When was America Great

[Sherlock Holmes]

I'd like an answer to this, at what time in history was America "great" in the sense the MAGATS want to return to that? Is there an approx date? is there a specific previous administration that fits the description?

 

[Missourian]

When we saved your whole ******* continent.

You're welcome.

 

[EMH]

In the 1990s we cut taxes and spending, the economy boomed, low end wages rose, and the Republican Party was pro America and conservative.

Then came W and Faux News and the "Pro Israel Christian" and America has gone off a cliff ever since...

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

When we saved your whole ******* continent.

You mean during WW2? after or before Pearl Harbor? so losing half a million men was when we were "great"? you mean we need wars again?

You're welcome.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

In the 1990s we cut taxes and spending, the economy boomed, low end wages rose, and the Republican Party was pro America and conservative.

Then came W and Faux News and the "Pro Israel Christian" and America has gone off a cliff ever since...

I watched NEWSMAX for the first time last night to see what the MAGATS watch and my God, the idiocy I saw there was astonishing.

 

[Mr. Friscus]

You mean during WW2? after or before Pearl Harbor? so losing half a million men was when we were "great"? you mean we need wars again?

The sacrifice was great, for a just cause.

I don’t think you’re seeking out an honest convo. You’re already blaming America for participating in WW2 and saying its a bad thing… and suggesting all wars are wars with no consideration for which wars and for what reasons.

You don’t appear to be genuinely curious. I think you are bitter at Trump and America, and are just trolling for a fight

 

[Dogmaphobe]

I'd like an answer to this, at what time in history was America "great" in the sense the MAGATS want to return to that? Is there an approx date? is there a specific previous administration that fits the description?

When did you move here from the Islamic Hell hole that spawned you?

It was before that.

 

[Mr. Friscus]

I watched NEWSMAX for the first time last night to see what the MAGATS watch and my God, the idiocy I saw there was astonishing.

I can’t speak for Newsmax, but I get that feeling if I ever come across MSNBC, CNN, ABC, NBC, CBS, The View, etc.

Absolutely crazed people.

But they are mainstream, Newsmax is not

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

The sacrifice was great, for a just cause.

I don’t think you’re seeking out an honest convo.

That's your call, my question is in the thread title and seems entirely reasonable.

You’re already blaming America for participating in WW2 and saying its
A bad thing… and suggesting all wars are wars with no consideration for which was and for what reasons.

Which statement of mine gave you that impression?

You don’t appear to be genuinely curious.

And you don't appear to have an answer as to when was America great as alluded to by MAGA.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

When did you move here from the Islamic Hell hole that spawned you?

It was before that.

Right, that's another "I don't know" I believe, I wonder why this is such a hard question....

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

This is odd, no clear answer yet to what I expected to be a simple, non controversial question...

 

[Maxdeath]

I get it you were never enthused with the U.S. You never felt it was good or great.
So let’s ask you a question. Since you never felt that America was such a great country what do you feel needs to happen for it to become great?
Should we stop all exploration of space? Print more money so we can pay off student loans? Open the borders and allow anyone in? Should we spend more on things like studying the mating habits of the Brazilian tree frog? Maybe you feel we should become a city state of China?
Inquiring minds want to know

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

I get it you were never enthused with the U.S. You never felt it was good or great.
So let’s ask you a question. Since you never felt that America was such a great country what do you feel needs to happen for it to become great?
Should we stop all exploration of space? Print more money so we can pay off student loans? Open the borders and allow anyone in? Should we spend more on things like studying the mating habits of the Brazilian tree frog? Maybe you feel we should become a city state of China?
Inquiring minds want to know

So no answer from you, how odd that a simple question is eluding the very people who want great "again" but have no idea when that was.

 

[Arlette]

I'd like an answer to this, at what time in history was America "great" in the sense the MAGATS want to return to that? Is there an approx date? is there a specific previous administration that fits the description?

The 1950s, Mayberry

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

The 1950s, Mayberry

OK that's getting somewhere the 1950s, but what is "Mayberry"?

 

[E. Pluribus]

Make America Great Again was Trump's slogan during his first election campaign which referred to the previous Democrat presidencies which were not so great.

 

[JGalt]

I'd like an answer to this, at what time in history was America "great" in the sense the MAGATS want to return to that? Is there an approx date? is there a specific previous administration that fits the description?

Tuesday, November 5, 2024. Greatest time in American history.

So suck it, commie loser.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

Tuesday, November 5, 2024. Greatest time in American history.

So suck it, commie loser.

Translation: "I don't know Mr. Holmes".

 

[JGalt]

Translation: "I don't know Mr. Holmes".

So you don't think the reelection of Donald J. Trump made America great again?

The majority of Americans disagreed with you.

 

[Sherlock Holmes]

So you don't think the reelection of Donald J. Trump made America great again.

The majority of Americans disagreed with you.

With all due respect, the term "again" means a prior time, prior to 2016, prior to Trump, I'm just asking when that was, not a hard question - unless of course Trump (and you) has no idea what he's talking about.