% of US slaves who were black

What percentage of US slaves were black?

  • 100 - 90

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • 89 - 50

    Votes: 6 50.0%
  • 49 - 20

    Votes: 2 16.7%
  • <20

    Votes: 3 25.0%

  • Total voters
    12

Muhammed

Diamond Member
Dec 20, 2010
31,758
17,932
1,915
North Coast, USA
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.
 
PS: convicts...

The joke about Australia is that it was founded by a bunch of criminals. And from 1788 until 1868, Britain did send roughly 164,000 convicts to the land down under. America's dirty little secret? The same exact thing was happening here. In fact, experts estimate that over 52,000 British prisoners were shipped off to colonial America.

Britain had been shipping convicts to America for decades before they started sending them to Australia. In fact, it was precisely because of America's fight for independence that the Brits had to start sending their criminals to Australia. But from 1718 until 1775, convict transportation to the American colonies flourished. Some estimates claim that almost 10 per cent of migrants to America during this time were British convicts.



Britain Sent Loads Of Convicts To America, Not Just Australia

Greg
 
PS: convicts...

The joke about Australia is that it was founded by a bunch of criminals. And from 1788 until 1868, Britain did send roughly 164,000 convicts to the land down under. America's dirty little secret? The same exact thing was happening here. In fact, experts estimate that over 52,000 British prisoners were shipped off to colonial America.

Britain had been shipping convicts to America for decades before they started sending them to Australia. In fact, it was precisely because of America's fight for independence that the Brits had to start sending their criminals to Australia. But from 1718 until 1775, convict transportation to the American colonies flourished. Some estimates claim that almost 10 per cent of migrants to America during this time were British convicts.



Britain Sent Loads Of Convicts To America, Not Just Australia

Greg
Democrat US presidents enslaved millions who were not convicts.

For instance, Wilson enslaved both of my great grandfathers. And they were not black.
 
Last edited:
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.
Is this while the Country was under British Rule or after the Formation of the Constitution?

White slavery in the US
Looking at the large historical picture, this was not true. In fact, taking slavery as a percentage of the total population into account, there have been more white slaves than black throughout history. The first 'slaves' taken to work plantations in the American colonies, for example, were in fact white.
Why were there more black slaves to white slaves - Answers
www.answers.com/Q/Why_were_there_more_black_slaves_to_white_slaves
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.
Is this while the Country was under British Rule or after the Formation of the Constitution?

White slavery in the US
Looking at the large historical picture, this was not true. In fact, taking slavery as a percentage of the total population into account, there have been more white slaves than black throughout history. The first 'slaves' taken to work plantations in the American colonies, for example, were in fact white.
Why were there more black slaves to white slaves - Answers
www.answers.com/Q/Why_were_there_more_black_slaves_to_white_slaves
It is rather generalized..
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.
Is this while the Country was under British Rule or after the Formation of the Constitution?

White slavery in the US
Looking at the large historical picture, this was not true. In fact, taking slavery as a percentage of the total population into account, there have been more white slaves than black throughout history. The first 'slaves' taken to work plantations in the American colonies, for example, were in fact white.
Why were there more black slaves to white slaves - Answers
www.answers.com/Q/Why_were_there_more_black_slaves_to_white_slaves
The USA.
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.
Is this while the Country was under British Rule or after the Formation of the Constitution?

White slavery in the US
Looking at the large historical picture, this was not true. In fact, taking slavery as a percentage of the total population into account, there have been more white slaves than black throughout history. The first 'slaves' taken to work plantations in the American colonies, for example, were in fact white.
Why were there more black slaves to white slaves - Answers
www.answers.com/Q/Why_were_there_more_black_slaves_to_white_slaves
The USA.
Does that also include the slaves of redskins that would be taken by another tribe? Is that counted in your survey?
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.
I feel certain that most think it is 90-100%. If we find that it is different, that fact should be widely corrected. It would be interesting to find that Britons and Indians were in the mix and they have been able to refrain from blaming all their ills on their past history! Blacks blame all of their failures on slavery several decades ago while others "pull themselves up with their bootstraps" and became productive citizens in the US.
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.

This could be a difficult one.

Mexicans held Indians as slaves.

The first case of a runaway slave in the U.S. was a white man with a black master

Many whites came to America as slaves - the very word kidnap comes from a time when kids in Britain were being whisked off the streets and "kid nabbed" for ship labor and then sold in the U.S.
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.

This could be a difficult one.

Mexicans held Indians as slaves.

The first case of a runaway slave in the U.S. was a white man with a black master

Many whites came to America as slaves - the very word kidnap comes from a time when kids in Britain were being whisked off the streets and "kid nabbed" for ship labor and then sold in the U.S.
But that was before the US won its FREEDOM from British Rule. Damn, didnt that make all Americans slaves to the king of England? I think it did.
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.

This could be a difficult one.

Mexicans held Indians as slaves.

The first case of a runaway slave in the U.S. was a white man with a black master

Many whites came to America as slaves - the very word kidnap comes from a time when kids in Britain were being whisked off the streets and "kid nabbed" for ship labor and then sold in the U.S.
But that was before the US won its FREEDOM from British Rule. Damn, didnt that make all Americans slaves to the king of England? I think it did.

That's why I said this would be a difficult one. A black man was the first slave owner in the United States. So, from what year do we start counting and what classes of slaves are included?

If you're a liberal, you begin when the most blacks were the slaves.
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.

This could be a difficult one.

Mexicans held Indians as slaves.

The first case of a runaway slave in the U.S. was a white man with a black master

Many whites came to America as slaves - the very word kidnap comes from a time when kids in Britain were being whisked off the streets and "kid nabbed" for ship labor and then sold in the U.S.
But that was before the US won its FREEDOM from British Rule. Damn, didnt that make all Americans slaves to the king of England? I think it did.

That's why I said this would be a difficult one. A black man was the first slave owner in the United States. So, from what year do we start counting and what classes of slaves are included?

If you're a liberal, you begin when the most blacks were the slaves.
No he wasn't.
 
All of them


I don’t want to hear any crap that indentured servants were slaves
 
History test:

How many of you here believe that the majority of slaves in the US were black?

Please provide an argument to support your opinion.

This could be a difficult one.

Mexicans held Indians as slaves.

The first case of a runaway slave in the U.S. was a white man with a black master

Many whites came to America as slaves - the very word kidnap comes from a time when kids in Britain were being whisked off the streets and "kid nabbed" for ship labor and then sold in the U.S.
But that was before the US won its FREEDOM from British Rule. Damn, didnt that make all Americans slaves to the king of England? I think it did.

That's why I said this would be a difficult one. A black man was the first slave owner in the United States. So, from what year do we start counting and what classes of slaves are included?

If you're a liberal, you begin when the most blacks were the slaves.
No he wasnt.
 

Forum List

Back
Top