Who are the Palestinians? An Arab Invention.

[Book of Jeremiah]

Ut-oh! Looks like the revisionists won't have an explanation for this story either. Play it again, Sam!

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

Where ARE all those Palestinians, the proclaimed one million of them who lived in Israel before they were ‘displaced’?

Nowhere.

Nowhere, because they never existed.

And where are all the mosques for those “1 million Palestinians”? With Muslims comes mosques. There can be no Muslim population without a large proportion of mosques. If they had been 1 million at the turn of the Century, or even in 1920 after they began immigrating to fight the British, with their rapid population growth Palestine would consist of over 40 million people today and not 4 million. That alone proves the Palestinian jihad lies. Their population is small because they are new invaders and occupiers who arrived late with an aim to commit jihad. They never lost land that was never theirs to begin with!

The British army permitted merely a few Ottomans to remain due to religious observations, the rest was Jewish. In reality according to eyewitness reports the barren British Mandate had a very small number of people living on it. Félix Bonfils (1831-1885) was a French photographer and writer who was active in the Middle East. Four years after his arrival he reported 15,000 prints of Egypt, Palestine, Syria, and Greece, and 9,000 stereoscopic-views. He traveled to the region several times and we hear of no mass population of Palestinians, which contradicts everything the Palestinians lie about to the world.

His pictures did not manage to capture any photographs of a single so-called ‘Palestinian’ who are suppose to have lost land to Jewish occupation, if we believe Arab propaganda. All he found was a few bedouines passing through and some remnants of the Ottoman Turks. Guess why? Because the “Palestinian” people as we know them today never existed.

____________
Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian? What? Are they invisible? Do they somehow magically evaporate when photographed? How to explain? Thousands and thousands of pictures of Jews, Synagogues, Jewish symbolism in Palestine but not a single mosque or Arab in a photo. How is that? Anyone?

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

 

[montelatici]

Again, a propaganda film from the Zionist Organization. There are real (and earlier) documentaries available that show that Jews were a very tiny minority even in 1896. Not to mention the Ottoman census, the British census and other source documentation that makes it clear that your propaganda film is what it is, propaganda. Now here is a simple Lumiere Brothers documentary that just presents the situation as it was in 1896.

That's why I posted the video I posted. It proves yours is a forgery and full of lies. You had better look at the video I posted. Your video claims that a Jewish man praying at the wall was speaking in Arabic. The language of the Jews in Palestine was Arabic? Now that is a stretch!!! The lies are so preposterous (including claims that there majority of population was Arab - estimates are well under 100 Arabs total in one local and zero in other locals according to at least one source, very few Arabs and most of those were Nomads) The lies on your propaganda film are so outrageous that no one would believe it and now you've got actual footage of a real film from that time period which blows yours straight out of the water.

Have another look:


THE LIFE OF THE JEWS IN OTTOMAN PALESTINE IN 1913 THERE WERE FEW ARABS 100 YEARS AGO

MegaPhylum

Of course the Arab Jews in Palestine spoke Arabic, like all Middle Eastern Jews of the time. What language do you think they spoke on a daily basis?

You are making things up as usual. There are official census records, Ottoman and later British, that make it clear you are a clown. The Muslims and Christians continued to be the overwhelming majority even in 1922 when the British Census was taken.

The Lumiere brothers documentary was filmed in 1896, whose propaganda was it? The documentary is fact, not the Zionist propaganda you post from propaganda sites.

Can you possibly ever post anything but Zionist propaganda?

You aren't fooling anyone Mr. Hasbara.

 

[P F Tinmore]

Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian?

I have about ten photo albums without a single black person in them. So, that must mean that there are no black people in the US.

 

[montelatici]

You see Mr. Hasbara, I have access to all the facts from the source documents. I'm the Hasbara's worst nightmare. I have the facts. LOL

http://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/yabber/census/PalestineCensus1922.pdf

 

[Eloy]

Ut-oh! Looks like the revisionists won't have an explanation for this story either. Play it again, Sam!

