Furor Surrounding Ilhan Omar Remarks Intensifies National Debate Over Israel

Palestinians were the majority and had the majority of the land before 1948.

Interesting how progressives reject minority rights when the minority is Jews.
I'm not a progressive, and what has occupying a land has to do with a majority or a minority ?
Palestinians were massacred and pushed out of their homes and still face the same treatment as we speak...and Jews from NYC, Europe and elsewhere come in are given arms and a land of Palestinians.
 
Last edited:
The mistreatment of Palestinians has been an ongoing problem.

Israel: 50 Years of Occupation Abuses

The Palestinians spent 20 years under Jordanian and Egyptian control where they were starved, killed, and marginalized.

Jordan killed 4,000 Jordanian Palestinians in 1970 and 1971.

I don't see any proportional outrage here.

It would be helpful if you could provide credible proof of your claims - along with relevant context.


The ignorance is stunning. Have you ever wondered why no Arab Nation wants the Palestinians? Wow.....just wow. And Isreal is the bad guy?

Please educate yourself. Black September - Wikipedia
I'm sorry but your claim is wrong....Palestinians live in most Arab countries, and they were always welcomed....there are still to this day Palestinian refuge camps since the 1948 (Lebanon, Syria, Jordan....).



Wrong. Both Jordan and Saudi Arabia will not accept Palestinian refuges and have not for decades. If things are as bad as you and others state than why don't Palestinians immigrate to other Arab countries? The answer is because they are not wanted.
That's why I dont like to discuss this issue with most cons, you have 0 clue about it apart from what AIPAC media tells you.
1 in 2 Jordanians is a Palestinian....Saudi Arabia welcomed thousands of Palestinians as well, so did most of the Arabic countries.
 
Last edited:
Activists have been criticizing Israeli policies towards Palestinians long before the Minnesota congresswoman.

NEW YORK (AP) — For Congress, the allegations of anti-Semitism directed toward Rep. Ilhan Omar have no precedent. Yet on college campuses, in state legislatures and in many other venues nationwide, the polarized debate about Israel is a familiar conflict and likely to intensify in the months and years ahead.

Fueled by a wave of youthful activists, including many Jews aligning with Muslims, criticism of Israel’s policies toward the Palestinians has grown in volume and scope, with persistent calls for boycotts and disinvestment. Pro-Israel organizations and politicians have countered with tough responses, and efforts to reconcile the differences have gained little traction.

Among those fearing escalation is Deborah Lipstadt, a history professor at Emory University and author of a new book, “Antisemitism: Here and Now,” about the recent resurgence of anti-Semitism in the United States and Europe. She calls herself an optimist, but she says it’s hard to be hopeful in the current political climate.

“Leaders on the left and the right are using this phenomenon as a way of drumming up support, claiming they’re victims,” she said. “I fear it will get far worse before it gets better.”

Congress has never experienced this kind of furor involving a Muslim member accused of anti-Semitism.

Omar, a freshman congresswoman from Minnesota, sparked turmoil within the Democratic caucus with her criticisms of Israel and suggestions that Israel’s supporters wanted lawmakers to pledge “allegiance” to a foreign country. Divided Democrats eventually drafted a resolution that condemned a wide range of bigotry and did not mention Omar by name.

One of the first two Muslim women in Congress, Omar supports a contentious part of the overall dispute — the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement, or BDS, which promotes various forms of boycotts against Israel.

More: Furor Surrounding Ilhan Omar Remarks Intensifies National Debate Over Israel

This is a debate worth having - and long overdue. Arabs are also Semites, so anti-Semitism also applies to Palestinians. Does anyone not think that Palestinians have been discriminated against? What do you think?
Omar, a freshman congresswoman from Minnesota, sparked turmoil within the Democratic caucus with her criticisms of Israel and suggestions that Israel’s supporters wanted lawmakers to pledge “allegiance” to a foreign country. Divided Democrats eventually drafted a resolution that condemned a wide range of bigotry and did not mention Omar by name.
Anyone in doubt of Omar's criticisms doesn't have to look any further than S. 170 Combating BDS Act of 2017

"It is, for instance, beyond dispute that what Omar is saying is true given that the very first bill passed by the U.S. Senate this year was one that allowed punishment for American citizens who boycott Israel, while U.S. citizens in 26 states are formally punished for boycotting this foreign nation, as we reported last month in the case of a Texas elementary speech pathologist who lost her job for refusing to sign a pledge not to boycott Israel (to keep her job with Texas, she’s allowed to boycott any other nation or even an American state: just not this one favored foreign nation)."

