The definitive documents of the 1948 war

[P F Tinmore]

How could a non-existent entity have armed forces?

Under the mandate, Britain was supposed to be their defensive force. Britain cut and run leaving Palestinian civilians under the attack of Israel's military.

This is a blunt lie, Under the mandate Britain was supposed to maintain peace , it wasn't their obligation to side with the Palestinians or the Jews. The Arabs and the Jews did not want the British around.
The British tried to reach a peaceful resolution , when they have seen that it is not an option , they got out.
And It was a good decision to leave , why would they stay and risk their lives for people who obviously don't want them there...

'Palestinian civilians under the attack of Israel's military'
Another blunt lie , there was a civil war going on, even before the British left both sides were attacking each other.
Only After the British left the neighboring Arab countries joined the fight to help the Palestinians, with the goal of wiping Israel of the map.

Britain violated the League of Nations covenant. That was the source of violence.

"Civil war" was a term coined by Israel. There was no civil war.

 

[Wolverine1984]

By all means , anything you don't agree with was 'coined by Israel'
How do you know this ? How do you know there were no civil war ? were you there ?

 

[P F Tinmore]

By all means , anything you don't agree with was 'coined by Israel'
How do you know this ? How do you know there were no civil war ? were you there ?

A civil war is when differences between the people of a place turn to war. It is said that it is where brother fights brother. This did not happen in Palestine. The Palestinians were attacked by foreigners and they defended themselves. That is not a civil war.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

By all means , anything you don't agree with was 'coined by Israel'
How do you know this ? How do you know there were no civil war ? were you there ?

A civil war is when differences between the people of a place turn to war. It is said that it is where brother fights brother. This did not happen in Palestine. The Palestinians were attacked by foreigners and they defended themselves. That is not a civil war.

And they and the rest of the Arabs lost.
Get over it.
Or whine for another 60 years and create nothing.

 

[P F Tinmore]

By all means , anything you don't agree with was 'coined by Israel'
How do you know this ? How do you know there were no civil war ? were you there ?

A civil war is when differences between the people of a place turn to war. It is said that it is where brother fights brother. This did not happen in Palestine. The Palestinians were attacked by foreigners and they defended themselves. That is not a civil war.

And they and the rest of the Arabs lost.
Get over it.
Or whine for another 60 years and create nothing.

Don't you have to wait until the war ends before you claim victory?

 

[Wolverine1984]

By all means , anything you don't agree with was 'coined by Israel'
How do you know this ? How do you know there were no civil war ? were you there ?

A civil war is when differences between the people of a place turn to war. It is said that it is where brother fights brother. This did not happen in Palestine. The Palestinians were attacked by foreigners and they defended themselves. That is not a civil war.

The Jews who fought in this civil war were living in the Mandate,they were not an foreign army like you claim.
The war was fought by two apposing factions of the same mandate ,this is by definition a civil war.

The Palestinians were not attacked, you making up a one sided story that does not mach the truth.Tensions were raising between Palestinians and Jews long before 1948, violence was committed by both sides witch escalated to a full out war by 1948.

 

[Toddsterpatriot]

A civil war is when differences between the people of a place turn to war. It is said that it is where brother fights brother. This did not happen in Palestine. The Palestinians were attacked by foreigners and they defended themselves. That is not a civil war.

And they and the rest of the Arabs lost.
Get over it.
Or whine for another 60 years and create nothing.

Don't you have to wait until the war ends before you claim victory?

So you will continue whining.

 

[P F Tinmore]

By all means , anything you don't agree with was 'coined by Israel'
How do you know this ? How do you know there were no civil war ? were you there ?

A civil war is when differences between the people of a place turn to war. It is said that it is where brother fights brother. This did not happen in Palestine. The Palestinians were attacked by foreigners and they defended themselves. That is not a civil war.

The Jews who fought in this civil war were living in the Mandate,they were not an foreign army like you claim.
The war was fought by two apposing factions of the same mandate ,this is by definition a civil war.

The Palestinians were not attacked, you making up a one sided story that does not mach the truth.Tensions were raising between Palestinians and Jews long before 1948, violence was committed by both sides witch escalated to a full out war by 1948.

There were two opposing factions. The Palestinian Muslims, Christians, and Jews were on one side. On the other side were the settlers that the Zionists imported by the boatload to take over the country as was their stated goal. These settlers were financed, armed, and under the control of foreigners.

