Did Germany really murder six million Jews in WWI?

[Marŝi tra la Cindro]

Before, during, and after WWI activists and the media accused Germany (among other nations, most notably Russia/the USSR) of the barbaric slaughter of exactly six million Jews. You can still find these claims today. But... Did any of it really happen? The six million figure is well known from Torah prophecy about the restoration of Israel. On a religious level that would have needed to happen to restore the Jewish state even if it didn't happen on a physical level.

 

[BlindBoo]

Nope. They sure didn't. However Hitlers Nazi Germany murdered between 12 and 18 million humans in their labor/death camps, including several million Jewish folks.

There was no Flood that Moses built an Arc for either.

 

[Marŝi tra la Cindro]

Nope. They sure didn't. However Hitlers Nazi Germany murdered between 12 and 18 million humans in their labor/death camps, including several million Jewish folks.

There was no Flood that Moses built an Arc for either.

So you would consider the claims otherwise from before and immediately after WWI to be untrue?

 

[ReinyDays]

There were 9 million Jews in Europe in 1939 ... 3 million Jews in Europe in 1945 ... has your hatred blinded you to simple arithmetic? ...

 

[Marŝi tra la Cindro]

There were 9 million Jews in Europe in 1939 ... 3 million Jews in Europe in 1945 ... has your hatred blinded you to simple arithmetic? ...

So you would assert that the previous claims of six million Jews being killed by the German state in WWI were untrue?

 

[BlindBoo]

Nope. They sure didn't. However Hitlers Nazi Germany murdered between 12 and 18 million humans in their labor/death camps, including several million Jewish folks.

There was no Flood that Moses built an Arc for either.

So you would consider the claims otherwise from before and immediately after WWI to be untrue?

I have seen no reports of widespread or systematic extermination of Jews, Gypsies, and other so call vagrants by Germans immediately following WWI. They didn't start that until after the Nazi's took total power in 1933.

 

[rightwinger]

There were 9 million Jews in Europe in 1939 ... 3 million Jews in Europe in 1945 ... has your hatred blinded you to simple arithmetic? ...

So you would assert that the previous claims of six million Jews being killed by the German state in WWI were untrue?

Never saw any claims of Germany killing six million Jews in WWI

 

[Marŝi tra la Cindro]

I have seen no reports of widespread or systematic extermination of Jews, Gypsies, and other so call vagrants by Germans immediately following WWI. They didn't start that until after the Nazi's took total power in 1933.

Never saw any claims of Germany killing six million Jews in WWI

There are four attached to the OP. Russia was also accused of the same.

 

[rightwinger]

I have seen no reports of widespread or systematic extermination of Jews, Gypsies, and other so call vagrants by Germans immediately following WWI. They didn't start that until after the Nazi's took total power in 1933.

Never saw any claims of Germany killing six million Jews in WWI

There are four attached to the OP. Russia was also accused of the same.

No evidence

Your link says 6 million Jews live there.....not that they were exterminated

 

[Marŝi tra la Cindro]

Besides examples of the media having pushed this narrative, what evidence for the media having pushed this narrative would you accept?

 

[jwoodie]

There were 9 million Jews in Europe in 1939 ... 3 million Jews in Europe in 1945 ... has your hatred blinded you to simple arithmetic? ...

I do not dispute the Nazi death camps, but how were these numbers calculated? Was there an international census? How many were civilian/military war casualties and how many were displaced and/or left Europe?

 

[ReinyDays]

During World War I ... everybody in Europe was killing Jews, and had been doing so for close to 500 years ... they just didn't have the technology to do this in any great numbers ...

 

[BlindBoo]

I have seen no reports of widespread or systematic extermination of Jews, Gypsies, and other so call vagrants by Germans immediately following WWI. They didn't start that until after the Nazi's took total power in 1933.

Never saw any claims of Germany killing six million Jews in WWI

There are four attached to the OP. Russia was also accused of the same.

No, they do not report on a slaughter or a massacre of those 6 million Jews that were in danger. Jews were persecuted throughout Europe. The wholesale slaughter by the millions didn't happen until the Nazis took control of Germany.

 

[ReinyDays]

There were 9 million Jews in Europe in 1939 ... 3 million Jews in Europe in 1945 ... has your hatred blinded you to simple arithmetic? ...

I do not dispute the Nazi death camps, but how were these numbers calculated? Was there an international census? How many were civilian/military war casualties and how many were displaced and/or left Europe?

My understanding is that this is how they've come up with these numbers ... 9 million take away 3 million equals 6 million ... all estimates ... so give or take a million ... a Jew in the Wehrmacht, I don't think so ...

 

[Camp]

Germany kept meticulous records.

There were 9 million Jews in Europe in 1939 ... 3 million Jews in Europe in 1945 ... has your hatred blinded you to simple arithmetic? ...

I do not dispute the Nazi death camps, but how were these numbers calculated? Was there an international census? How many were civilian/military war casualties and how many were displaced and/or left Europe?

My understanding is that this is how they've come up with these numbers ... 9 million take away 3 million equals 6 million ... all estimates ... so give or take a million ... a Jew in the Wehrmacht, I don't think so ...

Actually, millions of names and details can be found online. While many were destroyed during the war, scholars and researchers spent decades accumulating records from all sources varying from small military unit logs to railroad transport records of prisoner transports to concentration labor and death camps.

 

[danielpalos]

Before, during, and after WWI activists and the media accused Germany (among other nations, most notably Russia/the USSR) of the barbaric slaughter of exactly six million Jews. You can still find these claims today. But... Did any of it really happen? The six million figure is well known from Torah prophecy about the restoration of Israel. On a religious level that would have needed to happen to restore the Jewish state even if it didn't happen on a physical level.

No, it is just your right wing reading comprehension. It was about six million Jews living in a war zone and helping them rebuild their lives after the war.

 

[task0778]

A. It was WWII, not WWI.

B. The Germans kept meticulous documents, statistics, and records. Der Fuehrer wanted to know of course. While not an exact number, most historians agree on that 6 million number as fairly accurate.

C. There are anti-Semites who doubt it ever happened. There are also people who do not believe we put men on the moon and mankind has only been around for 6000 years.

 

[ChemEngineer]

There are scores of millions of Americans who think that socialism is superior to liberty and freedom and free markets. They do not deserve to live in a free country.

 

[Camp]

A. It was WWII, not WWI.

B. The Germans kept meticulous documents, statistics, and records. Der Fuehrer wanted to know of course. While not an exact number, most historians agree on that 6 million number as fairly accurate.

C. There are anti-Semites who doubt it ever happened. There are also people who do not believe we put men on the moon and mankind has only been around for 6000 years.

One group of researchers counted people photographed and filmed being murdered and those being transported to death camps.

 

[ReinyDays]

There are scores of millions of Americans who think that socialism is superior to liberty and freedom and free markets. They do not deserve to live in a free country.

How "free" is a country where thought is regulated? ...