS hospital is refusing.

Her family say she will die soon without it, yet managers at Heartlands Hospital in Birmingham say it would be unethical to provide the drug under the deal, only for it to be withdrawn later.

The drug, Kalydeco also known as ivacaftor, costs £182,000 per patient per year, and works for five per cent of people with CF who have a certain defective gene, around 270 people in England.

It corrects a malfunctioning protein which causes

the characteristic build-up of fluid and mucus in the lungs that causes devastating damage.

It usually kills in the late 30s.

The drug, effectively allows sufferers to lead a normal life, and has been available in America since January, and is successfully trialled and licenced in this country.

However it has not yet been approved for use on the NHS and an expert specialist group is due to make recommendations to health service funding organisations by December.

Vertex Pharmaceuticals has offered to make the drug available on compassionate grounds to certain patients.

Caroline’s father, Neil, 72, said: "Caroline has struggled for 29 years and it has been horrendous at times, but the last year has been the worst.

"She has always been a good girl, but she is very low now. She knows that she's dying.

"She has been given the golden crown, then had it snatched from her.

"The NHS Trust is sitting by while we are watching Caroline's health deteriorate at an alarming rate. How much longer can this go on?

"To have this one chance of life taken away after a lifetime of suffering is cruel beyond belief."

Jessica Nickless, vice-chairman the Ivacaftor Patients Interest Group, said: "If I stood by and witnessed someone being murdered I would be complicit to that murder, yet doctors can watch someone die. They are condemning Caroline to a slow, lingering death.

"For Caroline, it is now or never. We have almost exhausted every avenue."
A spokesman for Heartlands Hospital said: "We fully support our patients and are doing everything in our power to facilitate a fair solution.

"The trust decided not to obtain Kalydeco on a compassionate basis because the drug company scheme is temporary and the trust would face withdrawing the medication when the scheme stops."

Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS - Telegraph

Do we really want to copy this shit?
 
Awesome shit....who woudnt want the government in control of your health care and life....oh yeah normal, thinking people
 
I think people who are on dialysis in this country will face similar issues. A panel will decide who lives and who dies. Decisions will no longer be between doctor and patient.
 
So who would pay for it in the US? I bet you would have to pay a fortune for insurance which would cover it.
 
So who would pay for it in the US? I bet you would have to pay a fortune for insurance which would cover it.


Well if that's the case than so be it.....but i'd rather be able to be covered than it be no.....that's the point of making money......
 
So who would pay for it in the US? I bet you would have to pay a fortune for insurance which would cover it.


Well if that's the case than so be it.....but i'd rather be able to be covered than it be no.....that's the point of making money......

You would rather it be covered than not be covered? Well, obviously, but the cost of it in the US would likely be the same (in insurance costs) than it would be in the UK.
 
Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS

A 29-year-old woman will die without a new drug that the NHS is refusing to provide despite the manufacturer offering it to her for free, it emerged today.

Caroline Cassin, 29, who suffers from Cystic Fibrosis (CF) has been offered a new drug free of charge for a limited period by the makers but her NHS hospital is refusing.

Her family say she will die soon without it, yet managers at Heartlands Hospital in Birmingham say it would be unethical to provide the drug under the deal, only for it to be withdrawn later.

The drug, Kalydeco also known as ivacaftor, costs £182,000 per patient per year, and works for five per cent of people with CF who have a certain defective gene, around 270 people in England.

It corrects a malfunctioning protein which causes

the characteristic build-up of fluid and mucus in the lungs that causes devastating damage.

It usually kills in the late 30s.

The drug, effectively allows sufferers to lead a normal life, and has been available in America since January, and is successfully trialled and licenced in this country.

However it has not yet been approved for use on the NHS and an expert specialist group is due to make recommendations to health service funding organisations by December.

Vertex Pharmaceuticals has offered to make the drug available on compassionate grounds to certain patients.

Caroline’s father, Neil, 72, said: "Caroline has struggled for 29 years and it has been horrendous at times, but the last year has been the worst.

"She has always been a good girl, but she is very low now. She knows that she's dying.