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

Where ARE all those Palestinians, the proclaimed one million of them who lived in Israel before they were ‘displaced’?

Nowhere.

Nowhere, because they never existed.

And where are all the mosques for those “1 million Palestinians”? With Muslims comes mosques. There can be no Muslim population without a large proportion of mosques. If they had been 1 million at the turn of the Century, or even in 1920 after they began immigrating to fight the British, with their rapid population growth Palestine would consist of over 40 million people today and not 4 million. That alone proves the Palestinian jihad lies. Their population is small because they are new invaders and occupiers who arrived late with an aim to commit jihad. They never lost land that was never theirs to begin with!

The British army permitted merely a few Ottomans to remain due to religious observations, the rest was Jewish. In reality according to eyewitness reports the barren British Mandate had a very small number of people living on it. Félix Bonfils (1831-1885) was a French photographer and writer who was active in the Middle East. Four years after his arrival he reported 15,000 prints of Egypt, Palestine, Syria, and Greece, and 9,000 stereoscopic-views. He traveled to the region several times and we hear of no mass population of Palestinians, which contradicts everything the Palestinians lie about to the world.

His pictures did not manage to capture any photographs of a single so-called ‘Palestinian’ who are suppose to have lost land to Jewish occupation, if we believe Arab propaganda. All he found was a few bedouines passing through and some remnants of the Ottoman Turks. Guess why? Because the “Palestinian” people as we know them today never existed.

____________
Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian? What? Are they invisible? Do they somehow magically evaporate when photographed? How to explain? Thousands and thousands of pictures of Jews, Synagogues, Jewish symbolism in Palestine but not a single mosque or Arab in a photo. How is that? Anyone?

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

 

[Book of Jeremiah]

Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian?

I have about ten photo albums without a single black person in them. So, that must mean that there are no black people in the US.

This wasn't a family photo album, Tinmore. Don't pretend to be stupid now. Look at the title again. 9,000 Photographs from 1800's British Mandate of Palestine but he couldn't find a single Arab? Not a single trace of even one Mosque or Palestinian? How is that?
9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

 

[Book of Jeremiah]

Ut-oh! Looks like the revisionists won't have an explanation for this story either. Play it again, Sam!

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

Where ARE all those Palestinians, the proclaimed one million of them who lived in Israel before they were ‘displaced’?

Nowhere.

Nowhere, because they never existed.

And where are all the mosques for those “1 million Palestinians”? With Muslims comes mosques. There can be no Muslim population without a large proportion of mosques. If they had been 1 million at the turn of the Century, or even in 1920 after they began immigrating to fight the British, with their rapid population growth Palestine would consist of over 40 million people today and not 4 million. That alone proves the Palestinian jihad lies. Their population is small because they are new invaders and occupiers who arrived late with an aim to commit jihad. They never lost land that was never theirs to begin with!

The British army permitted merely a few Ottomans to remain due to religious observations, the rest was Jewish. In reality according to eyewitness reports the barren British Mandate had a very small number of people living on it. Félix Bonfils (1831-1885) was a French photographer and writer who was active in the Middle East. Four years after his arrival he reported 15,000 prints of Egypt, Palestine, Syria, and Greece, and 9,000 stereoscopic-views. He traveled to the region several times and we hear of no mass population of Palestinians, which contradicts everything the Palestinians lie about to the world.

His pictures did not manage to capture any photographs of a single so-called ‘Palestinian’ who are suppose to have lost land to Jewish occupation, if we believe Arab propaganda. All he found was a few bedouines passing through and some remnants of the Ottoman Turks. Guess why? Because the “Palestinian” people as we know them today never existed.

____________
Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian? What? Are they invisible? Do they somehow magically evaporate when photographed? How to explain? Thousands and thousands of pictures of Jews, Synagogues, Jewish symbolism in Palestine but not a single mosque or Arab in a photo. How is that? Anyone?

