Well if the GOP can make the issue about individual workers keeping the extra 50-200 bucks per month, it probably works for them. The GOP added over two trillion to the debt with the tax cuts. That's why they are not very popular. But most people will think that their relatively small increase in take home pay is not really the cause for most of that, and they're right.
If the Dem can make the issue about workers keeping their cuts while clawing back part of the rest to pay for soc sec of medicare, it probably works for them.