Shogun
Free: Mudholes Stomped
- Jan 8, 2007
- 30,530
- 2,266
- 1,045
who says that their culture was reflective of your standard regarding governing power structure?
History says. Because those maps you showed me in the 1800s had absolutely nothing to do with my question nor did they prove a native Arab Islamic minority or majority in Israel at the time, nor did any of the maps give a border with a capitol.
For instance, here is an Atlas of Europe from the year 1900. Do you see borders?
What's this? Did you just admit Israel existed during the stone age?
Unfortunately, you're incorrect. Israel did not exist during the stone age, if the common conception that the stone age ended 10,000 years ago.
Israel's history begins around the beginning of the Brozne Age, around 3,300 BC. Of course, you would know this if you actually studied a bit and did research. Like the kind of research that would show you which Emperor re-named Israel into Palestine...
Better yet, you clearly did not comprehend my reference to invalidation due to lack of alphabet and shoes.
Actually, all civilizations have had their own written language starting with the first civilization, the Sumerians. In fact, they even had their own "Bible" the Enûma Eli. I have no idea if they had shoes or not.
But, you know what's interesting, Shogun? The primary language spoken in the territory of "Palestine" from the year the Roman Emperor re-named it all the way through today? Hebrew. Howbaout that? Through Ottoman, Malmuk, Crusader, Arab-Islamic, Roman... it doesn't matter who. The Jews who lived there spoke the same language as Jesus spoke, the same language Moses spoke and the same language Abraham spoke.
How is that possible if the people who lived there were Arab-Islamic? Arabs do not speak any other language primarily other than Arabic, which pre-dates the English language by several centuries.
And before anyone bashes me, yes I know Jesus primarily spoke Aramaic, but he also spoke Hebrew. How else could he have taught the Torah to other fellow Jews?
First off... it's continually HILARIOUS how you keep responding to those 1800s maps. Seriously. I get the feeling that you are about to insist that the word "Palestine" was REALLY Roman for "Land of the JEWS only"
yes I know Jesus primarily spoke Aramaic,
and, if you've managed to take your head out of your ass you'll see that I've never suggested that jews do not have a valid history on that land. Indeed, they do. However, this doesn't mean that no one else does as well and that theirs are not as valid as the jewish claim. They all have historic merit. This is why it's so fun to watch you react to historic maps and the concept of "jews only matter" zionism.
AND, which is why my standard has always been a shared single state of palisrael that is just as much of a homeland for palis as it is for jews.
Now, feel free to cry antisemite or something similarly reflexively laughable.
and, don't lecture me on history, buddy, when you keep insisting that the origin of that land was in any way jewish. WE ALL know where your hiburu ass comes from, Egyptian. Do you think anyone misses how OT Canaan conquering has set up a pattern for ironic jews? You no more came from that land than white people came from North America, originally. THAT is what we call historic fact.
and, EVERY civ had a written language, eh? Might want to share that joke with the ghost of some native american tribes. Hell, there are people RIGHT NOW in tribal africa, south america and Austrailia that don't have a WRITTEN language. But, it's funny that YOU seem to think that everyone does just because one was first developed in the stone age.
ps, i trust that you are about as much a scholar of ancient languages as you've proven to be a master of sociology.
and, just so you know, early hebrew language wasn't at all universal. Hell, there are Zoroaster believers from that same locale who have nothing to do with your blanket jew baby insistance that jews create oxygen and solid ground. See, this is what you get for using the jewish virtual library and the JewPost as your only source reference.