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

 

[montelatici]

Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian?

I have about ten photo albums without a single black person in them. So, that must mean that there are no black people in the US.

This wasn't a family photo album, Tinmore. Don't pretend to be stupid now. Look at the title again:

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

This guy is serious. He doesn't believe that Muslims and Christians were 95% of the population in Palestine in the 1800s. Notwithstanding the census data and the documentary film evidence. Unbelievable.

It makes one wonder how it was possible that the Muslims and Christians still owned 85% of the land in Palestine in 1945, as surveyed by the UN. Clever those Muslims and Christians of Palestine. LOL

 

[Book of Jeremiah]

At least they tell the truth sometimes. They should do it more often.
Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad admits Arab lies and denies there exist “palestinians” right on Al-Hekma TV (Egypt) on March 23, 2012.

Have the Arab in Israel (so called “palestinians”) managed to fool you to believe they are Natives in the land of Israel ?

And why they are so intimidated by History and facts ?

In a temper tantrum Fathi Hammad could not keep his mouth shut but had to blurt out the truth: that the “Palestinian” people are a fabrication, an invention.

There never existed a displaced people called Palestinian. And there never existed an invasion of Palestinian land over a territory that belonged to the jews over 1,000 years before Mohammed was even born.

The actual Palestinians are illegal immigrants from surrounding Arab nations pushed to occupy the area to commit intifada (resistance).

The Palestine-Israeli conflict is not about loss of land. It’s about hate and racism. Jew hate. In fact, it’s about 1,400 years of racism created by the Arabs based on the teachings of prophet Mohammed.

The Muslim faith demands that Muslims must hate Jews in particular (and Christians) and must dedicate themselves to kill Jews. And what are they doing? They are killing Jews and non-Muslims all over the world. This deliberate effort to ethnic cleansing of the Jews by propaganda and lies have even been spread into the West by Arab money, and deliberate Arab propaganda put into our schools and media.

In March 1977, Zahir Muhsein, an executive member of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO), said in an interview to the Dutch newspaper Trouw: “The ‘Palestinian people’ does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel.”
(Video) Hamas Official: “Who are the Palestinians? The Palestinians don’t come from Palestine.”

 

[Eloy]

Ut-oh! Looks like the revisionists won't have an explanation for this story either. Play it again, Sam!

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

Where ARE all those Palestinians, the proclaimed one million of them who lived in Israel before they were ‘displaced’?

Nowhere.

Nowhere, because they never existed.

And where are all the mosques for those “1 million Palestinians”? With Muslims comes mosques. There can be no Muslim population without a large proportion of mosques. If they had been 1 million at the turn of the Century, or even in 1920 after they began immigrating to fight the British, with their rapid population growth Palestine would consist of over 40 million people today and not 4 million. That alone proves the Palestinian jihad lies. Their population is small because they are new invaders and occupiers who arrived late with an aim to commit jihad. They never lost land that was never theirs to begin with!

The British army permitted merely a few Ottomans to remain due to religious observations, the rest was Jewish. In reality according to eyewitness reports the barren British Mandate had a very small number of people living on it. Félix Bonfils (1831-1885) was a French photographer and writer who was active in the Middle East. Four years after his arrival he reported 15,000 prints of Egypt, Palestine, Syria, and Greece, and 9,000 stereoscopic-views. He traveled to the region several times and we hear of no mass population of Palestinians, which contradicts everything the Palestinians lie about to the world.

His pictures did not manage to capture any photographs of a single so-called ‘Palestinian’ who are suppose to have lost land to Jewish occupation, if we believe Arab propaganda. All he found was a few bedouines passing through and some remnants of the Ottoman Turks. Guess why? Because the “Palestinian” people as we know them today never existed.

____________
Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian? What? Are they invisible? Do they somehow magically evaporate when photographed? How to explain? Thousands and thousands of pictures of Jews, Synagogues, Jewish symbolism in Palestine but not a single mosque or Arab in a photo. How is that? Anyone?