"She has been given the golden crown, then had it snatched from her.

"The NHS Trust is sitting by while we are watching Caroline's health deteriorate at an alarming rate. How much longer can this go on?

"To have this one chance of life taken away after a lifetime of suffering is cruel beyond belief."

Jessica Nickless, vice-chairman the Ivacaftor Patients Interest Group, said: "If I stood by and witnessed someone being murdered I would be complicit to that murder, yet doctors can watch someone die. They are condemning Caroline to a slow, lingering death.

"For Caroline, it is now or never. We have almost exhausted every avenue."
A spokesman for Heartlands Hospital said: "We fully support our patients and are doing everything in our power to facilitate a fair solution.

"The trust decided not to obtain Kalydeco on a compassionate basis because the drug company scheme is temporary and the trust would face withdrawing the medication when the scheme stops."

Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS - Telegraph

Do we really want to copy this shit?

A person with CF in the US may well not be able to work and therefore not have insurance. Without insurance, the person could not get the drug, unless they were so poor that they qualified for Medicaid, which is government healthcare. Most anyone who has been laid off for an extended period of time would also be without coverage. The examples you guys come up with to make your points are always major fails.
 
Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS

A 29-year-old woman will die without a new drug that the NHS is refusing to provide despite the manufacturer offering it to her for free, it emerged today.

Caroline Cassin, 29, who suffers from Cystic Fibrosis (CF) has been offered a new drug free of charge for a limited period by the makers but her NHS hospital is refusing.

Her family say she will die soon without it, yet managers at Heartlands Hospital in Birmingham say it would be unethical to provide the drug under the deal, only for it to be withdrawn later.

The drug, Kalydeco also known as ivacaftor, costs £182,000 per patient per year, and works for five per cent of people with CF who have a certain defective gene, around 270 people in England.

It corrects a malfunctioning protein which causes

the characteristic build-up of fluid and mucus in the lungs that causes devastating damage.

It usually kills in the late 30s.

The drug, effectively allows sufferers to lead a normal life, and has been available in America since January, and is successfully trialled and licenced in this country.

However it has not yet been approved for use on the NHS and an expert specialist group is due to make recommendations to health service funding organisations by December.

Vertex Pharmaceuticals has offered to make the drug available on compassionate grounds to certain patients.

Caroline’s father, Neil, 72, said: "Caroline has struggled for 29 years and it has been horrendous at times, but the last year has been the worst.

"She has always been a good girl, but she is very low now. She knows that she's dying.

"She has been given the golden crown, then had it snatched from her.

"The NHS Trust is sitting by while we are watching Caroline's health deteriorate at an alarming rate. How much longer can this go on?

"To have this one chance of life taken away after a lifetime of suffering is cruel beyond belief."

Jessica Nickless, vice-chairman the Ivacaftor Patients Interest Group, said: "If I stood by and witnessed someone being murdered I would be complicit to that murder, yet doctors can watch someone die. They are condemning Caroline to a slow, lingering death.

"For Caroline, it is now or never. We have almost exhausted every avenue."
A spokesman for Heartlands Hospital said: "We fully support our patients and are doing everything in our power to facilitate a fair solution.

"The trust decided not to obtain Kalydeco on a compassionate basis because the drug company scheme is temporary and the trust would face withdrawing the medication when the scheme stops."

Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS - Telegraph

Do we really want to copy this shit?

A person with CF in the US may well not be able to work and therefore not have insurance. Without insurance, the person could not get the drug, unless they were so poor that they qualified for Medicaid, which is government healthcare. Most anyone who has been laid off for an extended period of time would also be without coverage. The examples you guys come up with to make your points are always major fails.


Again you miss the point....the point is we dont want government health insurance of this happens......what about people who pay for private insurance? you know most of us.......
 
Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS

A 29-year-old woman will die without a new drug that the NHS is refusing to provide despite the manufacturer offering it to her for free, it emerged today.

Caroline Cassin, 29, who suffers from Cystic Fibrosis (CF) has been offered a new drug free of charge for a limited period by the makers but her NHS hospital is refusing.

