You attempted to have a philosophical discussion and asked people to put aside their personal biases. That was your first mistake.
As to the actual question/topic, I think the bot is correct to a point, but, as you indicate, the point is narrow and does ignore any potential nuance, giving these generalized responses, which are typical responses to the question, but the bot has trouble identifying, of course, how these parties have changed and are changing, how some of these issues overlap, and how the fringe elements in both parties have far too much input ino their party politics and, therefore politics itself, and really do not represent the actual beliefs of most of the people in these respective parties.
Pretty decent though, overall. Kind of a Cliff Notes, 10,000 ft. view version, if you will.