Are Atheists able to use rational thought, deductive reasoning, and scrupulous logic to substantiate and legitimize their perceptions? Or are they simply lacking a perception that most people experience without the need for rationalization? Are they spiritually dumb?
So because we don't feel the feeling you and the masses feel, we are spiritually dumb?
Smart person X believes in god or ‘You are not qualified’.
Ad hominem +
Argument from Authority.
Invisible pink unicorns exist. You’re not an expert in them, so you can’t say they don’t.
The validity of a claim, such as the existence of god, is not governed by the intelligence of the minds which hold it. Evidence and reason are the deciding factors.
Sir Isaac Newton, one of history’s greatest scientists, was not only
intensely religious but also believed in
alchemical transmutation. Alchemy is, however, fully incorrect given our modern understanding of chemistry, the atom and nucleosynthysis.
The fact that an intelligent person holds an irrational belief is simply evidence that our brains are able to
compartmentalise world-views and models from one another, usually in order to maintain a state of ‘ignorant bliss’ and escape the discomfort of
cognitive dissonance.