Zone1 Why can't men compete in women's sports if they are not transitioning?

[Votto]

It is a fair question. Why can't men compete in women's sports if you are going to allow them to do it if they are transitioning?

How is taking hormones and cutting off your wing wang make you able to compete? How does that qualify you to compete?

Makes no sense.

 

[JoeMoma]

Depends on the sport! There have been cases of men completing in woman's sports by simply stating that they identify as female -- no surgery of hormone treatment required. I know at least a couple of times when males competed in women's weight lifting events just to prove the point of the unfairness.

 

[Captain Caveman]

It is a fair question. Why can't men compete in women's sports if you are going to allow them to do it if they are transitioning?

How is taking hormones and cutting off your wing wang make you able to compete? How does that qualify you to compete?

Makes no sense.

Why can't heavyweight boxers box in the featherweight class?

 

[Polishprince]

Why can't heavyweight boxers box in the featherweight class?

That might be interesting. Floyd Mayweather successfully defeated the much larger Big Show in a boxing match at Wrestlemania after all.

 

[Captain Caveman]

That might be interesting. Floyd Mayweather successfully defeated the much larger Big Show in a boxing match at Wrestlemania after all.

The reason for boxing weight classes is so 99.99999999999999% of the lower classes survive.

 

[DGS49]

There is only one relevant question, and it is dispositive of the issue: Why do males and females have separate competitions?

The answer is simple and irrefutable: Because women cannot compete with men. They will "get slaughtered."

And because women cannot compete with men, it makes no sense to allow specific men to compete against women, simply because they have deluded themselves into thinking that they ARE women.

Which is the crux of the trans-thing, isn't it? Nobody challenges their right to exist, or to manifest themselves any way they want. But they have no right to compel society to treat them as though their delusions were real.

 

[Votto]

There is only one relevant question, and it is dispositive of the issue: Why do males and females have separate competitions?

The answer is simple and irrefutable: Because women cannot compete with men. They will "get slaughtered."

And because women cannot compete with men, it makes no sense to allow specific men to compete against women, simply because they have deluded themselves into thinking that they ARE women.

Which is the crux of the trans-thing, isn't it? Nobody challenges their right to exist, or to manifest themselves any way they want. But they have no right to compel society to treat them as though their delusions were real.

True dat.

But Progressives don't care.

My question is, why must the criteria be that they have the delusion they are the other gender to compete? Why not just allow them to compete without the delusion of gender insanity?

 

[Scoutster]

Why can't heavyweight boxers box in the featherweight class?

 

[Dr.Destructo]

Trump gonna put a stop to that.

It's called WOMENS SPORTS because it's for REAL WOMEN to participate in!

 

[Dogmaphobe]

It is a fair question. Why can't men compete in women's sports if you are going to allow them to do it if they are transitioning?

How is taking hormones and cutting off your wing wang make you able to compete? How does that qualify you to compete?

Makes no sense.

They don't even cut off their wing wang.

Lea Thomas waves his around in the locker room as an act of intimidation.

 

[Dogmaphobe]

Why can't heavyweight boxers box in the featherweight class?

I just signed up for Pop Warner Football for this fall.


I'm gonna rule!!!

 

[IM2]

Estrogen changes a person's body. That's why.

Try studying what estrogen does to a person who transitions.

 

[Captain Caveman]

It is a fair question. Why can't men compete in women's sports if you are going to allow them to do it if they are transitioning?

How is taking hormones and cutting off your wing wang make you able to compete? How does that qualify you to compete?

Makes no sense.

Because men shouldn't compete in women's sports, I told the girlfriend that I can no longer wash the dishes.

 

[Captain Caveman]

Estrogen changes a person's body. That's why.

Try studying what estrogen does to a person who transitions.

Estrogen is a female biological hormone.

Testosterone is a male biological hormone.

The mentality ill swap these and take supplements.

 

[Seymour Flops]

True dat.

But Progressives don't care.

My question is, why must the criteria be that they have the delusion they are the other gender to compete? Why not just allow them to compete without the delusion of gender insanity?

Exactly, because how can you ever verify that they have the delusion, and are not just gaming the system?

That leaves what must be a horrible possibility for for the left: Suppose a genuine dude that thinks he's a girl joins the women's boxing team and the next day, a dude who only claims to think he's a girl to game the system joins another team, and beats the first dude's face in the next week?

Democrats, wouldn't that be an injustice?

 

[Seymour Flops]

Estrogen changes a person's body. That's why.

Try studying what estrogen does to a person who transitions.

Just tell us if you're the expert.

Use Lia Thomas as an example. How is "she" different now, than from when she was a mediocre male swimmer?

 

[Robert W]

It is a fair question. Why can't men compete in women's sports if you are going to allow them to do it if they are transitioning?

How is taking hormones and cutting off your wing wang make you able to compete? How does that qualify you to compete?

Makes no sense.

Can any poster imagine that Muhammad Ali declared he is a woman and fought against women?