I agree with a playoff, too. But there's still going to have to be subjectivity.
It starts and stops with the BCS rankings.....don't like it? See, you don't like voting and polls.
So what if there are 3 SEC teams in the BCS Top 8? Or, as it stands, if South Carolina wins the SEC Championship, they still wouldn't be in the BCS Top 8. They'd be left out.
The top 8 get in.....is that clear to you, or what aren't you understanding? South Carolina would get into another bowl game. Why are you playing the "what if" game? What if the world came to an end the night before the championship game....who would get the title? See how you can play the "what if" game?