bucs90
Gold Member
- Feb 25, 2010
- 26,545
- 6,027
- 280
This is a tragic accident, asphyxia. It happens when someone is restrained and cannot breathe. It is not intentional.
It says the cops tried to question the man about the disturbance (Which they were SENT to after a 911 all). He refused, and became "uncooperative".
And there is the problem. If the cops are called to something you are involved in (crime or not, he was INVOLVED as he is there with the suspect/victim) they are going to ask you.......I don't know, something like "So what happened? Why did we get called here?"
When you become uncooperative, refuse to provide identification (they need it for their report, which would have said the man was innocent of any crime, not to mention under Terry vs Ohio they have a right to ID the man).........and the cops tell you that you are being detained, how about don't resist?
My God. Its not that hard to just tell the cops whats going on, toss your ID to them real quick, and move along.
99% chance this call would've ended with the cops leaving and clearing it with dispatch saying "Everything 10-4; Parental discipline, back in service".
But no. Someone had to be an idiot, and it leads to a horrible accident.
What should the cops have done? Just say "OH well guys, they aren't cooperating, lets just leave". That's not how it works.
While the cops have a job to do,a concerned citizen would wonder about a few things,1st how long do you think it takes to asphyxiate someone? and where is the training,this should have never happened,period!
To go unconscious, not that long. A minute or so, how ever long you can go without oxygen. Once they pass out, if they are still in the same position, they could die. Sometimes it is mistaken for the suspect going "dead weight" to be a pain in the ass or resist.
They do train for it, but it's hard to see or predict. For one, you cant handcuff them in the front without a belly chain. And those are expensive and hard to apply to a person who is resisting.
The EASY answer is to use a taser, which is 1,000X safer than a hands-on struggle. BUT, the public hates tasers because they look scary. So, cops hesitate to use them.
As for training more, and getting just all around better cops......budget cuts have caused a lot of senior officers to leave the job for private sector jobs. Turnover is high, morale is low. So, most cops are either A) Older cops who don't have the skill/education to do anything else or B) (most often) Young cops with little experience.
To attract, retain and train good cops costs money.
The video link isn't working anymore, so I didn't see this situation.