Collective punishment IS A WAR CRIME!

[Hollie]

Your link identifies the use of the spray during street protests.

As opposed to other methods if riot control, the spray seems pretty low impact. I'm guessing you just view rioting and mayhem by Islamic terrorists as an entitlement without consequence?

A street protest is not a riot until the riot police come and start one.

Ah, yes. What a truly twisted mindset. The criminally insane think the same way.

The criminal who broke into a house was not at fault for killing the homeowner. If the homeowner had not come home unexpectedly, the criminal would not have been forced to kill him.

Without riot police.



With riot police.

As long as you saw it on YouTube.....

Of course they are fake. A couple Palestinian activists maxed out their credit cards to hire actors and buy props.

Of course you will believe anything you see on YouTube.

 

[P F Tinmore]

A street protest is not a riot until the riot police come and start one.

Ah, yes. What a truly twisted mindset. The criminally insane think the same way.

The criminal who broke into a house was not at fault for killing the homeowner. If the homeowner had not come home unexpectedly, the criminal would not have been forced to kill him.

Without riot police.



With riot police.

As long as you saw it on YouTube.....

Of course they are fake. A couple Palestinian activists maxed out their credit cards to hire actors and buy props.

Of course you will believe anything you see on YouTube.

Youtube is not the source. It is the medium.

 

[Lipush]

First off... definitions:

Collective punishment is a form of retaliation whereby a suspected perpetrator's family members, friends, acquaintances, sect, neighbors or entire ethnic group is targeted. The punished group may often have no direct association with the other individuals or groups, or direct control over their actions.
Collective punishment - Wikipedia

Under the 1949 Geneva Conventions, collective punishment is a war crime.
Fourth Geneva Convention - Wikipedia

Now for a typical, but lesser known example:

It is a truly putrid stench. Palestinians who have been sprayed describe it as "worse than raw sewage" and "like a mixture of excrement, noxious gas and a decomposing donkey".

Invented by Israeli firm Odortec, skunk water was first used by the Israeli military against demonstrators in the occupied West Bank in 2008. Since then armoured vehicles equipped with water cannon spraying jets of the stinky liquid have become a regular sight....
Who, What, Why: What is skunk water? - BBC News

Israel regularly sprays this on Palestinian streets, homes, and on their schools with their children. But they are hated because of antisemitism?

Think. Collective punishment. War crime!

Firing rockets at civilians is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Randomly stabbing passersby on the street is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Randomly running over people on the street is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Random suicide bombing is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Random arsoning is a collective punishment, religious sinning, and a war crime.



Are you concerned about all those the same way?

 

[Lipush]

Is it a war crime when a Palestinian animal walks into a pizza restaurant in Jerusalem and blows up a bunch of women and children?

Is it a war crime when a Palestinian animal runs down women, children, and the elderly by intentionally running them down with a car or stabbing them?

I wonder...

It is a crime and it is out of desperation.

Who gives a f***. Suicide bombers came out of Gaza, so Gaza got blocked due to Israel having this funny feeling of NOT wanting more people to blow up inside of it. Weird, huh.

 

[montelatici]

First off... definitions:

Collective punishment is a form of retaliation whereby a suspected perpetrator's family members, friends, acquaintances, sect, neighbors or entire ethnic group is targeted. The punished group may often have no direct association with the other individuals or groups, or direct control over their actions.
Collective punishment - Wikipedia

Under the 1949 Geneva Conventions, collective punishment is a war crime.
Fourth Geneva Convention - Wikipedia

Now for a typical, but lesser known example:

It is a truly putrid stench. Palestinians who have been sprayed describe it as "worse than raw sewage" and "like a mixture of excrement, noxious gas and a decomposing donkey".

Invented by Israeli firm Odortec, skunk water was first used by the Israeli military against demonstrators in the occupied West Bank in 2008. Since then armoured vehicles equipped with water cannon spraying jets of the stinky liquid have become a regular sight....
Who, What, Why: What is skunk water? - BBC News

Israel regularly sprays this on Palestinian streets, homes, and on their schools with their children. But they are hated because of antisemitism?