Her family say she will die soon without it, yet managers at Heartlands Hospital in Birmingham say it would be unethical to provide the drug under the deal, only for it to be withdrawn later.

The drug, Kalydeco also known as ivacaftor, costs £182,000 per patient per year, and works for five per cent of people with CF who have a certain defective gene, around 270 people in England.

It corrects a malfunctioning protein which causes

the characteristic build-up of fluid and mucus in the lungs that causes devastating damage.

It usually kills in the late 30s.

The drug, effectively allows sufferers to lead a normal life, and has been available in America since January, and is successfully trialled and licenced in this country.

However it has not yet been approved for use on the NHS and an expert specialist group is due to make recommendations to health service funding organisations by December.

Vertex Pharmaceuticals has offered to make the drug available on compassionate grounds to certain patients.

Caroline’s father, Neil, 72, said: "Caroline has struggled for 29 years and it has been horrendous at times, but the last year has been the worst.

"She has always been a good girl, but she is very low now. She knows that she's dying.

"She has been given the golden crown, then had it snatched from her.

"The NHS Trust is sitting by while we are watching Caroline's health deteriorate at an alarming rate. How much longer can this go on?

"To have this one chance of life taken away after a lifetime of suffering is cruel beyond belief."

Jessica Nickless, vice-chairman the Ivacaftor Patients Interest Group, said: "If I stood by and witnessed someone being murdered I would be complicit to that murder, yet doctors can watch someone die. They are condemning Caroline to a slow, lingering death.

"For Caroline, it is now or never. We have almost exhausted every avenue."
A spokesman for Heartlands Hospital said: "We fully support our patients and are doing everything in our power to facilitate a fair solution.

"The trust decided not to obtain Kalydeco on a compassionate basis because the drug company scheme is temporary and the trust would face withdrawing the medication when the scheme stops."

Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS - Telegraph

Do we really want to copy this shit?

Just wondering.
If the FDA didn't approve the drug, would it still be covered by an insurance company in the US?
 
Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS



Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS - Telegraph

Do we really want to copy this shit?

A person with CF in the US may well not be able to work and therefore not have insurance. Without insurance, the person could not get the drug, unless they were so poor that they qualified for Medicaid, which is government healthcare. Most anyone who has been laid off for an extended period of time would also be without coverage. The examples you guys come up with to make your points are always major fails.


Again you miss the point....the point is we dont want government health insurance of this happens......what about people who pay for private insurance? you know most of us.......

Do you really think your insurance carrier will cover $182k/year treatments for a medication that only works in 5% of the people that use it? I have some magical unicorn powder that will work just as well for half the price. Of course, you'll have to pay out of pocket for that too.

You do know that private insurers all have "death panels" right? They're called actuaries. They assess risk/ reward scenarios and determine what will be paid for and what won't. Experimental drugs don't make the cut.

Hell, most of them won't cover procedures like bariatric surgery that instantly cures diabetes and allows an obese person to lower their risk of heart disease, helps with the wear and tear on the joints.....so let's see....guaranteed cure of obesity related diabetes and all the health problems it causes, reduced risk of heart disease and all the problems that causes, orthopedic relief means less chance of having joint replacement surgeries down the road......and they won't cover it most of the time.

Same way with Lasik surgery.....they won't cover it....even though that $1500 would save them money in the long run by not having to pay for a lifetime of lenses and their share of the frames.
 
Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS



Cystic Fibrosis sufferer denied 'chance of life' drug by NHS - Telegraph

Do we really want to copy this shit?

A person with CF in the US may well not be able to work and therefore not have insurance. Without insurance, the person could not get the drug, unless they were so poor that they qualified for Medicaid, which is government healthcare. Most anyone who has been laid off for an extended period of time would also be without coverage. The examples you guys come up with to make your points are always major fails.


Again you miss the point....the point is we dont want government health insurance of this happens......what about people who pay for private insurance? you know most of us.......

You don't want gov't health ins. Ok. But do you think private health ins would make this situation any better for a person in the US? Really?
 

Forum List

Back
Top