Alberta USA??

How would Ottowa view this? What could they do to stop it? If Alberta agreed to it and got the protection of the United States military how would Canada react? If Alberta agreed to it and the rest of Canada interfered how would Alberta react?

A referendum probably fails, but the rest of Canada has to stop preventing them from drilling for oil. I've said for 20 years that it makes no sense to just leave the cash sitting in the ground when it can be drilled safely and without much of an environmental footprint.

I think Carney understands this.
 
How would Ottowa view this? What could they do to stop it? If Alberta agreed to it and got the protection of the United States military how would Canada react? If Alberta agreed to it and the rest of Canada interfered how would Alberta react?

It can still happen. Saskatchewan, Alberta, British Columbia Nova Scotia and New Brunswick have been stepchildren to Ottawa for generations.
 
It can still happen. Saskatchewan, Alberta, British Columbia Nova Scotia and New Brunswick have been stepchildren to Ottawa for generations.
Geez that's a lot of geography
 
The US can't even get Puerto Rico, a part of the US, to be a state of the US. How are they going to get Alberta in as a state?
Kind of a fair question but not worded well. The US as a whole does not want Puerto Rico to be a state. Democrats did, because it would help their party. Same with DC. With all of the laws involved in actually forming a state, both parties would have to agree to do it. The most likely way would be to form TWO states at the same time, one red and one blue. But, even then the total representation would have to work out to the point that neither side loses or it doesn't get done. There is unlikely to be a 51st state anytime soon. But, territories are another issue. Republicans will never allow another blue state to form and vice versa.
 
Kind of a fair question but not worded well. The US as a whole does not want Puerto Rico to be a state. Democrats did, because it would help their party. Same with DC. With all of the laws involved in actually forming a state, both parties would have to agree to do it. The most likely way would be to form TWO states at the same time, one red and one blue. But, even then the total representation would have to work out to the point that neither side loses or it doesn't get done. There is unlikely to be a 51st state anytime soon. But, territories are another issue. Republicans will never allow another blue state to form and vice versa.
~~~~~~
Seems that only 23% of Puerto Rico is interested in becoming a State of the U.S/
 
How would Ottowa view this? What could they do to stop it? If Alberta agreed to it and got the protection of the United States military how would Canada react? If Alberta agreed to it and the rest of Canada interfered how would Alberta react?

Interesting concept but I doubt it will obtain serious legs. Canucks overall seem to really like being Canadians.

I wonder though that if Alberta did secede, would Canada have a civil war to prevent that as the USA did in mid 19th Century?
 
Interesting concept but I doubt it will obtain serious legs. Canucks overall seem to really like being Canadians.

I wonder though that if Alberta did secede, would Canada have a civil war to prevent that as the USA did in mid 19th Century?
Well.... Quebec is a very independent place that frequently gives Ottawa the finger.
 
The US can't even get Puerto Rico, a part of the US, to be a state of the US. How are they going to get Alberta in as a state?
Puerto Rico is way the hell out there in the Caribbean with several significantly inhabited islands between it and the USA. Technically it should be part of South America, maybe Venezuela, instead of North America. I don't see it as a U.S. state. And so far, for the most part, neither does Puerto Rico.

And I seriously doubt, even in Alberta, there are enough Canadians who want to be Americans for any serious legislation re secession to gain public support. Or in Ottawa.
 
Last edited:
How would Ottowa view this? What could they do to stop it? If Alberta agreed to it and got the protection of the United States military how would Canada react? If Alberta agreed to it and the rest of Canada interfered how would Alberta react?


Recent polls says that only 36% of Albertans want to separate from Canada.

Alberta is in no position to vote for this because nearly the entire Province is subject to Native land treaties and claims, and the Canadian indigenous people will NEVER vote to be part of the USA. I've attached a map:

 
15th post

New Topics

Back
Top Bottom