- Nov 14, 2011
- 121,681
- 68,525
- 2,635
So you have not one example that was appealed to the federal courts. Good job commie.
- Kenneth H. Worthy: Worthy v. Barrett, 63 N.C. 199 (1869), appeal dismissed, 76 U.S. 611 (1869) Sheriff is not a federal office.
- William L. Tate: In re Tate, 63 N.C. 308, 309 (1869) Solicitor of the 12th Judicial District is not a federal office.
- J.D. Watkins: Louisiana ex rel. Sandlin v. Watkins, 21 La. Ann. 631 (La. 1869) This on was done prior to the ratification of the 14th amendment. WTF?
- Zebulon B. Vance: The Election Case of Joseph C. Abbott v. Zebulon B. Vance and Matt W. Ransom of North Carolina (1872) Well here's one, they claimed he was ineligible even after receiving a presidential pardon. Also it was never appealed in the federal courts, the guy resigned.
- A.F. Gregory: A Case Under the 14th Amendment, Daily Dispatch Not even going to try to find the story in that mess. Would you care to post the relevant article?
- Victor L. Berger: Cannon’s Precedents, Ch. 157, § 56 A State House seat in not a federal office.
- John H. Christy: Hinds’ Precedents, Ch. 14, § 459 ; Col. John H. Christy Obituary, Calhoun Times (Mar. 3, 1877) This link gave this response: "Forbidden You don't have permission to access this resource", so I can't comment on it.
So you have not one example that was appealed to the federal courts. Good job commie.
Don't have to show that. That wasn't what you asked for.
You asked me to show you court cases which affirmed public seat banishments and I showed that.