The Temple Mount -- the differences between Israeli (Western) and Palestinian (Muslim) Discourse

[Sixties Fan]

There were no Muslims until hundreds of years after the temple was destroyed. Look it up, I can't cut and paste from my tablet.

This non discussion is over.

 

[rylah]

The Arabs call it Al Quds, stupid.

Arabs also still call Spain "al Andalus",
and how it's been going so far?

Get real, the world changes.

 

[surada]

Arabs still call Spain al Andalus,

how it's been going so far?

It doesn't seem to be a problem. Do you want it to be a problem?

 

[ESay]

The questions for this thread:

1. What can Israel do (if anything) to shift the perception of the Palestinian/Muslim narrative?

2. If it can not be shifted, how should Israel proceed?

What do you mean saying about Muslim narrative? That Jerusalem is a holy place for them and the mosque should stay there forever?

 

[Sixties Fan]

This non discussion is over.

Surada,

Funny is your endless attempts at turning the topic of any thread into what you want it to be.

 

[Sixties Fan]

What do you mean saying about Muslim narrative? That Jerusalem is a holy place for them and the mosque should stay there forever?

Read the first post

 

[ESay]

Read the first post

Thanks, I have read this. And I have a question - does a concern of some Muslims about possible removal of the Al Aqsa mosque have a real basis or is it greatly overplayed?

 

[surada]

Thanks, I have read this. And I have a question - does a concern of some Muslims about possible removal of the Al Aqsa mosque have a real basis or is it greatly overplayed?

The mosque is to celebrate the God of Abraham and it's been there 1300 years.

 

[Roudy]

Al Quds meant "farthest mosque" not Jerusalem.

Qur'an talks about Al Aqsa Mosque to describe Muhammad's night journey but Al Aqsa (Farthest) Mosque was built 60 years after the death of the prophet.

In other words…There was no mosque in Jerusalem at the time of the death of Mohammad.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Thanks, I have read this. And I have a question - does a concern of some Muslims about possible removal of the Al Aqsa mosque have a real basis or is it greatly overplayed?

Beyond overplayed.
The Palestinian leaders are using the idea of Jews wanting to build the third Temple in order to put fear in the Muslim minds that the Al Aqsa is going to be destroyed.

Of course, their idea of what Al Aqsa is has turned into the WHOLE Temple Mount.

Al Aqsa is but a Mosque on the Temple Mount which the Muslims constantly desecrate by wearing shoes, hiding weapons and attacking Jews from whenever they are provoked, incited to do so.

 

[Roudy]

The mosque is to celebrate the God of Abraham and it's been there 1300 years.

Islam did not exist then. Minor problem.

 

[Sixties Fan]

The mosque is to celebrate the God of Abraham and it's been there 1300 years.

Allah is not the G-D of Abraham.

Go educate yourself.

 

[surada]

Islam and Abraham did not exist then. Minor problem.

You're confusing Arabs with Muslims. Arabs have been in Palestine and the Levant since Abraham.

 

[surada]

Allah is not the G-D of Abraham.

Go educate yourself.

Of course he is.

 

[surada]

Beyond overplayed.
The Palestinian leaders are using the idea of Jews wanting to build the third Temple in order to put fear in the Muslim minds that the Al Aqsa is going to be destroyed.

Of course, their idea of what Al Aqsa is has turned into the WHOLE Temple Mount.

Al Aqsa is but a Mosque on the Temple Mount which the Muslims constantly desecrate by wearing shoes, hiding weapons and attacking Jews from whenever they are provoked, incited to do so.

Emperor Justinian tried to rebuild the third temple about 300 AD, but it was felled by fire and earthquakes.

 

[surada]

Qur'an talks about Al Aqsa Mosque to describe Muhammad's night journey but Al Aqsa (Farthest) Mosque was built 60 years after the death of the prophet.

In other words…There was no mosque in Jerusalem at the time of the death of Mohammad.

There was no temple either.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Of course he is.

If Allah is the G-D of Abraham, then so is Jesus.

 

[Sixties Fan]

There was no temple either.

There were two Temples before Islam was ever created because Christians wanted to spread the "word" in Arabia.

Rewrite history all you like.

 

[Sixties Fan]

Emperor Justinian tried to rebuild the third temple about 300 AD, but it was felled by fire and earthquakes.

Still not discussing the Thread's two questions.

We do never need to wonder why

 

[surada]

There were two Temples before Islam was ever created because Christians wanted to spread the "word" in Arabia.

Rewrite history all you like.

What two temples are you talking about?