Then why make a claim you can't possibly support?
I can support it based on reports coming out of china
of course there are foreigners living in china that post glowing reports about china and they viciously attack any and all critics of the their adopted country
so if you search you can find others to agree with you
I think very few foreigners who are actually living or have lived in China post “glowing reports about China and viciously attack any and all critics of their adopted country.”
First of all very few foreigners stay in China longer than a few years, learn the language fluently, and almost none “adopt” the country (or are accepted by it). Even Chinese Americans usually feel culturally distinct and alienated. I lived there eight years and met hundreds of emigres, have a Chinese wife, was earlier close to the Taiwanese community in NYC, and still have Western friends and family on the Mainland — I personally know absolutely nobody in the category you describe.
Of course they
do exist.
Businessmen were understandably enthusiastic about real profits which were made, and are still being made, there. Many scholars and diplomats WERE overly optimistic about China transforming, but it should not be forgotten how much it HAS changed from Mao days. The U.S. first made its peace with China
under Mao,
during the Cultural Revolution, then
after the TianAnMen Massacre under DengXiaoping. It was always a deal predicated
not on China becoming “like us,” but for geo-political advantage against the USSR and for profits.
As you said, there is most definitely a “dark side” to China. Actually,
many dark sides. Most educated patriotic Chinese are quite conscious of all this. Older people went through the Cultural Revolution, younger people grew up in a different China entirely. Corruption, CP hypocrisy, bureaucracy and censorship, fierce competition for good jobs, these may not be discussed honestly in the controlled press, but everyone in China is aware of all of it. Keeping everything in proper proportion is tough. People in China, as here, mostly just want to live better, which means “go along and get along” — for themselves and their families.
As you know there are dark sides to U.S. society too, and “Americans” are not exactly known these days for having a subtle or sympathetic eye even for their
fellow Americans who disagree over this leader or that party. The Communist Party in China, despite all the grumbling, remains reasonably popular there and no ready alternative exists, though splits in the party have occurred before and may well again. I think the CP appears — at least to most Chinese people — to be reasonably rational and working on behalf of China’s national interests. That doesn’t mean XiJinping’s “Dream” of a moderately well off China can be realized under his increasingly totalitarian rule. Will increased Western hostility lead to progressive change in China? Has it ever?
Most folks here at USMB would probably consider me a “China apologist” — because I challenge the almost insane unreality of much U.S.-centric populist thinking about an “evil China.” Actually I am terribly concerned about the direction in which China has moved in recent years, and I fear for the future of U.S.-Chinese relations under whichever candidate wins the upcoming elections.