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

Your bizarre claim that Palestinians did not exist before 1948 has been shown to be false by ample posts in this thread.

 

[Book of Jeremiah]

Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian?

I have about ten photo albums without a single black person in them. So, that must mean that there are no black people in the US.

This wasn't a family photo album, Tinmore. Don't pretend to be stupid now. Look at the title again:

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

This guy is serious. He doesn't believe that Muslims and Christians were 95% of the population in Palestine in the 1800s. Notwithstanding the census data and the documentary film evidence. Unbelievable.

It makes one wonder how it was possible that the Muslims and Christians still owned 85% of the land in Palestine in 1945, as surveyed by the UN. Clever those Muslims and Christians of Palestine. LOL

The United Nations map is a lie. Look at this report:

Land Ownership in 1948 The claim is often made that in 1948 a Jewish minority owning only 5 per cent of the land of Palestine made itself master of the Arab majority, which owned 95 per cent of the land. In May 1948 the State of Israel was established in only part of the area allotted by the original League of Nations Mandate. 8.6 per cent of the land was owned by Jews and 3.3 per cent by Israeli Arabs, while 16.9 per cent had been abandoned by Arab owners who imprudently heeded the call from neighbouring countries to "get out of the way" while the invading Arab armies made short shrift of Israel. The rest of the land—over 70 per cent—had been vested in Appendix 2 127 the Mandatory Power, and accordingly reverted to the State of Israel as its legal heir. (Government of Palestine, Survey of Palestine, 1946, British Government Printer, p. 257.) The greater part of this 70 per cent consisted of the Negev, some 3,144,250 acres all told, or close to 50 per cent of the 6,580,000 acres in all of Mandatory Palestine. Known as Crown or State Lands, this was mostly uninhabited arid or semi-arid territory, inherited originally by the Mandatory Government from Turkey. In 1948 it passed to the Government of Israel. These lands had not been owned by Arab farmers—neither under the British Mandate nor under the preceding regime. Thus it is obvious that the contention that 95 per cent of the land—whether of Mandatory Palestine or of the State of Israel—had belonged to Arabs has absolutely no foundation in fact. * * •

There is perhaps no better way of concluding and summing up this study than to quote from an article entitled Is Israel a Thorn or a Flower in the Near East? by Abdul Razak Kader, the Algerian political writer, now living in exile in Paris (Jerusalem Post, Aug. 1, 1969): "The Nationalists of the states neighbouring on Israel, whether they are in the government or in business, whether Palestinian, Syrian or Lebanese, or town dwellers of tribal origin, all know that at the beginning of the century and during the British Mandate the marshy plains and stone hills were sold to the Zionists by their fathers or uncles for gold, the very gold which is often the origin of their own political or commercial careers. The nomadic or seminomadic peasants who inhabited the frontier regions know full well what the green plains, the afforested hills and the flowering fields of today's Israel were like before. "The Palestinians who are today refugees in the neighbouring countries and who were adults at the time of their flight know all this, and no anti-Zionist propaganda—pan-Arab or pan-Moslem— can make them forget that their present nationalist exploiters are the worthy sons of their feudal exploiters of yesterday and that the thorns of their life are of Arab, not Jewish, origin
http://www.wordfromjerusalem.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/the-case-for-israel-appendix2.pdf

 

[Book of Jeremiah]

Ut-oh! Looks like the revisionists won't have an explanation for this story either. Play it again, Sam!

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

Where ARE all those Palestinians, the proclaimed one million of them who lived in Israel before they were ‘displaced’?

Nowhere.

Nowhere, because they never existed.

And where are all the mosques for those “1 million Palestinians”? With Muslims comes mosques. There can be no Muslim population without a large proportion of mosques. If they had been 1 million at the turn of the Century, or even in 1920 after they began immigrating to fight the British, with their rapid population growth Palestine would consist of over 40 million people today and not 4 million. That alone proves the Palestinian jihad lies. Their population is small because they are new invaders and occupiers who arrived late with an aim to commit jihad. They never lost land that was never theirs to begin with!

