Come now, quit trying to score points with irrelevant and erroneous information.
I wrote that the Soviet Union was transformed from being communist from within and without bloodshed. You would have us believe it was due to Ronald Reagan saying, "Mt Gorbachev, tear down this wall!" Ha Ha Ha
Absolutely none of the uprisings you mention brought reforms to East Germany, Poland, Hungary or Czechoslovakia. Peaceful revolutions happened in those countries as I wrote, only after reforms came to Russia. You would have us believe that the Stasi stood down because of the 1953 trouble. LOL
this is one reason why I can't be civil with you guys, you are liars.
I would 'have you believe' it was Reagan? I never mentioned the man, its right here in black and white letters, I never mentioned anything about him you liar. I said the shitty socialist economy failed and Americans footed the bill for 50 years in defense of you to wait it out, that is why Gorby wanted reforms. He wanted prosperity and better relations.
I am actually sorry that I paid my tax dollars to make your place better, I wish we would have stayed home and let you deal with hitler and Stalin yourself. I wish that because of people like you
Are you calling me a liar?
I first posted this:
'the fall of the Soviet Union was all about a failure of its socialist economy and the American military determination to defend Europe'
To which you responded:
"You would have us believe it was due to Ronald Reagan saying, "Mt Gorbachev, tear down this wall!""
Tell you what, I'll let you pick. If you deliberately distorted what I said then you are a liar, if you did it because you can't understand then you are an incompetent. Logically it is one of those two, your choice
I claimed that the Soviet Union system of government changed in a bloodless revolution. Why? Because the economy was failing. You were incorrect to describe the economy of the Soviet Union as "socialist". It was a command economy.
However, I have read enough American editorials and heard enough Americans to know that they believe they won the Cold War. Your argument was the same by your claim that somehow the Americans won because of their determination. This is the claim that I find funny. I have heard so many American politicians seriously claim this almost always due to Ronald Reagan. They actually and I suppose seriously believe that there was no agency of the German people themselves to reject the system they lived under and it was they themselves who tore down the wall which was symbolic of tearing down their authoritarian government which was underpinned by the Soviets.
The Americans played no part in East Germany's reunification of the German people. So, I caricatured your thinking that somehow American military might had any part in East Germans' rejection of the GDR by mentioning Ronald Reagan as a symbol of American military strength as if the German and Russian people had no agency. No, it was not due to the Americans but to the Russian people and the East German people as well as the people of other east European countries to revolt peacefully against their governments. This was a massive destruction of a system from within as I had originally said.
By the way, you will hear only Americans write and say things as you did. It is a distortion of history. The Russian people as well as those in eastern Europe did have agency. Without their choice of democracy and freedom, there would have been no bloodless revolts (with the notable exception of Romania). You missed that I mentioned Ronald Reagan as an image of American thinking, such as yours. I never claimed that you mentioned Ronald Reagan. Note my words which were carefully chosen ...
You would have us believe. Not you
actually believe.
So, I did not lie and I understand very well what you were claiming about the American agency. I am neither a liar nor incompetent but I confess to being somewhat wry.