Back to the OP.
As the WSJ Editorial Board noted this morning, Canada is just applying the same concepts to the United States that the United States is applying to Mexico.
Throughout his presidential campaign, Donald Trump liked to bang on about how Mexicans are stealing American jobs, and he called the North American Free Trade Agreement “maybe the worst trade deal ever signed anywhere but certainly ever signed in this country.” Now someone on the other side of the U.S. border is finally agreeing with him.
But it isn’t Mexico. It’s Canada. And this is probably not what Mr. Trump expected when he forced Nafta’s trading partners back to the negotiating table. As part of this renegotiation, the Canadians are now complaining that U.S. labor laws are unfair to Canada. Specifically, the Globe and Mail reports that Canadian negotiators spent Sunday’s talks in Mexico City trying to persuade their U.S. counterparts to pass a federal law negating the right-to-work laws that now prevail in 28 U.S. states.
The Canadians argue that these laws, by reducing the power of unions to compel dues from workers, mean weaker unions, lower labor standards and reduced wages. This in turn means that when it comes to attracting business, these U.S. states enjoy an unfair advantage over the higher-cost Canadians. The Canadians say they only want to level the playing field.
In other words, the Canadians are arguing that the U.S. is doing to its markets what Mr. Trump accuses Mexico of doing to ours: stealing jobs through lower-cost labor. The leader of Canada’s largest trade union, Jerry Dias, out-Trumped Mr. Trump in his bluntness: “Canada’s got two problems,” he says. “The low-wage rates in Mexico and the right-to-work states in the United States.”
It’s easy to laugh over someone turning Mr. Trump’s trade argument against him, especially when there’s zero chance of doing away with U.S. right-to-work protection. But there’s a serious point amid the absurdity: A reminder that sometimes when people complain about unfair trading practices, what they’re really objecting to is old-fashioned competition.
Making Canada Great Again