The British army permitted merely a few Ottomans to remain due to religious observations, the rest was Jewish. In reality according to eyewitness reports the barren British Mandate had a very small number of people living on it. Félix Bonfils (1831-1885) was a French photographer and writer who was active in the Middle East. Four years after his arrival he reported 15,000 prints of Egypt, Palestine, Syria, and Greece, and 9,000 stereoscopic-views. He traveled to the region several times and we hear of no mass population of Palestinians, which contradicts everything the Palestinians lie about to the world.

His pictures did not manage to capture any photographs of a single so-called ‘Palestinian’ who are suppose to have lost land to Jewish occupation, if we believe Arab propaganda. All he found was a few bedouines passing through and some remnants of the Ottoman Turks. Guess why? Because the “Palestinian” people as we know them today never existed.

____________
Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian? What? Are they invisible? Do they somehow magically evaporate when photographed? How to explain? Thousands and thousands of pictures of Jews, Synagogues, Jewish symbolism in Palestine but not a single mosque or Arab in a photo. How is that? Anyone?

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

Your bizarre claim that Palestinians did not exist before 1948 has been shown to be false by ample posts in this thread.

Didn't you listen to the Muslim Cleric in youtube video interview? He made it clear that they NEVER EXISTED. He admitted they were Arabs and Egyptians and that they had no religious connection to the land - he even said that the Koran proved there was no religious connection to Israel and that the Koran noted Israel as a land given to the Jews by God. It does not get anymore clear. Stop listening to the liars at the UN who are trying to keep this conflict going in order to use it to their own advantage.

 

[Eloy]

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

Your bizarre claim that Palestinians did not exist before 1948 has been shown to be false by ample posts in this thread.

Didn't you listen to the Muslim Cleric in youtube video interview? He made it clear that they NEVER EXISTED. He admitted they were Arabs and Egyptians and that they had no religious connection to the land - he even said that the Koran proved there was no religious connection to Israel and that the Koran noted Israel as a land given to the Jews by God. It does not get anymore clear. Stop listening to the liars at the UN who are trying to keep this conflict going in order to use it to their own advantage.

I have no interest in listening to a Muslim cleric. Sorry.

 

[Book of Jeremiah]

Ut-oh! Looks like the revisionists won't have an explanation for this story either. Play it again, Sam!

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

Where ARE all those Palestinians, the proclaimed one million of them who lived in Israel before they were ‘displaced’?

Nowhere.

Nowhere, because they never existed.

And where are all the mosques for those “1 million Palestinians”? With Muslims comes mosques. There can be no Muslim population without a large proportion of mosques. If they had been 1 million at the turn of the Century, or even in 1920 after they began immigrating to fight the British, with their rapid population growth Palestine would consist of over 40 million people today and not 4 million. That alone proves the Palestinian jihad lies. Their population is small because they are new invaders and occupiers who arrived late with an aim to commit jihad. They never lost land that was never theirs to begin with!

The British army permitted merely a few Ottomans to remain due to religious observations, the rest was Jewish. In reality according to eyewitness reports the barren British Mandate had a very small number of people living on it. Félix Bonfils (1831-1885) was a French photographer and writer who was active in the Middle East. Four years after his arrival he reported 15,000 prints of Egypt, Palestine, Syria, and Greece, and 9,000 stereoscopic-views. He traveled to the region several times and we hear of no mass population of Palestinians, which contradicts everything the Palestinians lie about to the world.

His pictures did not manage to capture any photographs of a single so-called ‘Palestinian’ who are suppose to have lost land to Jewish occupation, if we believe Arab propaganda. All he found was a few bedouines passing through and some remnants of the Ottoman Turks. Guess why? Because the “Palestinian” people as we know them today never existed.

