Graphs of CO2 v temperature before humans were producing CO2 on industrial scales MAGICALLY show temperature increases preceding CO2. Would any of you care to suggest how they could have occurred in any other fashion? Interestingly, per the work of Jeremy Shakun et al, 2012, these are followed in almost every instance by a swap as robust greenhouse warming overtakes the mild-mannered Milankovitch effects that started the affairs. CO2 leads warming in the latter portions of each instance of interglacial warming. And, of course, since the rise in CO2 that begun with the Industrial Revolution wasn't caused by Milankovitch heating or heating of any other sort, it obviously could NOT be lagging any heating. And since none of you have made the slightest headway in your attempts to refute THIS
the 120 ppm of CO2 humans have put into the atmosphere is collecting IR radiation and warming the planet (and coincidentally acidifying the world's oceans).
Period.
the 120 ppm of CO2 humans have put into the atmosphere is collecting IR radiation and warming the planet (and coincidentally acidifying the world's oceans).
Period.