My question is, shouldnt these investment firms have been able to see what was going on, and protected their investors from the major downturn we are seeing by selling out of those positions while they were on a high, waited for the market to bottom out, then buy back in when the market was low? Or does the whole thing not work like that? Are those types of investments just a long haul investment that you just ride out both the highs as well as the lows, looking for greater returns over time?
My FA would always say the latter. That said, we did do some rebalancing just today when I needed to take an RMD. Thing is, yes you sell high/buy low, but no one knows when that is until that peak/trough has turned the other way. Right now it's doing massive swings, sometimes it compensates quickly but then dives quickly again. Besides which it costs you broker fees every time you buy OR sell so your take has to pay for that first.
Btw the final score today was down 2000 points.
Biggest single-day drop since 2008 and biggest ever in terms of absolute points.
I agree, and my FA also basically says they dont make adjustments on market volatility. They just ride then out.....which to me sounds silly. In this case, they had indicators early that something was going to happen. They could see that people were spooked by co-vid, and even places like Italy weren seeing people running to the stores and buying everything available.
This was over 2 weeks ago. The market has taken a few heavy hits since that time. One would think with the indicators, and the first heavy nose dive, that financial managers would have been looking to help their investors conserve. However, from what I can tell, I guess they just plan to ride it out, even if it goes to rock bottom, I guess we are just in it for the duration. Even if millions of people lose their entire nest egg, I guess these big financial firms dont really care, they'll let your investment tank until there is nothing left I suppose.
This led me to another train of thought. I cant imagine those people who's portfolios are worth millions are taking these losses. They would be firing financial managers left and right if they were. Something tells me those who's portfolios are "important" probably have been cashed out a few weeks ago, and they are just waiting until the storm blows over until they buy back in.
Now dont get me wrong, in not harping on rich people, on the contrary, they made their money, and good for them. What I'm harping on is the fact that these investment firms really dont " manage" accounts unless they are worth their time and they can make big commissions off of them. I could be wrong, but I just cant see the "big fish" allowing their investments to take a beating.
Also, as far as trade fees, I'm not sure how all that works. I have a managed account that I pay a percentage of my total account balance each year, so, I'm assuming I wouldnt pay any transaction fees if they were to have liquidated my assets to protect my investment, after all, isnt that what they are there for?