____________
Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian? What? Are they invisible? Do they somehow magically evaporate when photographed? How to explain? Thousands and thousands of pictures of Jews, Synagogues, Jewish symbolism in Palestine but not a single mosque or Arab in a photo. How is that? Anyone?

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

Your bizarre claim that Palestinians did not exist before 1948 has been shown to be false by ample posts in this thread.

They do not exist period. But you won't find any Arab or Egyptian calling themselves a Palestinian prior to the 1960's. Go find an Encyclopedia and do your own research.

 

[Hollie]

You see Mr. Hasbara, I have access to all the facts from the source documents. I'm the Hasbara's worst nightmare. I have the facts. LOL

View attachment 114035

View attachment 114036http://users.cecs.anu.edu.au/~bdm/yabber/census/PalestineCensus1922.pdf

Well thanks for posting that. It debunks your claim that the Christian population exceeded the Jewish population.

 

[Eloy]

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

Your bizarre claim that Palestinians did not exist before 1948 has been shown to be false by ample posts in this thread.

They do not exist period. But you won't find any Arab or Egyptian calling themselves a Palestinian prior to the 1960's. Go find an Encyclopedia and do your own research.

I would consider it of no importance who did or did not call themselves Palestinians before the 1960s since the Palestinian people nowadays are sure who they are and so is the rest of the world.
A resolution of the Israel/Palestine conflict has no chance were the Israelis to pretend that the Palestine Liberation Organization represents nobody.

 

[Hollie]

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

Your bizarre claim that Palestinians did not exist before 1948 has been shown to be false by ample posts in this thread.

They do not exist period. But you won't find any Arab or Egyptian calling themselves a Palestinian prior to the 1960's. Go find an Encyclopedia and do your own research.

I would consider it of no importance who did or did not call themselves Palestinians before the 1960s since the Palestinian people nowadays are sure who they are and so is the rest of the world.
A resolution of the Israel/Palestine conflict has no chance were the Israelis to pretend that the Palestine Liberation Organization represents nobody.

What is important is that we understand the term "Pal'istanian" was an invention of Yassir "I'm actually Egyptian" Arafat. In the late 1960's, he created an invented national identity for an invented people.

 

[montelatici]

Did you get that? He takes 9,000 photographs and is not able to capture the photograph of a single Arab Palestinian?

I have about ten photo albums without a single black person in them. So, that must mean that there are no black people in the US.

This wasn't a family photo album, Tinmore. Don't pretend to be stupid now. Look at the title again:

9,000 Photos from 1800’s British Mandate of Palestine – with no trace of ‘Palestinians’

This guy is serious. He doesn't believe that Muslims and Christians were 95% of the population in Palestine in the 1800s. Notwithstanding the census data and the documentary film evidence. Unbelievable.

It makes one wonder how it was possible that the Muslims and Christians still owned 85% of the land in Palestine in 1945, as surveyed by the UN. Clever those Muslims and Christians of Palestine. LOL

The United Nations map is a lie. Look at this report:

Land Ownership in 1948 The claim is often made that in 1948 a Jewish minority owning only 5 per cent of the land of Palestine made itself master of the Arab majority, which owned 95 per cent of the land. In May 1948 the State of Israel was established in only part of the area allotted by the original League of Nations Mandate. 8.6 per cent of the land was owned by Jews and 3.3 per cent by Israeli Arabs, while 16.9 per cent had been abandoned by Arab owners who imprudently heeded the call from neighbouring countries to "get out of the way" while the invading Arab armies made short shrift of Israel. The rest of the land—over 70 per cent—had been vested in Appendix 2 127 the Mandatory Power, and accordingly reverted to the State of Israel as its legal heir. (Government of Palestine, Survey of Palestine, 1946, British Government Printer, p. 257.) The greater part of this 70 per cent consisted of the Negev, some 3,144,250 acres all told, or close to 50 per cent of the 6,580,000 acres in all of Mandatory Palestine. Known as Crown or State Lands, this was mostly uninhabited arid or semi-arid territory, inherited originally by the Mandatory Government from Turkey. In 1948 it passed to the Government of Israel. These lands had not been owned by Arab farmers—neither under the British Mandate nor under the preceding regime. Thus it is obvious that the contention that 95 per cent of the land—whether of Mandatory Palestine or of the State of Israel—had belonged to Arabs has absolutely no foundation in fact. * * •

