Can a Federal Judge order Schumer to end his shutdown?

[CrusaderFrank]

no judge can force the legislative branch to vote one way or the other on anything.

But they can force the coequal Executive Branch?

Are you sure?

 

[playtime]

But they can force the coequal Executive Branch?

force donny to comply with a law already on the books? of course.

Are you sure?

sí

 

[BasicHumanUnit]

Can a Federal Judge order Schumer to end his shutdown?​

Probably not.
And whether or not a judge can order the Executive branch to resume snap or not,
I'm personally way past sick and tired of subsidizing these arrogant, entitled imbeciles while they spend taxpayer money on the very finest foods AND JUNK FOODS while hard working Americans must take what they can get and work within a tight budget.

THIS IS WRONG! The American people are FOOLS to tolerate this abuse.

FAR too many of these people getting lavish taxpayer benefits are abusing the system and laughing about it.
The government is totally fucked up to be allowing taxpayers to BUY VOTERS FOR DEMOCRATS. And that is ALL it is.

It is unsustainable, harmful to the welfare of the NATION and morally bankrupt.
Those who TRULY need the assistance can't get it often times because of the rampant abuse.

 

[struth]

force donny to comply with a law already on the books? of course.



sí

What law?

 

[WorldWatcher]

LOL....At this point the vile dems would welcome any exit ramp, even if it was bogus.

Flight cuts of 10% start today.

There should be no 10% flight cuts today.

There should have been NO flights starting October 1st.

WW

 

[WorldWatcher]

I disagree

A judge can order Schumer same way a Judge ordered Trump to pay SNAP

No. One is ordering a Senator to vote in a certain way. The other is basically a "writ of mandamus" which is an order to a government official to preform their required duties.

But that difference will escape some.

WW

 

[CrusaderFrank]

force donny to comply with a law already on the books? of course.



sí

What law on the books? You're talking as if Schumer ended his inhumane Shutdown

 

[CrusaderFrank]

No. One is ordering a Senator to vote in a certain way. The other is basically a "writ of mandamus" which is an order to a government official to preform their required duties.

But that difference will escape some.

WW

But a Federal Judge can order a Senator in much the same way that he can order the Executive Branch, right?

 

[WorldWatcher]

But a Federal Judge can order a Senator in much the same way that he can order the Executive Branch, right?

No. One is ordering a Senator to vote in a certain way. The other is basically a "writ of mandamus" which is an order to a government official to preform their required duties.

Not even close to the same.

The Senators are doing their duty, they are voting.

WW

 

[struth]

No. One is ordering a Senator to vote in a certain way. The other is basically a "writ of mandamus" which is an order to a government official to preform their required duties.

But that difference will escape some.

WW

There was no writ of mandamus issued by a court to trump

 

[playtime]

What law?

<ahem>

October 27, 2025
| Dottie Rosenbaum

SNAP’s Contingency Reserve Is Available for Regular SNAP Benefits, as USDA and OMB Have Ruled in Past​

The Trump Administration recently claimed that SNAP benefits are not available for November 2025 because SNAP’s “contingency funds are not legally available to cover regular benefits.”[1] This stands in opposition to the law and prior practice, including by the Trump Administration itself...

https://www.cbpp.org/research/food-...s-available-for-regular-snap-benefits-as-usda

yer welcome.

 

[CrusaderFrank]

No. One is ordering a Senator to vote in a certain way. The other is basically a "writ of mandamus" which is an order to a government official to preform their required duties.

Not even close to the same.

The Senators are doing their duty, they are voting.

WW

But you believe that Judges can order POTUS to just spend money anyway the wind blows without Congressional approval

 

[WorldWatcher]

But you believe that Judges can order POTUS to just spend money anyway the wind blows without Congressional approval

Congress did approve the money the Judge ordered be spent.

When has "Congressional Approval" (or lack thereof) stopped Trump before?

Last time he was in office he took money that was approve by Congress for military families and spent it on his wall - that Congress hadn't approved. So I would suggest not getting high and mightily about Trump needing Congresses approval.

WW

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

Can a Federal Judge order Schumer to end his shutdown?

Instead of ordering Trump to act like a King and spend money he doesn’t have, any Federal Judge can order Schumer and all democrat Senators to vote for the CR

Crisis averted

No, a judge cannot force Congress to vote for a bill.

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

But a Federal Judge can order a Senator in much the same way that he can order the Executive Branch, right?

Correct, a judge can rule a law is unconstitutional.

Just as a judge can rule an EO is unconstitutional.

 

[CrusaderFrank]

Congress did approve the money the Judge ordered be spent.

When has "Congressional Approval" (or lack thereof) stopped Trump before?

Last time he was in office he took money that was approve by Congress for military families and spent it on his wall - that Congress hadn't approved. So I would suggest not getting high and mightily about Trump needing Congresses approval.

WW

Wait, Congress approved it? The Schumer Shutdown ended? Schumer and the dems gave up their suffering poor people leverage?

 

[CrusaderFrank]

Correct, a judge can rule a law is unconstitutional.

Just as a judge can rule an EO is unconstitutional.

So a Judge CAN order Schumer to end the shutdown

Good to know

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

Wait, Congress approved it? The Schumer Shutdown ended? Schumer and the dems gave up their suffering poor people leverage?

Frank, be polite and at least exercise a minimum of mental effort, so you don't waste people's time.

 

[struth]

Congress did approve the money the Judge ordered be spent.

When has "Congressional Approval" (or lack thereof) stopped Trump before?

Last time he was in office he took money that was approve by Congress for military families and spent it on his wall - that Congress hadn't approved. So I would suggest not getting high and mightily about Trump needing Congresses approval.

WW

The court ruled trump could use money approved by Congress for defense to build a wall for defense

Court allows border-wall construction to continue

The Supreme Court on Friday turned down a plea from opponents of President Donald Trump’s border wall to order a temporary stop to construction. By a vote of 5-4, the […]

www.scotusblog.com

 

[Fort Fun Indiana]

So a Judge CAN order Schumer to end the shutdown

That isn't what I said or implied.

Frank, don't add "shameless, lying troll" to your already dubious resumé.

A judge can rule a law to be unconstitutional.

If you would like to connect the dots to how that is the equivalent of ordering and end to the shutdown, be my guest. But don't be a mewling little prick and say that I stated or implied it.