Deported illegal is suing us LOL

[Care4all]

DACA recipient who claims to be first ‘Dreamer’ deported under Trump files suit
A 23-year-old so-called “dreamer” is suing the federal government over his deportation to his native Mexico earlier this year.

Juan Manuel Montes, who was 9 years old when he first came to the United States, claims he is entitled to remain in the country under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program. His attorneys said he is believed to be the first known person under the program to be deported during the Trump administration.

According to Montes’ attorneys, the 23-year-old qualified for DACA in 2014 and renewed his status for two years in 2016.

However, U.S. Customs and Border Protection disputes that account. CBP said his DACA permit expired in August 2015 and, according to its records, was not renewed. The agency added that Montes was convicted of theft and sentenced to probation.

His attorneys acknowledged Tuesday in the lawsuit filed in the Southern District of California that he had a misdemeanor on his record and “minor traffic offenses,” none of which would have disqualified him from DACA



dude is illegal, failed to follow through with his agreements and gets mad?
View attachment 122357

Non citizens can sue the government?

yes, of course foreigners can sue our govt....if (they believe) they were harmed by our govt... doesn't mean they will win though...depends on the actual case.

 

[usmbguest5318]

yes, of course foreigners can sue our govt....if they believe they were harmed by our govt...

What they believe is not the determining factor in whether they can sue the government. Neither is whether one is a foreigner or citizen.

 

[OldLady]

DACA recipient who claims to be first ‘Dreamer’ deported under Trump files suit
A 23-year-old so-called “dreamer” is suing the federal government over his deportation to his native Mexico earlier this year.

Juan Manuel Montes, who was 9 years old when he first came to the United States, claims he is entitled to remain in the country under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program. His attorneys said he is believed to be the first known person under the program to be deported during the Trump administration.

According to Montes’ attorneys, the 23-year-old qualified for DACA in 2014 and renewed his status for two years in 2016.

However, U.S. Customs and Border Protection disputes that account. CBP said his DACA permit expired in August 2015 and, according to its records, was not renewed. The agency added that Montes was convicted of theft and sentenced to probation.

His attorneys acknowledged Tuesday in the lawsuit filed in the Southern District of California that he had a misdemeanor on his record and “minor traffic offenses,” none of which would have disqualified him from DACA



dude is illegal, failed to follow through with his agreements and gets mad?
View attachment 122357

I would tend to support the plaintiff. The fact is that the government cannot keep track of things and would even lie if necessary. A Indian husband wife doctor team was forced to reschedule surgeries because the government told them that they did not have to renew their status until this year. Turned out that they were wrong and their status expired last summer.

The plaintiff was legal so he should have standing. We need someone who can look at what the real facts are in this case and make a determination. DACA is still the law of the land and the people who are currently in it should be allowed to remain. That is the fair thing to do.

From the coverage last night on CNN and Fox, it sounds like they are getting completely contradictory information from ICE about what actually happened. First his status is illegal, then it's not. First he went to Mexico without notifying them, then he says they sent him to Mexico. No explanation why he was trying to climb the fence back into the U.S. yet. ICE is so messed up they've had to put in some kind of formal request for information. Their files are a bigger mess than mine.

 

[OldLady]

DACA recipient who claims to be first ‘Dreamer’ deported under Trump files suit
A 23-year-old so-called “dreamer” is suing the federal government over his deportation to his native Mexico earlier this year.

Juan Manuel Montes, who was 9 years old when he first came to the United States, claims he is entitled to remain in the country under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program. His attorneys said he is believed to be the first known person under the program to be deported during the Trump administration.

According to Montes’ attorneys, the 23-year-old qualified for DACA in 2014 and renewed his status for two years in 2016.

However, U.S. Customs and Border Protection disputes that account. CBP said his DACA permit expired in August 2015 and, according to its records, was not renewed. The agency added that Montes was convicted of theft and sentenced to probation.

His attorneys acknowledged Tuesday in the lawsuit filed in the Southern District of California that he had a misdemeanor on his record and “minor traffic offenses,” none of which would have disqualified him from DACA



dude is illegal, failed to follow through with his agreements and gets mad?
View attachment 122357

Non citizens can sue the government?

yes, of course foreigners can sue our govt....if (they believe) they were harmed by our govt... doesn't mean they will win though...depends on the actual case.