There is perhaps no better way of concluding and summing up this study than to quote from an article entitled Is Israel a Thorn or a Flower in the Near East? by Abdul Razak Kader, the Algerian political writer, now living in exile in Paris (Jerusalem Post, Aug. 1, 1969): "The Nationalists of the states neighbouring on Israel, whether they are in the government or in business, whether Palestinian, Syrian or Lebanese, or town dwellers of tribal origin, all know that at the beginning of the century and during the British Mandate the marshy plains and stone hills were sold to the Zionists by their fathers or uncles for gold, the very gold which is often the origin of their own political or commercial careers. The nomadic or seminomadic peasants who inhabited the frontier regions know full well what the green plains, the afforested hills and the flowering fields of today's Israel were like before. "The Palestinians who are today refugees in the neighbouring countries and who were adults at the time of their flight know all this, and no anti-Zionist propaganda—pan-Arab or pan-Moslem— can make them forget that their present nationalist exploiters are the worthy sons of their feudal exploiters of yesterday and that the thorns of their life are of Arab, not Jewish, origin
http://www.wordfromjerusalem.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/the-case-for-israel-appendix2.pdf

You are too funny. You use made up propaganda from Zionist or partisan websites that try to contradict the facts based on scientific surveys undertaken by professionals. Why would the UN lie about who owned the land when it was they that were planning to steal the land from the Muslims and Christians to give it to people living in Europe? Think about it. But the UN map is not alone in defining who owned the land. There is the Survey of Palestine vol. 2, undertaken by the Anglo-American Committee on behalf of the UN in 1946.

A Survey of Palestine Volume 2 | Berman Jewish Policy Archive @ Stanford University

Or, para. 164 of the supplement to the UN partition resolution itself:

UNITED
NATIONS
A

• 
  General Assembly

A/364
3 September 1947
OFFICIAL RECORDS OF THE SECOND SESSION OF
THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY


SUPPLEMENT No. 11



UNITED NATIONS
SPECIAL COMMITTEE
ON PALESTINE



REPORT TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY

VOLUME 1

"164. The Arab population, despite the strenuous efforts of Jews to acquire land in Palestine, at present remains in possession of approximately 85 per cent of the land. "

https://unispal.un.org/DPA/DPR/unispal.nsf/0/07175DE9FA2DE563852568D3006E10F3

 

[montelatici]

You use a lot of words in your attempt to make the Palestinian people invisible but the world and his wife know who they are.

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

Your bizarre claim that Palestinians did not exist before 1948 has been shown to be false by ample posts in this thread.

They do not exist period. But you won't find any Arab or Egyptian calling themselves a Palestinian prior to the 1960's. Go find an Encyclopedia and do your own research.

How about 1922?

"PALESTINE.
CORRESPONDENCE WITH THE PALESTINE ARAB
DELEGATION AND THE ZIONIST ORGANISATION.


"No. 1.
The Palestine Arab Delegation to the Secretary of State for the Colonies.


HOTEL CECIL,
London, W.C.,
February 21st, 1922.
Sir,


Whilst the position in Palestine is, as it stands to-day, with the British Government holding authority by an occupying force, and using that authority to impose upon the people against their wishes a great immigration of alien Jews, many of them of a Bolshevik revolutionary type, no constitution which would fall short of giving the People of Palestine full control of their own affairs could be acceptable.

If the British Government would revise their present policy in Palestine, end the Zionist con-dominium, put a stop to all alien immigration and grant the People of Palestine — who by Right and Experience are the best judges of what is good and bad to their country — Executive and Legislative powers, the terms of a constitution could be discussed in a different atmosphere. If to-day the People of Palestine assented to any constitution which fell short of giving them full control of their own affairs they would be in the position of agreeing to an instrument of Government which might, and probably would, be used to smother their national life under a flood of alien immigration."

