Billy_Kinetta
Paladin of the Lost Hour
- Mar 4, 2013
- 52,766
- 22,201
- 2,320
Everyone already knows the general welfare clause gives the feds the power to tax.I dont need to read it again. I am the one that posted it. Welfare is paid for by taxes. It is in the general welfare of this nation that we take care of those that cant or wont take care of themselves or we create a larger problem. Please link to something credible that proves the founders were against this.Providing for the general welfare gives the feds the power to tax
Right, but read it again. I says "provide FOR the general welfare", meaning to maintain circumstances conducive to the general welfare of the nation.
It does not say "PROVIDE general welfare" to individuals, and the Founders never considered such a thing outside of charity.
Not until you first prove your position as earlier requested.
BTW, welfare did not become a function of government in the United States until the late 19th Century. In light of your apparent hinted belief that the Founders were in favor of wealth redistribution, why is that?
Please provide proof the founders were against this concept.
No. You have not fulfilled the initial request.