With good looks, I can assume I would be able to marry someone rich. That isn't exactly a benefit, it is just life. Looks matter.
On the wealth option, I guess it would depend on how bad my health was. IE the amount of time I have left.
I don't think health is a good one. If you are broke and look like shit, you will probably be lonely. Unless you find the same in a partner. Sounds like a shitty way to spend life. lol
Like you I'd go with looks.
You can be happy with things you gain from your looks.
Health is great if everything else is going well.....
I think also, looks are more important for women....
HOWEVER, people live being unattractive and, I am sure are probably happier than I am