UK correspondence with Palestine Arab Delegation and Zionist Organization/British policy in Palestine: "Churchill White Paper" - UK documentation Cmd. 1700/Non-UN document (excerpts) (1 July 1922)

 

[Hollie]

The World has a wife? Who knew? Do tell! Maybe she can tell us who these invisible Palestinian people are who are trying to steal Israeli land!

The state of Israel is deeply compromised in its claim to legitimacy. Zionists might have overcome their inherent perfidious nature in world regard but for the half century of occupation and attempt to render the indigenous Palestinian people invisible.

There is only one explanation for not being visible in a single photo prior to 1948 when Israel became restored as a Nation. They never existed. They are a fabrication, a lie concocted in the 60's, you've got ample evidence to prove this right on this very thread. Just open your eyes and read, Elroy. This isn't difficult. The truth is self-evident. It just isn't convenient for you or your friends.

The truth is these people who claim to be "Palestinians" are actually Egyptians and Arabs and the sooner they return back to their own lands the better it will be for everyone. Pass the word....

Your bizarre claim that Palestinians did not exist before 1948 has been shown to be false by ample posts in this thread.

They do not exist period. But you won't find any Arab or Egyptian calling themselves a Palestinian prior to the 1960's. Go find an Encyclopedia and do your own research.

How about 1922?

"PALESTINE.
CORRESPONDENCE WITH THE PALESTINE ARAB
DELEGATION AND THE ZIONIST ORGANISATION.


"No. 1.
The Palestine Arab Delegation to the Secretary of State for the Colonies.


HOTEL CECIL,
London, W.C.,
February 21st, 1922.
Sir,


Whilst the position in Palestine is, as it stands to-day, with the British Government holding authority by an occupying force, and using that authority to impose upon the people against their wishes a great immigration of alien Jews, many of them of a Bolshevik revolutionary type, no constitution which would fall short of giving the People of Palestine full control of their own affairs could be acceptable.

If the British Government would revise their present policy in Palestine, end the Zionist con-dominium, put a stop to all alien immigration and grant the People of Palestine — who by Right and Experience are the best judges of what is good and bad to their country — Executive and Legislative powers, the terms of a constitution could be discussed in a different atmosphere. If to-day the People of Palestine assented to any constitution which fell short of giving them full control of their own affairs they would be in the position of agreeing to an instrument of Government which might, and probably would, be used to smother their national life under a flood of alien immigration."

UK correspondence with Palestine Arab Delegation and Zionist Organization/British policy in Palestine: "Churchill White Paper" - UK documentation Cmd. 1700/Non-UN document (excerpts) (1 July 1922)

How about the Ottoman land records?

Turkey transfers Ottoman land records to Palestinian Authority


Cutting and pasting the same map when you're befuddled about the history of the area is really pretty silly. As we know from the official Ottoman records, the former majority landowners of the area called Pal'istan were in fact absentee landowners from Egypt, Syria and Lebanon.

From the official Ottoman land records:
Turkey transfers Ottoman land records to Palestinian Authority

Even before 1917, Jewish and Zionist institutions had purchased large tracts of land in Palestine from absentee landlords, who lived mainly in Syria and Lebanon. These landlords had previously leased their property to local farmers, but were happy to sell it for the right price, without giving a thought to their tenant farmers. Nevertheless, Palestinians view these sales as more legitimate than those that took place during the British occupation that began in 1917.

Under Ottoman rule, a substantial portion of the land in Palestine was registered as state land. Some of this land was later sold or transferred to pre-state Jewish institutions. Other portions belonged to the Muslim waqf (religious trust), and these, according to Islamic law, cannot be sold. However, there was no orderly registration process; ownership was determined primarily using records such as tax payments.