Yup. The Germans themselves wanted to surrender to the Western Allies. They would have handed over everyone we wanted, they just wanted to be able to continue the war against the Soviets, and this was offered in the middle of 1944.
By the end of the war, the Soviets had been bled dry. They no longer had the huge advantage in people they had enjoyed at the beginning of the war. Had the US gone to war with them, with German help. I have no doubt we would have won. It would however certainly have been a very bloody affair.
The Soviet tanks were far better than ours. No question. They weren't as good as the Panther, but they were orders of magnitude better than ours. Even the Pershing was no match for a JSU-152 or JS-2. But, our air power would absolutely have ruled the sky's after about three to four months.
That would negate the Soviet advantage in artillery and in men. We were a fully mobile army, they weren't. They were only as mobile as they were because we gave them 600,000 trucks through lend lease. The US gave the Soviets millions of tons of munitions, food, weapons, and medicine. Had that been taken away the Soviet armies would have collapsed after a few months of combat.
The problem would have been in administering that huge area. We can't control Iraq, there is no way we could have controlled the vastly larger Soviet Union. We would still have troops there, and we would still be actively fighting partisans to this day had we attacked.
By 1944, the Soviets were kicking their asses. Of course Germans wanted an out. Did they really think they could get off the hook with the soviets after what they had done?
As early as 1939, the head of the Abwehr, Wm. Canaris, was attempting to contact the Brits.
Later, Stalin demanded that no surrender be allowed...he demanded that Germany be crushed....of course, Roosevelt hopped right to it...the Morgenthau Plan.
War could have been over years earlier.
In 1940s America, I doubt you would have found anyone willing to let the Nazi regime survive
After what the Nazis did to the Soviets, Stalin would not rest until the Germans were crushed.
Hitler passed the point of no return and then some. There was no way anyone was going to offer any terms lighter than unconditional surrender
As a side note
Imagine how many FDR hate threads we would get out of PC if he had let HITLER off the hook
1. "In 1940s America, I doubt you would have found anyone willing to let the Nazi regime survive..."
Jeeezzzzz....you're more out of Left field than Brett Gardner.
I challenge you....get both brain cells goin'.....find anyone in the thread who suggested letting the Nazi regime surviving.
Double dog dare ya'...
2. "After what the Nazis did to the Soviets, Stalin would not rest until the Germans were crushed."
Said by someone with zero understanding of Stalin.
He wanted world communism.
Therefore, any thing or anyone who might impede communism's march across Europe had to be crushed.
That was his reason for having his spies advance the Morganthau Plan.
Harry Dexter White had been a Soviet "asset"since the early 1930s, providing information to Whittaker Chambers, a courier for the communist underground. By 1941 White was
a top aide and adviser to Henry Morgenthau, Jr.,Secretary of the Treasury.
This was Stalin's leverage.
White had Morganthau agree to Stalin's plan for Germany.
Stalin and his spies in the Roosevelt administration insisted...
.demanded!.....that Germany
not be allowed to surrender. It had to be obliterated....
....even though this meant extending the war and
dramatically increasing Allies casualties.
"There was no way anyone was going to offer any terms lighter than unconditional surrender"
Correct....because those were Stalin's orders to Roosevelt....no matter how many American lives it cost.
3. "Imagine how many FDR hate threads we would get out of PC if he had let HITLER off the hook."
First of all....this is in no was a 'hate FDR" thread.
It is a "hate ignorance" thread.
Everything I post is true, researched, documented.
You are the one who hates.....because you can't stand FDR's love affair with Stalin being revealed.
And again....no one has suggested letting "HITLER off the hook."