This concludes the demonstration of muslim proof.
It doesn’t hold up to scrutiny of any kind.
Mr.Kalam posted 1 thing that was contradicted at the bottom of the page he didn’t include a link to, then he repudiated his proof and added another source which was contradicted in the same document .Which he would not give a link to.
Mr.kalam when confronted with the evidence. Slings insults
claims offense and secret superior knowledge .
He is willing to teach ,if I'll just stop wiggling in my seat.
Its a good but transparent play, invent some high moral ground.
His gambit, no will read the evidence from his sources and in most cases he will be correct.
People want their knowledge predigested delivered in convenient small bites.
And they don’t want to hear anything that contradicts their preconceived notions.
If you want to know what Islam is about, you can be lead down a garden path by people like Mr.Kalam or you have to read the "scripture " and you have to read the "scripture "in order it was concocted in and in the context of the day to day life of Islam’s only "prophet".
I recommend reading Guillaume’s book first then reading the Quran.and then doing it again and again adding the Tafsirs and all the hadith as you can digest .
That mean opening Author: Ibn Ishaq/A. Guillaume
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Pages: 813 Binding: Hardback
Description from the publisher:
Professor Guillaume's translation of the Sira of Ibn Iss-Haq is now reissued. The translator used Ibn Hisham's abridgement and also included many additions and variants found in the writings of early authors. The book thus presents in English practically all that is known of the life of the Prophet. In the introduction, the translator discusses the character of the Sira in the light of the opinion of early Arabian scholars, noting especially the difficulties of the poetry. As the earliest monument of Arabian prose literature, the Sira remains a work of the first importance.
The Life of Muhammad: Translation of Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah
Sirat Rasoul Allah
Its worth the effort to know for certain, one way or the other.
It doesn’t hold up to scrutiny of any kind.
Mr.Kalam posted 1 thing that was contradicted at the bottom of the page he didn’t include a link to, then he repudiated his proof and added another source which was contradicted in the same document .Which he would not give a link to.
Mr.kalam when confronted with the evidence. Slings insults
claims offense and secret superior knowledge .
He is willing to teach ,if I'll just stop wiggling in my seat.
Its a good but transparent play, invent some high moral ground.
His gambit, no will read the evidence from his sources and in most cases he will be correct.
People want their knowledge predigested delivered in convenient small bites.
And they don’t want to hear anything that contradicts their preconceived notions.
If you want to know what Islam is about, you can be lead down a garden path by people like Mr.Kalam or you have to read the "scripture " and you have to read the "scripture "in order it was concocted in and in the context of the day to day life of Islam’s only "prophet".
I recommend reading Guillaume’s book first then reading the Quran.and then doing it again and again adding the Tafsirs and all the hadith as you can digest .
That mean opening Author: Ibn Ishaq/A. Guillaume
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Pages: 813 Binding: Hardback
Description from the publisher:
Professor Guillaume's translation of the Sira of Ibn Iss-Haq is now reissued. The translator used Ibn Hisham's abridgement and also included many additions and variants found in the writings of early authors. The book thus presents in English practically all that is known of the life of the Prophet. In the introduction, the translator discusses the character of the Sira in the light of the opinion of early Arabian scholars, noting especially the difficulties of the poetry. As the earliest monument of Arabian prose literature, the Sira remains a work of the first importance.
The Life of Muhammad: Translation of Ibn Ishaq's Sirat Rasul Allah
Sirat Rasoul Allah
Its worth the effort to know for certain, one way or the other.