 

[Wolverine1984]

A civil war is when differences between the people of a place turn to war. It is said that it is where brother fights brother. This did not happen in Palestine. The Palestinians were attacked by foreigners and they defended themselves. That is not a civil war.

The Jews who fought in this civil war were living in the Mandate,they were not an foreign army like you claim.
The war was fought by two apposing factions of the same mandate ,this is by definition a civil war.

The Palestinians were not attacked, you making up a one sided story that does not mach the truth.Tensions were raising between Palestinians and Jews long before 1948, violence was committed by both sides witch escalated to a full out war by 1948.

There were two opposing factions. The Palestinian Muslims, Christians, and Jews were on one side. On the other side were the settlers that the Zionists imported by the boatload to take over the country as was their stated goal. These settlers were financed, armed, and under the control of foreigners.

Are you for real ?
'there were no opposing factions' please ,if there were no factions there would have been no fighting ...
There were 2 opposing factions and they lived under the same mandate , this is civil war , you can remain in denial all you want , this doesn't change the facts...

 

[P F Tinmore]

The Jews who fought in this civil war were living in the Mandate,they were not an foreign army like you claim.
The war was fought by two apposing factions of the same mandate ,this is by definition a civil war.

The Palestinians were not attacked, you making up a one sided story that does not mach the truth.Tensions were raising between Palestinians and Jews long before 1948, violence was committed by both sides witch escalated to a full out war by 1948.

There were two opposing factions. The Palestinian Muslims, Christians, and Jews were on one side. On the other side were the settlers that the Zionists imported by the boatload to take over the country as was their stated goal. These settlers were financed, armed, and under the control of foreigners.

Are you for real ?
'there were no opposing factions' please ,if there were no factions there would have been no fighting ...
There were 2 opposing factions and they lived under the same mandate , this is civil war , you can remain in denial all you want , this doesn't change the facts...

Yeah, there were two factions like I said. The native Palestinians and the Zionist imports.

 

[Wolverine1984]

I'm sorry I thought you said 'There were no factions'.

Either way , the emigrating Jews and the Palestinians lived under the same mandate and started fighting , this is a civil war.

Your statement that the Palestinians were attacked (One sided) does not represent the truth.

 

[P F Tinmore]

I'm sorry I thought you said 'There were no factions'.

Either way , the emigrating Jews and the Palestinians lived under the same mandate and started fighting , this is a civil war.

Your statement that the Palestinians were attacked (One sided) does not represent the truth.

The war was between the Palestinians and the Zionists.

Did the Palestinians go to Europe and attack the Zionists?

 

[Wolverine1984]

I'm sorry I thought you said 'There were no factions'.

Either way , the emigrating Jews and the Palestinians lived under the same mandate and started fighting , this is a civil war.

Your statement that the Palestinians were attacked (One sided) does not represent the truth.

The war was between the Palestinians and the Zionists.

Did the Palestinians go to Europe and attack the Zionists?

Actually they did...

 

[P F Tinmore]

I'm sorry I thought you said 'There were no factions'.

Either way , the emigrating Jews and the Palestinians lived under the same mandate and started fighting , this is a civil war.

Your statement that the Palestinians were attacked (One sided) does not represent the truth.

The war was between the Palestinians and the Zionists.

Did the Palestinians go to Europe and attack the Zionists?

Actually they did...

OK? How so?

 

[Wolverine1984]

Munich massacre - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[P F Tinmore]

Munich massacre - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You can't be serious. That was 50 years after the Zionists started the war on Palestine.

 

[Wolverine1984]

Munich massacre - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You can't be serious. That was 50 years after the Zionists started the war on Palestine.

Oh that makes it OK then.
Besides the Zionist didn't start a war , the violence escalated from both sides, but by all means don't let facts stand in your way.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Munich massacre - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You can't be serious. That was 50 years after the Zionists started the war on Palestine.

Oh that makes it OK then.
Besides the Zionist didn't start a war , the violence escalated from both sides, but by all means don't let facts stand in your way.

Back to my original question.

Did the Palestinians go to Europe and attack the Zionists to create this war?

 

[Wolverine1984]

what does that have to do with anything ?

 

[Jos]

what does that have to do with anything ?

So would you like "50/50" "Ask the audience" "or phone a friend"