Porter Rockwell
Gold Member
- Dec 14, 2018
- 6,088
- 666
- 140
- Banned
- #361
natural rights are recognized and secured in State Constitutions and available via Due Process not our Second Amendment.Thank you for finally recognizing that legal fact.It is due to our federal form of Government. The several States of our Union are sovereign within their jurisdiction, with the general Government handling inter-State and inter-national stuff.Why do you believe the government needs a second amendment right?
To provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such Part of them as may be employed in the Service of the United States, reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of training the Militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress;
The individual Right to keep and bear Arms and the militia are two separate and distinct issues.
There is no provision for natural rights and individual rights in our Second Article of Amendment. All terms are expressly collective and plural.
The first clause must command the second clause.
Now, you're back to talking nonsense.
There are two parts to the Second Amendment, the NEED to insure the security of a free state AND an ACKNOWLEDGEMENT by the government to guarantee a preexisting Right.
YOU NEED SOME NEW MATERIAL.
Simon already told me You are wrong, even If hell freezes over.Well regulated militia have literal recourse to our Second Amendment in Any conflict of laws.well regulated militia are declared necessary to the security of a free State.Well. It was defined at the time. The Militia was every able bodied free man.
The MILITIA was what was intended to be regulated, not the firearms... AND under your theory regulated firearms means registration, limitations, etc.
natural and individual rights are recognized and secured in State Constitutions and available via Due Process in federal venues.
Asked, answered and refuted dannyboy. You need some new material. You're going to force me to become repetitive.
You wish I were wrong, but for all the posting you do, you seem to come up short on the facts. You never provide any.