First measles death reported in Texas as Kennedy downplays the outbreak
Dr. Lara Johnson, a pediatrician and the chief medical officer at Covenant Children’s Hospital in Lubbock, said during a news conference Wednesday afternoon that the patients who were hospitalized were admitted because they were having trouble breathing and needed supportive care such as supplemental oxygen.
"We don’t hospitalize patients for quarantine purposes," Johnson said.
She added that her team has cared for “around 20” kids with measles so far. Several of those patients required intensive care. None of the hospitalized had been vaccinated against measles.
At least 124 people have been infected in the fast-spreading outbreak. Health and Human Services secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said, “we have measles outbreaks every year.”
www.nbcnews.com
Again, context matters.
There is a difference between "downplaying" the outbreak vs. telling people that it has happened before - in order to avoid hysteria.
The irony is that the same publications that accused Kennedy of "downplaying the outbreak" called it an "outbreak".
RFK Jr, on the other hand, called it "an epidemic".
His exact words:
“
We are following the measles epidemic every day. I think there's 124 people who have contracted measles at this point, mainly in Gaines County, Texas, mainly, we're told in the Mennonite community,”
If "Following it
every day" and calling it "an
epidemic" is considered "downplaying it"- then calling it a
simple "outbreak" is what?
Personally, I'm ok with calling it either an outbreak or an epidemic but if the media wants to play "word games" and take quotes out of context -
then we can do this all day long. I prefer not to because it only leads to further discord and division.
As far as saying the 20 people that were hospitalized were there mainly for "quarantine reasons" he likely misspoke.
That said, the outbreak was mostly in a certain area, among the Mennonite community. Most people may not be aware but the Mennonite community is essentially a branch of the Amish. The Amish/Mennonite communities historically only use hospitals when absolutely necessary. So if RFK Jr. was getting information from people within the Mennonite community, there is a good chance he would have been told that the people who were hospitalized were there mainly for "quarantine reasons" vs getting extensive medical care.
To be clear: I have no idea if this is the case or not - I am simply pointing out "how" that sort of thought process could enter his mind.
But that said, RFK Jr. is on the national stage now - and everything he says or does will be scrutinized - even if it is as simple as a "misspoken" quote. It's not his first rodeo so I'm sure he'll learn from this and move forward - it's not as "big of a deal" as some try to make it out to be, imo.