To the extent (an extent which I assume is not really validly doubted) that black people in our land were the subject of racism in the past, and that racism has adversely impacted black people in the present, I grasp the call for making some amends.
Today, many black Americans start off in an economically disadvantaged position in our society which exists as a present day consequence of past discrimination. The entire notion of “affirmative action” began along those lines. It was a way of temporarily “tilting the field” to compensate black Americans for the present day consequences of past societal discrimination.
But …
Objectively, it tends to discriminate against “present” day white Americans since those are the people who, involuntarily, are made the sacrificial lambs in the process.
In brief, being discriminated against — on the basis of race — under an “Affirmative Action Program” is no less racist today than Jim Crow laws were in the past.
There are other convoluted thoughts on the legality of such Affirmative Action programs. But the goal has pretty much always been driven by the notion that society has some obligation to take cognizance of race to overcome the results of past discrimination.
We should have been (since our founding) a “colorblind society.” We weren’t. So the thinking is that we “need” to weigh race back into the process, to fix things. In other words, our past failure to be a colorblind society demands that we not be a colorblind society, now.