Disir
Platinum Member
- Sep 30, 2011
- 28,003
- 9,608
- 910
A federal appeals court on Thursday said inmates had a right to sue a Tennessee judge who shortened people's jail sentences if they agreed to get vasectomies or other forms of birth control.
The lawsuit, filed in 2017, said White County Sheriff Oddie Shoupe and Judge Sam Benningfield violated the constitution by allowing inmates to get 30 days off a jail term if they agreed to a birth control implant or vasectomy.
Benningfield was publicly reprimanded for the practice.
A federal district court judge said the lawsuit was rendered moot in 2018, after Tennessee passed a new law banning such deals. But the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed, and sent the case back to the Nashville-based district court for review.
The case was not moot, the appeals court said, because the inmates who sued still stood to benefit from the 30-day credit they were denied because they refused to participate in the deal.
Court revives lawsuit against judge who shortened jail time if inmates got 'sterilized'
But, it was awesome.
The lawsuit, filed in 2017, said White County Sheriff Oddie Shoupe and Judge Sam Benningfield violated the constitution by allowing inmates to get 30 days off a jail term if they agreed to a birth control implant or vasectomy.
Benningfield was publicly reprimanded for the practice.
A federal district court judge said the lawsuit was rendered moot in 2018, after Tennessee passed a new law banning such deals. But the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed, and sent the case back to the Nashville-based district court for review.
The case was not moot, the appeals court said, because the inmates who sued still stood to benefit from the 30-day credit they were denied because they refused to participate in the deal.
Court revives lawsuit against judge who shortened jail time if inmates got 'sterilized'
But, it was awesome.