The House Democrats’ “Rebuke” of Rep. Ilhan Omar Is a Fraud for Many Reasons, Including Its Wild Distortion of Her Comments
 
Trump tells a group of Jewish businessmen that they won't vote for him because he doesn't need their money silence

Trump says there are "Good people on both sides" of the Charlottesville United the Right rally in which neonazies marched around with torches shouting anti-semitic chants and eventually killed a woman again...silence

A right wing crazy shoots up a synagogue ... not quite silence but hardly any criticism of Trump's incitement of this kind of thing see above

Kevin McCarthy tweets at three Jewish business with anti-semitic tropes silence

Jim Jordan tweets out an attack of a Jewish businessman and Presidential candidate and replaces the S that begins his last name with a dollar sign silence

Ilan Omar tweets out a criticism of a Jewish lobbying group and others pointing out the power of the Israeli government in our politics...and all of a sudden the Democratic Party has an "anti-semite problem"

Oh...
 
The prime minister addressed “slightly confused people” after an Israeli celebrity defended the rights of Israel’s Arab population.

JERUSALEM (AP) — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says Israel is the homeland “only of the Jewish people,” in a new jab at the country’s Arab minority ahead of April’s election.

Netanyahu on Sunday addressed “slightly confused people” after an Israeli celebrity defended the rights of Israel’s Arab population. Arabs comprise about 20 percent of Israel’s 9 million residents. They have full citizenship rights but have faced decades of discrimination.

More: Netanyahu: Israel Is The National State 'Only Of The Jewish People'

Nutanyahoo and his hardliners are a major part of the problem in Israel. Voters can do better.



Funny......Palestinians in Israel have citizenship but in Arab Countries they do not. Yeah.....I guess Israel is really evil. Again...please educate yourself. This is getting painfully.


"Virtually all Arab countries host some Palestinian refugees. What they have declined to do is grant those Palestinians and their descendants full citizenship - as a result, Palestinians living in the Arab world endure miserable living and working conditions."


/Why-do-Arab-Nations-refuse-to-allow-Palestinians-to-migrate-to-neighboring-Arab-Nations-and-become-citizens
 
The prime minister addressed “slightly confused people” after an Israeli celebrity defended the rights of Israel’s Arab population.

JERUSALEM (AP) — Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says Israel is the homeland “only of the Jewish people,” in a new jab at the country’s Arab minority ahead of April’s election.

Netanyahu on Sunday addressed “slightly confused people” after an Israeli celebrity defended the rights of Israel’s Arab population. Arabs comprise about 20 percent of Israel’s 9 million residents. They have full citizenship rights but have faced decades of discrimination.

More: Netanyahu: Israel Is The National State 'Only Of The Jewish People'

Nutanyahoo and his hardliners are a major part of the problem in Israel. Voters can do better.



Funny......Palestinians in Israel have citizenship but in Arab Countries they do not. Yeah.....I guess Israel is really evil. Again...please educate yourself. This is getting painfully.


"Virtually all Arab countries host some Palestinian refugees. What they have declined to do is grant those Palestinians and their descendants full citizenship - as a result, Palestinians living in the Arab world endure miserable living and working conditions."


/Why-do-Arab-Nations-refuse-to-allow-Palestinians-to-migrate-to-neighboring-Arab-Nations-and-become-citizens
And the 3 million in the West Bank? Do they have citizenship?

WIll they ever?
 

Forum List

Back
Top