Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
I would like to think that I would be inclined to cut the guy a break, but what if he drives drunk next week and kills someone. Arresting him at this point could be a way of keeping a drunk driver off the road. Per the video, it's that person 2nd DUI offense.Well it was close. Some cops would have cut him some slack while others may not. He could have gave him a ride home or call a taxi for the guy.
Since the cops had time to arrive per a call, it seems the guy didn't drive off immediately. Thus he may have had the engine running for heating the car. This happen per the vid Jan 1st.It seems to me that it would be valid for the law to consider anyone who is at the controls of a vehicle, while the vehicle's engine is running, to be “driving” that vehicle, even if the vehicle has not actually in motion. Surely, you are considered to be driving, if you are stopped at a stop light.
On the other hand, it could be a valid defense that the engine is running only because the occupant wants heat or A/C, and the occupant could claim to have had no intention of actually causing the vehicle to move.
He was in the parking lot outside a bar.If he was not on a public roadway they cannot legally charge him. Note that unless there is personal injury the police cannot charge someone with accidently damaging another vehicle on private property.
Cops are called about an intoxicated man who went out from a bar to his car. I presume the caller believes the man is going to drive. drunk. The police arrive to find the man sitting behind the wheel of the car with the engine running, but the car has not moved, legally parked. Should the police arrest him for DUI at this point?
That is my understanding as well. That said, should the cops wait for him to actually start the car moving before arresting him?I believe that even when the car is started and the engine running that it can be considered operating a vehicle. It does not necessary have to be moving.
Cops are called about an intoxicated man who went out from a bar to his car. I presume the caller believes the man is going to drive. drunk. The police arrive to find the man sitting behind the wheel of the car with the engine running, but the car has not moved, legally parked. Should the police arrest him for DUI at this point?
Did you ever cite such a person on private property?Yes. The legal definition, when I was an officer, included "standing", which was the operation of a motor vehicle not in motion. Ever seen those signs in front of those stores saying "no standing"? That doesn't mean everyone fall down.
It means "no sitting there in park, while tbe vehicle is running, waiting for your passenger". And in some places it is an offense. And without question it is an incontrovertible operation of a motor vehicle. Moving, or not.
Yes.Did you ever cite such a person on private property?
I don't ever recall seeing a "No Standing" sign outside a store. I have seen signs outside a store stating that the parking was for that store only usually with a warning that unattended cars may be towed.Yes. The legal definition, when I was an officer, included "standing", which was the operation of a motor vehicle not in motion. Ever seen those signs in front of those stores saying "no standing"? That doesn't mean everyone fall down.
It means "no sitting there in park, while tbe vehicle is running, waiting for your passenger". And in some places it is an offense. And without question it is an incontrovertible operation of a motor vehicle. Moving, or not.
I don't ever recall seeing a "No Standing" sign outside a store. I have seen signs outside a store stating that the parking was for that store only usually with a warning that unattended cars may be towed.
I wouldn't think a running vehicle with the driver waiting on a passenger who is a customer would be a problem.
They are typically positioned at points of ingress, and egress. Their purpose isn't to frustrate, or annoy the public. They are meant to facilitate the service of the public should emergency responders need access to the business.
I have never seen such a sign either. Must be a regional thing.
Cops are called about an intoxicated man who went out from a bar to his car. I presume the caller believes the man is going to drive. drunk. The police arrive to find the man sitting behind the wheel of the car with the engine running, but the car has not moved, legally parked. Should the police arrest him for DUI at this point?
Could be. But just be clear... I didn't ticket some guy for pulling up to the door, so his wife could load tbe groceries while it was raining cats, and dogs. This kid was a fucking punk, bumping his favorite "jam" six feet from the entrance of the business that called in the disturbance. He was initially uncooperative with the command to move, and find a parking space. Apparantly... He didn't know what "standing" meant legally either. $150 later... He figured it outI have never seen such a sign either. Must be a regional thing.
