- Apr 1, 2011
- 169,997
- 47,201
- 2,180
I think the various tax deductions and credits work very well, and they absolutely do incentivize strategies that put more money in motion.The government shouldn't be deciding which investments are "positive" and which aren't. The government almost never makes good decisions. Whether the rich are willing to pay more is only one question. Some are and some aren't. The real issue is will society benefit by taking their income. It won't. The money taxed away would probably be invested in stocks or in their businesses. All taxing the rich does is reduce economic growth.Graduated income tax rates with deductions and credits incentivize a wide variety of positive, tax-advantaged investment and economic activity that manifest on both national and local levels, and both for individuals and corporations. A flat tax would eliminate all of that positive activity.
Personally, I think we should poll "the rich" on this. I have many advisory clients who are worth seven figures and several worth eight figures. It has been my (admittedly anecdotal) observation that a vast majority of them are perfectly comfortable paying graduated rates, and that even adding a couple of new, higher margins would not cause them to become suicidal or damage the economy.
What some guy screams on the radio is one thing, real life is another.
.
What benefits society is a subjective question. Does a society benefit overall when those who lack the capacity (for any of a wide range of reasons) are provided a higher foundation, even at the expense of a certain amount of economic dynamism? Yeah, I definitely think so.
There is obviously a tipping point there, and going too far in either direction is the problem.
.
They mostly incentivize mal-investment. You're right, what benefits society is subjective. That's why it should be left up to individuals to decide what benefits themselves. Government will never make the correct decision. Whenever it has tried the results are disastrous. The recent housing fiasco is a classic example.