Shusha
Gold Member
- Dec 14, 2015
- 13,245
- 2,287
- 290
P F Tinmore
You claim that immigrating Jews obtained Palestinian citizenship. This was true from 1924 onwards. The Jewish people living in the territory of Palestine in 1948, then, according to your own argument, were Palestinian citizens. When the five Arab armies attacked -- they were attacking the citizens of Palestine (but only the Jewish ones). The Arab citizens of Palestine also attacked the citizens of Palestine (but only the Jewish ones).
That makes the war of 1948 a civil war between citizens of Palestine as well as an international war between sovereigns, according to your own argument.
You claim that immigrating Jews obtained Palestinian citizenship. This was true from 1924 onwards. The Jewish people living in the territory of Palestine in 1948, then, according to your own argument, were Palestinian citizens. When the five Arab armies attacked -- they were attacking the citizens of Palestine (but only the Jewish ones). The Arab citizens of Palestine also attacked the citizens of Palestine (but only the Jewish ones).
That makes the war of 1948 a civil war between citizens of Palestine as well as an international war between sovereigns, according to your own argument.