Think. Collective punishment. War crime!

Firing rockets at civilians is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Randomly stabbing passersby on the street is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Randomly running over people on the street is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Random suicide bombing is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Random arsoning is a collective punishment, religious sinning, and a war crime.



Are you concerned about all those the same way?

Interesting, excluding suicide bombings (invented by the Tamil Tiger's resistance) the IRA did all of those things. Were they committing collective punishment for resisting British occupation? The problem with Israelis is that they just will not admit they are belligerent occupiers and oppressors.

 

[louie888]

Lipush

You are all over the place. Back on topic:

 

[Hollie]

Lipush

You are all over the place. Back on topic:

You have cut and pasted this many times and made the same fraudulent claim about raw sewage.

Would that make you a serial spammer?

 

[Hollie]

First off... definitions:

Collective punishment is a form of retaliation whereby a suspected perpetrator's family members, friends, acquaintances, sect, neighbors or entire ethnic group is targeted. The punished group may often have no direct association with the other individuals or groups, or direct control over their actions.
Collective punishment - Wikipedia

Under the 1949 Geneva Conventions, collective punishment is a war crime.
Fourth Geneva Convention - Wikipedia

Now for a typical, but lesser known example:

It is a truly putrid stench. Palestinians who have been sprayed describe it as "worse than raw sewage" and "like a mixture of excrement, noxious gas and a decomposing donkey".

Invented by Israeli firm Odortec, skunk water was first used by the Israeli military against demonstrators in the occupied West Bank in 2008. Since then armoured vehicles equipped with water cannon spraying jets of the stinky liquid have become a regular sight....
Who, What, Why: What is skunk water? - BBC News

Israel regularly sprays this on Palestinian streets, homes, and on their schools with their children. But they are hated because of antisemitism?

Think. Collective punishment. War crime!

Firing rockets at civilians is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Randomly stabbing passersby on the street is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Randomly running over people on the street is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Random suicide bombing is a collective punishment and a war crime.

Random arsoning is a collective punishment, religious sinning, and a war crime.



Are you concerned about all those the same way?

Interesting, excluding suicide bombings (invented by the Tamil Tiger's resistance) the IRA did all of those things. Were they committing collective punishment for resisting British occupation? The problem with Israelis is that they just will not admit they are belligerent occupiers and oppressors.

If you exclude suicide bombings, why not selectively exclude other acts and represent the IRA as just good Christians doing god's work.

 

[louie888]

Wrong again, Hollie! At least you are consistent.

[Jewish] Human rights watchdog B'Tselem published a video showing Israel's armoured tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Israeli security forces spray raw sewage at Palestinian homes -- Sott.net

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

 

[Hollie]

Wrong again, Hollie! At least you are consistent.

[Jewish] Human rights watchdog B'Tselem published a video showing Israel's armoured tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Israeli security forces spray raw sewage at Palestinian homes -- Sott.net

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

You identified in another thread it was "skunk water".

Are you befuddled by the various threads you cut and paste to?

 

[Lipush]

Lipush

You are all over the place. Back on topic:

Israel and Hamas both committed certain war crimes.

Your Anti-Israeli biased so you cannot see things clearly.

 

[Lipush]

Wrong again, Hollie! At least you are consistent.

[Jewish] Human rights watchdog B'Tselem published a video showing Israel's armoured tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Israeli security forces spray raw sewage at Palestinian homes -- Sott.net

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

I stopped believeing anything Betselem says once they started with blood libels.

They once said that settler poison Palestinian wells. Once they've been called out on it they never given any proof. Which is basically what you do here since day one.

I'm still waiting for them, AND you, to prove what you say.

 

[Roudy]

Lipush

You are all over the place. Back on topic:

You have cut and pasted this many times and made the same fraudulent claim about raw sewage.

Would that make you a serial spammer?

And a sock.

