1950s were great if you were white, male and Christian
America was FOUNDED by white, male Christians! White Christians were the majority of the nation. So you agree that the 1950s was great for the majority of people. Then someone said: Let's make it great for the rest of the people, the Blacks, the Women, the minorities and Gays. But have we succeeded in that goal? If it is better for the Blacks, why are they more unhappy now than ever? If it is better for the women then why all the #MeToo lawsuits? If it is better for the minorities and Gays, then why all the unrest, lawsuits and protests? It has gotten somewhat better for some of these groups, BUT AT THE EXPENSE OF WHITE CHRISTIANS. So if the majority of people feel they are worse off, then the net gain for making it a little better for some minority groups is a STEP BACK. It is no gain for all if the majority must suffer so that a few can get ahead. If the present was really a better time, then it would truly be better for ALL, and no group has it "great" as it once was in the 1950s. Except the very rich.
When we make the Middle Class and America great again as it was in the 1950s for ALL people across the board, then you can tell me that we have actually "progressed." And perhaps that is the best explanation of the promise made by Trump: to make America great again for the Middle Class and for the Middle Class to enclose a wider diversity of people. Now whether or not Trump can really do that, especially with all the opposition, is another matter. But the question of whether the 1950s was great is moot-- -- -- it WAS. It just wasn't great for EVERYONE. The goal was to KEEP it that great and for more people; I submit that today we have FAILED in that goal to keep it that great for ANYONE, white, black, gay, anyone. The liberal agenda has failed because it sought to make America better for a few minority groups, but AT THE EXPENSE of the majority.