Si modo
Diamond Member
It's never illogical to imagine, but logic is not based on unsupported claims, otherwise known as "cheap talk".In a court of law...and that's presumed innocent. But, logically, yes. Also, logically, her claim is presumed bullshit until supported.Since when does a person have to prove their innocence? Isn't she innocent until proven guilty?
It's illogical to imagine that a 65 year old woman might ever get sick? Make that argument.
Logic also means that if the claim is made, the burden is on the claimer to support it. Otherwise it is just as rational to think it's a bullshit claim as it is to believe it.
Cheap talk.