You republicans keep changing your story, to stay consistent with the latest mccain flip flop.
Doesn't matter if the withdrawl time table is a hard date or a soft date. Mere months ago, republicans were telling us that if we gave any day whatsoever, the insurgents would just lie low and wait for us to leave. If you give them a soft date, its the same damn thing. Once the date becomes public knowlege, according to Bush apologists, the insurgents could just lay low and not attack until we leave.
It doesn't matter if the shooting stops tommorow, or ten years from now. This was an abject failure. We spent a trillion dollars to replace a secular, anti-iranian iraqi government, with a theocratic-leaning, nominally pro-iranian government. And we didn't find WMD. At the cost of a trillion dollars and thousands of lives.
That's not a victory by any measure. That's an abject clusterfuck, and a waste of the nation's blood and treasure.