When that first Travel Ban was argued in front of the 9th Circuit, the justices were not in agreement about that.

 

[Care4all]

if they had only let him get his DACA PAPERS out of his friend's car showing he was renewed under DACA for two years, we would not have this suit right now.

 

[Siete]

deport the guy because his DCA had expired, which it hadn't, then keep him out of the country for violating his DACA because he left the country when he was deported ...

who the hell is the brainstorm behind all that ?

It has a Republican tattoo on its forehead.

 

[OldLady]

deport the guy because his DCA had expired, which it hadn't, then keep him out of the country for violating his DACA because he left the country when he was deported ...

who the hell is the brainstorm behind all that ?

It has a Republican tattoo on its forehead.

Well, when you put it that way.....LOL

 

[TNHarley]

if they had only let him get his DACA PAPERS out of his friend's car showing he was renewed under DACA for two years, we would not have this suit right now.

didn't have his wallet, but you think he had his daca papers? Why hasn't he shown them yet?

 

[Siete]

if they had only let him get his DACA PAPERS out of his friend's car showing he was renewed under DACA for two years, we would not have this suit right now.

didn't have his wallet, but you think he had his daca papers? Why hasn't he shown them yet?

same reason whoever deported him didn't look on their computer when he was in holding.

 

[Luddly Neddite]

He was here legally and deported illegally. You knee jerk RWNJs need to brace yourselves because it's likely that will be the finding. Then will come your screeching, incorrectly, that it was an "activist" judge and his ruling was because he has an Hispanic sounding name.


Sent from my iPad using USMessageBoard.com

 

[TNHarley]

if they had only let him get his DACA PAPERS out of his friend's car showing he was renewed under DACA for two years, we would not have this suit right now.

didn't have his wallet, but you think he had his daca papers? Why hasn't he shown them yet?

same reason whoever deported him didn't look on their computer when he was in holding.

So its someone elses fault he hasn't shown the papers he has? Well, that makes perfect sense.

 

[Manonthestreet]

All a show...verdict is predetermined....guess whose court this landed in?
'Mexican Judge' Curiel Will Rule On Deported DACA DREAMer Case
US District Judge Gonzalo Curiel, who Trump rightly said was biased against him due to his "Mexican heritage," is set to decide on the case of Juan Manuel Montes, the 23-year-old criminal illegal alien DREAMer who was deported despite allegedly being protected under DACA.

 

[Ray From Cleveland]

All a show...verdict is predetermined....guess whose court this landed in?
'Mexican Judge' Curiel Will Rule On Deported DACA DREAMer Case
US District Judge Gonzalo Curiel, who Trump rightly said was biased against him due to his "Mexican heritage," is set to decide on the case of Juan Manuel Montes, the 23-year-old criminal illegal alien DREAMer who was deported despite allegedly being protected under DACA.

Gee.......anybody giving odds for a bet how that will come out???

 

[TNHarley]

Concerned American

 

[xyz]

By the way, they've also deported US citizens before.
ICE May Have Deported as Many as 70 US Citizens In the Last Five Years

Even before Trump.
The US Keeps Mistakenly Deporting Its Own Citizens

A history of the US deporting its own citizens

In fact, even before ICE. I remember reading an article that occasionally US citizens were deported in the 1980s and 90s. I can't find it right now.

And the one million deported during the Great Depression.
The U.S. Deported a Million of Its Own Citizens to Mexico During the Great Depression

 

[Devils_Advocate]

By the way, they've also deported US citizens before.
ICE May Have Deported as Many as 70 US Citizens In the Last Five Years

Even before Trump.
The US Keeps Mistakenly Deporting Its Own Citizens

A history of the US deporting its own citizens

In fact, even before ICE. I remember reading an article that occasionally US citizens were deported in the 1980s and 90s. I can't find it right now.

And the one million deported during the Great Depression.
The U.S. Deported a Million of Its Own Citizens to Mexico During the Great Depression

Can they deport me to Norway?