 

[Shusha]

... tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

Non-lethal methods of crowd control or riot control (see above "protesters"), by definition, are not collective punishment.

 

[montelatici]

... tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

Non-lethal methods of crowd control or riot control (see above "protesters"), by definition, are not collective punishment.

How can you seriously claim Israel doesn't practice collective punishment? You people are the theater of the absurd.

"The UN Human Rights Office in the OPT has monitored and documented punitive home demolition cases, including the case of the Al-Shaludi Family. In 2015, the Office presented a report to the Human Rights Council regarding the resumption of the practice, stating it breaches the Fourth Geneva Convention, and violates a range of Israel’s human rights obligations, and underlining that no-one should be punished for an act they did not commit". - See more at: Punitive demolitions in OPT

 

[Hollie]

... tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

Non-lethal methods of crowd control or riot control (see above "protesters"), by definition, are not collective punishment.

How can you seriously claim Israel doesn't practice collective punishment? You people are the theater of the absurd.

"The UN Human Rights Office in the OPT has monitored and documented punitive home demolition cases, including the case of the Al-Shaludi Family. In 2015, the Office presented a report to the Human Rights Council regarding the resumption of the practice, stating it breaches the Fourth Geneva Convention, and violates a range of Israel’s human rights obligations, and underlining that no-one should be punished for an act they did not commit". - See more at: Punitive demolitions in OPT

It's comical how the Islamic terrorist huggers whine about human rights violations in the context of Israel responding to attacks from Islamic terrorists.

 

[Shusha]

... tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

Non-lethal methods of crowd control or riot control (see above "protesters"), by definition, are not collective punishment.

How can you seriously claim Israel doesn't practice collective punishment? You people are the theater of the absurd.

"The UN Human Rights Office in the OPT has monitored and documented punitive home demolition cases, including the case of the Al-Shaludi Family. In 2015, the Office presented a report to the Human Rights Council regarding the resumption of the practice, stating it breaches the Fourth Geneva Convention, and violates a range of Israel’s human rights obligations, and underlining that no-one should be punished for an act they did not commit". - See more at: Punitive demolitions in OPT

You should read over this thread. I did not claim that Israel does not practice collective punishment and I gave a specific example of what collective punishment Israel does practice.

Riot control of protesters does NOT meet the definition of collective punishment.

 

[P F Tinmore]

... tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

Non-lethal methods of crowd control or riot control (see above "protesters"), by definition, are not collective punishment.

How can you seriously claim Israel doesn't practice collective punishment? You people are the theater of the absurd.

"The UN Human Rights Office in the OPT has monitored and documented punitive home demolition cases, including the case of the Al-Shaludi Family. In 2015, the Office presented a report to the Human Rights Council regarding the resumption of the practice, stating it breaches the Fourth Geneva Convention, and violates a range of Israel’s human rights obligations, and underlining that no-one should be punished for an act they did not commit". - See more at: Punitive demolitions in OPT

You should read over this thread. I did not claim that Israel does not practice collective punishment and I gave a specific example of what collective punishment Israel does practice.

Riot control of protesters does NOT meet the definition of collective punishment.

The Palestinians have Protests. The IDF creates the riots.

 

[Shusha]

The Palestinians have Protests. The IDF creates the riots.

Fine. Use whatever nomenclature you want. Spraying protesters does not meet the definition of collective punishment.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Wrong again, Hollie! At least you are consistent.

[Jewish] Human rights watchdog B'Tselem published a video showing Israel's armoured tanker trucks fitted with "water cannons" which spray the foul fluid at Palestinian protesters.

Israeli security forces spray raw sewage at Palestinian homes -- Sott.net

Collective punishment is a WAR CRIME.

I stopped believeing anything Betselem says once they started with blood libels.

They once said that settler poison Palestinian wells. Once they've been called out on it they never given any proof. Which is basically what you do here since day one.

I'm still waiting for them, AND you, to prove what you say.

I have never seen that from B'Tselem. Do you have links?